“Torch,” said Amy.
Leo was already holding one. Leo was always holding one. He pulled it out of his pocket like a magician pulling out a rabbit, and switched it on.
They moved the bundle of red velvet aside, slowly, the way you move a bedroom curtain when someone is asleep. And Leo shone the torch inside.
It was a gap. Narrow, very narrow, as wide as a hand, between the right side of the stage and the wall. And it was deep. As deep as the stage itself, right down to the floor. And at the bottom, in the torchlight, something glinted.
Something silver. With one handle sticking up, like an ear. And a ribbon.
“The cup!” shouted Hutie, so loudly that Falafel jumped in the air outside the window.
“The cup,” whispered Leo, and the torch trembled in his hand. “It wasn’t stolen. It fell.”
Within a minute, the whole of Hilltop House was standing round the stage. Benny and Omer, Alice and Penny, Tom and Maya, and Oliver with his banner folded under his arm. Everyone pushed, everyone wanted a peek, and everyone talked at once, until Amy raised her hand. And everyone went quiet.
“Here’s what happened,” said Amy. She opened her notebook and pointed at the stage, like a teacher at a whiteboard.
“Last night the cup was standing at the edge of the stage. Right at the edge. In the middle. Noam drew the curtain with one big pull, from right to left. Whoosh.” She swept her arm. “Sewn into the bottom of the curtain, like every theatre curtain, there are weights. So it hangs nice and straight. I saw them this morning. The weights hit the cup, and it fell over on its side. That’s the shadow Tom saw.”
Tom nodded, proud and relieved. He hadn’t seen a ghost. He’d seen a cup.
“And in the morning,” Amy went on, “Mrs. Cohen opened the curtain. One strong pull to the right. And the weights at the bottom dragged the cup along with them, lying on its side. Along the edge. To the right.” She pointed at the scratch. “That’s the scratch. It goes to the right because the cup was dragged to the right. All the way to the end. And there, at the end, was the gap. The cup fell in. And the curtain bunched up over it and hid it. Exactly as Tom said.” She smiled at him. “The curtain ate it.”
“So nobody stole it,” said Omer slowly, as if he needed to hear it out loud to believe it.
“Nobody stole it,” said Amy. “The thief is a curtain.”
Benny said nothing. He was looking at the gap, and his face was red. But not with anger.
“Right,” said Penny. “Let’s get it out, then.”
That turned out to be harder than it sounds.
Omer tried first. He lay down on the stage and pushed his arm into the gap, right up to the shoulder. His arm stopped halfway. “A bit more,” he grunted. “A bit more…” And then: “I’m stuck.”
It took Alice and Penny two minutes and three contradictory pieces of advice to free him.
Benny tried second, because his arms were longer. He got further. He got nearly there. His fingertips touched the ribbon, pushed it, and the cup slid a little further down into the corner. “Oops,” said Benny. “Now it’s even further away.”
David brought a broom. The broom was too fat. David brought a mop handle. The handle went in, but it had nothing to grip with. Zehava brought a long ladle, her very longest, saying, “I’m not giving up the Queen, so this is the second best.” The ladle reached the cup and knocked on it, ding, and that was all.
“We need something that can catch the handle,” said Leo. “Something thin and long that can bend.”
Everybody turned, at the same moment, towards the same girl.
Hutie was already sitting on the stage with her red string, unwinding it from her pocket, metre after metre. “The fisherman’s knot,” she said without looking up, her fingers flying. “A loop that closes when you pull. But only when you pull. So it can’t escape.”
She tied a loop at the end of the string and, inside the loop, for weight, she tied Leo’s rubber. “You’ll get it back,” she promised Leo, who looked worried. Then she lay on her tummy beside the gap and lowered the string inside, slowly, slowly.
“Leo, light. Amy, tell me what you see.”
Amy pressed her eye to the gap. “Left. More. A bit more. Stop. Now down.”
Hutie pulled. Something caught. Everyone held their breath. She raised the string, slowly, centimetre by centimetre.
It was a sock. One green sock, very dusty.
“That’s mine!” shouted Omer. “I’ve been looking for it for a year!”
Hutie lowered the string again. This time she brought up a ping-pong ball. Then a butterfly hairclip, and Penny shrieked, “My clip! From Year Two!” Then a green pencil, then a folded note nobody dared to open, then a pink whoopee cushion that made, when Hutie squeezed it by accident, a very, very rude noise.
The whole hall exploded with laughter. And Oliver, with the most innocent face in the world, held out his hand. “That,” he said, “I’ll take. It’s… scientific research.”
“This gap,” said Leo, fascinated, “is like Kuku’s palace. Only for things.”
“Five minutes to noon,” announced Oliver, holding Leo’s watch, in a football commentator’s voice. “Four minutes and fifty-nine seconds. Four minutes and fifty-eight…”
“Oliver,” said Hutie, Amy and Leo together.
“Silent,” said Oliver. And was silent for exactly three seconds. “But now it’s four-fifty.”
Far away, from Ruti’s office, they heard the phone ring once, then stop.
At five to twelve, Hutie lowered the string for the ninth time. The loop went down, down, and stopped. Amy saw it touch the handle. “Now,” she whispered. “Just close it.”
