Amy the little detective with a magnifying glass and her friends in the yard

Amy the Detective, Chapter 33: The Missing Trophy

For ten years in a row, Oak House had won the quiz.

For ten years in a row, Oak House had won the quiz.

Every year, at the start of summer, the two houses met. Once at theirs, once at ours. Four children from each house went up on stage, sat behind a long table and answered questions. About science, history, animals, sport and “a bit of everything”. And the winning house took home the cup. A tall silver cup with two handles like ears and a silver ribbon tied to one of them. For ten years that cup had stood on a shelf at Oak House, and never moved.

“This year,” said Penny at supper, banging the table, “the cup is ours.”

“This year the cup is ours,” repeated Alice, banging harder.

“This year we’ve got Leo,” said Benny, putting a hand on Leo’s shoulder like a coach with his star player. And Leo, who was chewing, choked a little.

The Hilltop House team was: Alice and Penny, the captains, because nobody dared tell them no. Benny, for the sport questions. And Leo, for everything else. And Amy? Amy didn’t want to go on stage. She preferred to sit in the front row with her notebook and see everything. “A detective doesn’t need to answer questions,” she said. “A detective needs to ask them.”

For three weeks Leo trained. He read the encyclopaedia under the blanket by torchlight. He asked Noam to quiz him at breakfast, lunch and supper. He learned every capital city in Europe, all the planets, and the names of all the bones in the hand. At night, Omer said, he mumbled “Saturn, Uranus, Neptune” in his sleep.

And on quiz night, the hall at Hilltop House was packed to the walls.

The hall was a long room with rows of chairs and a wooden stage at the end, as high as the dining-hall tables, with a heavy red velvet curtain that drew across from side to side. Shira hung strings of tiny lights. Zehava made biscuits shaped like question marks. And Oliver made a huge orange banner that said: Hilltop House – This Time It’s Personal!

At half past six, the Oak House minibus arrived. Out climbed twelve children, a counselor with a moustache, and a team of four. At the head of the team walked a tall girl with a tight ponytail and glasses, called Gali. She was carrying the silver cup in both hands, because that’s what you do: the cup travels with the winners. She passed Amy, looked at the orange banner and gave a small, confident smile. “See you next year,” she said. “At ours.”

“She’s annoying,” whispered Hutie.

“She’s confident,” said Amy, writing in her notebook: Gali – Oak House captain. Holds the cup the way you hold a baby.

Mrs. Cohen ceremoniously took the cup from Gali and placed it on the stage, right at the front edge, in the middle, so everyone could see. There it stood, gleaming in the fairy lights, with the two teams sitting behind it at either end of the long table.

And the quiz began.

It was the most nail-biting quiz Hilltop House had seen. Oak House led after the first round, history, because Gali knew every date in the world. Hilltop House drew level in the second round, sport, because Benny knew who had scored in every final since he was born. In the third round, animals, Leo answered six questions in a row, including “What do hedgehogs eat?”, adding, “And snails, and sometimes carrots, but only by accident,” at which the whole of Hilltop House exploded with laughter and applause, and Oak House didn’t understand why. In the fourth round, science, Gali answered the hardest question, about electricity, and Oak House went back into the lead by one point.

Then came the last question. The golden question. Whoever answered it would win.

The counselor with the moustache, who was also the judge, unfolded a slip and read slowly: “How many legs does a spider have?”

Gali hit the buzzer first. “Six,” she said quickly.

“Incorrect,” said the judge.

The whole hall held its breath. Leo pressed the buzzer. His hand was shaking.

“Eight,” he said. And after a moment he added quietly, “Insects have six. Spiders have eight. Spiders aren’t insects.” He looked at the back row, where David sat with Morris the spider on his cap. “Also, Morris has eight. I checked. Twice.”

“Correct!” shouted the judge.

And the hall exploded.

Oliver leapt onto his chair waving his banner. Alice and Penny hugged Leo from both sides so hard his glasses flew off. Benny lifted him onto his shoulders. Zehava shouted “I knew it!” with the Queen in her hand, although nobody had asked her anything. Tom and Maya danced in the aisle. And David took Morris off his cap and raised him in the air, like a tiny cup with eight legs.

Mrs. Cohen went up on stage, lifted the silver cup and presented it to Leo. And Leo, with his glasses crooked on his nose, raised the cup above his head. The hall cheered so loudly that Kuku crowed from the coop, with no bell, for the second time that month.

Only Amy, in the front row, saw Gali. She was standing at the side of the stage by the curtain, arms by her sides, eyes too shiny. And for a moment she didn’t look like a captain. She looked like an eleven-year-old girl who had lost.

Then there was a party. With Zehava’s biscuits, juice and music from Shira’s guitar. The cup was put back on the stage, at the front edge, in the middle, “so everyone can have their photo taken with it,” said Mrs. Cohen. And everyone did. Even Sugar, through the window, managed to get his nose into one picture.

At nine, Oak House climbed onto the minibus. Gali got on last. She stopped on the step, turned and looked at the hall, the stage, the cup. “Next year,” she said. But this time it didn’t sound like a threat. It sounded sad.