Hutie pulled, gently, gently. The loop tightened round the handle. And the red string went taut.
“It’s heavy,” said Hutie through her teeth. “It’s heavy!”
Benny lay down beside her and took hold of the string too, behind her hands, without pulling too hard. They pulled together. And the cup rose. It caught on the wall for a moment, clinked, then rose again. The handle appeared, then the ribbon, then the whole cup, dusty, with cobwebs on one side, but in one piece.
Noam, standing to one side, rubbed his face. “I closed the curtain,” he said. “Me. With my big whoosh. Like in the theatre.” He sighed. “From now on, I close curtains slowly. Like in a library.”
Leo hugged the cup, dust, cobwebs and all, and didn’t mind in the least. David bent down, looked closely at the cobwebs, then at his cap, where Morris sat. “Not his,” he announced seriously. “Morris doesn’t work in dark places. He likes a view.”
At twelve o’clock exactly, Ruti walked into the hall with the phone in her hand. She saw the cup, and Hutie, and Benny, and Oliver with the pink cushion. And she lowered the phone.
“Well,” she said. “Then I don’t need to ring.”
“Yes, you do,” said Benny.
Everyone looked at him.
He got up off the floor, brushed the dust off his shirt and took a deep breath. “I said Gali stole it,” he said. “In front of everyone. Out loud. She didn’t hear, but I said it.” He looked at Amy. “That counts, doesn’t it? Even if she didn’t hear?”
“It counts,” said Amy quietly.
“Then I want to talk to her,” said Benny. “Me. Not you. Me.”
Ruti dialled and handed him the phone. And the whole of Hilltop House sat on the chairs in the hall, pretending not to listen, and listened.
“Gali? It’s Benny. From Hilltop House. The one who lifted Leo onto his shoulders.” Silence. “Yes. So… the cup vanished this morning. And I… I said you took it.” A long silence. Benny went red from his neck to his ears. “No, not to you. I said it to everyone. But it wasn’t true. It fell behind the curtain. A curtain ate it. Long story.” He swallowed. “So, sorry. That’s it. Sorry.”
Then he listened for a long time. And his face changed. From red, to surprise, to a small smile.
When he hung up, everyone asked at once: “What did she say?”
“She said she stood by the curtain all evening,” said Benny, “because she saw the cup was too close to the edge. And she wanted to say so. But she didn’t, because she thought losers don’t give advice.” He put the phone down. “And she said she isn’t angry. And that it’s the first apology she’s ever had from Hilltop House. In ten years.”
“And what else?” asked Penny.
“She suggested a rematch,” said Benny. “And I suggested a picnic.”
And so, the following Friday, both houses met on the hill behind the house, with blankets, question-mark biscuits and Zehava’s lemonade. They had a rematch, but this time in mixed teams: two from Hilltop House and two from Oak House in each. Gali and Leo were on the same team, answered every animal question together, and argued for ten minutes about whether spiders are cleverer than octopuses. Benny and Omer played football with the counselor with the moustache, who turned out to be an excellent goalkeeper. And Sugar ate half of Oak House’s biscuits, and everyone laughed, because they don’t have a pony.
After the quiz, Gali sat down next to Amy at the edge of the blanket with a cup of lemonade. They were quiet for a moment, like two detectives checking each other out.
“How did you know?” Gali asked at last. “That it wasn’t me?”
“I didn’t,” said Amy. “That’s why I didn’t say anything. I saw you get on the minibus empty-handed. But that isn’t proof. So we measured.”
Gali smiled and took a small blue exercise book out of her bag, full of dates in tiny handwriting. “I write down every date in the world,” she said. “You write down every clue.” She looked at Amy’s notebook with its embroidered magnifying glass. “Maybe next year we’ll do a quiz on detectives.”
“Only if there’s a question about spiders,” said Amy. And Gali laughed, for the first time, a real laugh, head thrown back.
By the end of the day, nobody remembered who had won the quiz. Not even Leo, who remembers everything. And the silver cup stood all day in the middle of the big blanket, very far from any edge.
On Sunday, David screwed a wooden board over the gap beside the stage and closed it. “Thirty centimetres,” he said, with a nod to Leo. “Thirty years I’ve been here and never noticed. Until someone came along with a tape measure.” Leo got his rubber back. Omer got his sock. Penny got her clip. And the folded note? Nobody knew whose it was, so it stayed with Amy, inside her notebook, for another case, another day.
That evening, Amy wrote:
Case Number 17: The Missing Trophy. Solved. Who: a curtain (with weights). How: Noam closed it, Mrs. Cohen opened it, and the gap swallowed it. What I learned: sometimes the thief isn’t anyone at all. And before you blame someone, measure. Benny learned something too: saying “sorry” is a kind of winning.
She closed her notebook and heard Leo, from the boys’ wing at the end of the corridor, mumbling “Saturn, Uranus, Neptune” out of habit.
And she didn’t yet know that in the morning, when Omer was first in the boys’ shower and the steam covered the mirror, letters would appear on it. Real letters, from a real alphabet. But in a completely different order. And nobody, not even Leo, would understand what they said.