Then everyone went to bed. Noam was the last in the hall. He switched off the lights. Then, because the stage was full of cups and crumbs and Oliver’s banner, he drew the heavy red curtain with one big pull, from right to left, with a “whoosh”, like in a theatre. “We’ll tidy up tomorrow,” he told himself, and locked the hall.

And in the morning, when Mrs. Cohen opened the curtain with one strong pull to the right, all the way, the cup wasn’t there.

Not at the edge. Not on the table. Not under the chairs. The stage was full of cups and crumbs, and Oliver’s banner lay on the floor. But the silver cup, with its two handles and its ribbon, had vanished.

“Oak House,” said Benny at once. He was standing in the hall doorway with clenched fists. “Obviously. They took it. Gali took it. I saw her standing by the stage. By the curtain. She didn’t take her eyes off it all evening.”

“She got on the minibus last,” said Penny. “I saw. She stopped and looked at the stage.”

“Thieves,” said Omer. “They don’t know how to lose.”

“Then we’ll go there,” said Benny. “Now. All of us. And take it back.”

“Nobody is going anywhere,” said Ruti, though she looked very worried too. She was already holding the phone. “I’ll ring the director of Oak House. And we’ll find out what happened.”

“Wait,” said Amy.

Everyone looked at her. Benny opened his mouth, then shut it.

“No blaming without proof,” said Amy. “And no phoning to blame without proof. If we ring and say ‘you stole it’, and it turns out they didn’t, they’ll hate us forever. And they’d be right to.” She looked at Ruti. “Give us until lunchtime. Please.”

Ruti looked at her, then at Benny, then at the phone. And sipped her coffee. “Until lunchtime,” she said. “And not a minute later.”

Benny stood in the doorway a moment longer with his fists clenched. Then he kicked a chair, not hard, and sat on it with his head in his hands. Amy sat down beside him.

“I’ve never won anything,” said Benny quietly, without looking up. “Not at football, until that final. Not on a school report. Not anything. And last night, when I lifted Leo onto my shoulders, I felt like I’d won too. For the first time.” He took a deep breath. “And now they’ve taken it.”

“We don’t know yet who took it,” said Amy. “And if someone took the cup, they didn’t take the win. Leo said ‘eight’. Everyone heard. That already happened, and nobody can steal it.”

Benny looked up at her. After a moment, he nodded. And his fists opened.

Amy, Hutie and Leo went up on the stage. Amy opened her notebook and read what she had written the night before. Cup – on stage, front edge, middle. Gali – by the curtain. Nine o’clock – minibus. Noam – last in the hall. Drew the curtain.

“What do we know for sure?” she asked. “Not what Benny thinks. What we know.”

“That at nine the cup was still here,” said Leo. “Because at quarter to nine I had my photo taken with it. For the seventh time.”

“And at nine Oak House left,” said Hutie. “And Gali got on the minibus. Empty-handed. I saw. She held the rail with both hands.”

Amy wrote: Gali – empty hands on the rail. She put a tiny question mark next to Gali’s name. Then she rubbed it out.

They searched the stage. And Hutie, crawling on her knees along the edge, found the first clue. At the front edge of the stage, exactly in the middle, where the cup had stood, was a scratch. A fresh, pale scratch in the dark wood. It didn’t go straight forward. It went sideways. To the right. As if something heavy and metal had been dragged along the edge.

“Someone dragged it,” said Hutie.

“Or something,” said Amy.

Then Tom, standing in the doorway with Maya, said something in a small voice. “The curtain ate something.”

Everyone turned round.

“Last night,” said Tom, going pink. “I came back for my dinosaur, which I’d left under a chair. And Noam drew the curtain, whoosh. And I saw a shadow. Something fell over. And then the curtain ate it.” He swallowed. “I thought it was a ghost. So I ran away.”

Amy wrote down every word. Tom – saw a shadow fall when the curtain closed. “The curtain ate it.”

“Leo,” she said. “I need you to measure.”

“Measure what?”

“Everything,” said Amy. “The hall. The stage. All of it. I want a map.”

Leo didn’t need telling twice. He pulled out his tape measure and his exercise book, and for a whole hour he measured. The length of the hall, and its width, wall to wall. The stage, side to side, along the front edge. Its height. The curtain. He drew, rubbed out and drew again. Hutie held the tape and asked every two minutes if he’d finished.

At quarter to twelve he stood in the middle of the hall with his exercise book, looking at his drawing with a pale face.

“Something doesn’t add up,” he said.

“What?”

“The hall, wall to wall, is eight metres thirty wide. I measured three times.” He pointed at the stage. “And the stage, side to side, is exactly eight metres wide. I measured that three times too.”

“So?” asked Hutie.

“So the stage is against the left wall,” said Leo slowly, “and it doesn’t reach the right wall. Thirty centimetres are missing.” He looked up. “Where are the thirty centimetres?”

They looked to the right. On the right side of the stage, where the heavy red curtain gathered when it was open, hung a thick bundle of velvet, folded, from ceiling to floor. And behind it, Amy now saw for the first time, was darkness. A narrow, tall, black darkness. Like an open mouth.

Amy the Detective, Chapter 33: The Missing Trophy - Like Likro - books to read online