“Miaow.”
Shira put down her spoon and covered her nose with a napkin. “Sorry,” she said. “I don’t know what’s wrong with me.”
“Miaow,” she went again. And then: “Miaow. Miaow.”
It was the third day. The third day that Shira, the girls’ counsellor, the one with the guitar and the high ponytail and the most catching laugh in Hilltop House, had been sneezing like a cat. Not an ordinary “Atishoo!” like Aharon’s, which rattles windows. A small, thin, high sneeze that came out of her nose in exactly the shape of “miaow”. Always in threes. Or fours. Or, on one especially bad morning, sevens.
Worst of all was the evening sing-song. Shira sat with her guitar in the playroom, all the girls round her, and began the song everyone loves, about the moon looking for its way home. “The moon climbs high, above the hill, and searches for —” And then: “Miaow. Miaow. Miaow.” The girls waited politely. Shira tried again. “Above the hill, and searches for —” “Miaow.” The third time, Alice and Penny, who always join in with everything at top volume, answered her together: “Miaow!” Within a minute the whole girls’ wing choir was singing the moon song with a “miaow” at the end of every line, and Shira laughed so hard she cried, and sneezed, and laughed, all at once.
Ruti, on the other hand, was especially happy that week. Because under the kitchen window, where Sugar had trampled the petunias in the summer, she had planted a new bed. “This time I’ve planted something tough,” she told anyone who’d listen, coffee mug in hand. “Something that doesn’t need much water, grows fast, and Sugar won’t eat, because it’s bitter to him. And it’s flowering already! Imagine. Two weeks, and flowers.” She was so proud she even invited David to see. David looked, said “Lovely”, and then added, the way David always adds something, a thing nobody understood at the time: “As long as no guests turn up.”
“What guests?” asked Ruti.
But David had already gone, keys jingling, whistling to himself.
“It’s a cat,” Hutie announced loudly at breakfast, to the whole table. “Shira’s swallowed a cat.”
“You can’t swallow a cat,” said Leo.
“A small cat,” said Hutie.
“Not even a small cat,” said Leo. “Anatomically.”
“Then there’s a cat in the house,” said Hutie. “A secret cat. And Shira’s sneezing because of it. And I’m going to find it, and I’m going to call it Shoelace.”
And so, that day, the Great Cat Hunt of Hilltop House began. Omer put a saucer of milk in every corner of the house, seven saucers, and the next morning they were all empty, and everyone shouted “There IS a cat!”, until they found Falafel asleep in the seventh saucer with a white milk moustache. Tom wandered the corridors going “Pss pss pss” everywhere, the way you call a cat, until Zehava said if he kept it up she’d start sneezing herself. And Oliver, still on his break from pranks, made do with drawing an orange cat in glasses on the points board, with the caption: Prime Suspect.
Zehava, for her part, decided to deal with the problem her own way. She made Shira tea with honey, lemon, ginger and garlic. “Garlic chases away every illness,” she explained. “And every person who stands too close.” Shira bravely drank it and sneezed a garlicky miaow. Then Zehava tried chicken soup, then a spoonful of olive oil, then hung round Shira’s neck a string of little onions, “like my grandmother used to”. The onions didn’t help. But nobody went near Shira all day, so at least nobody caught anything.
And Mrs. Cohen sent Shira to the doctor. The doctor looked up Shira’s nose, down her throat and into her ears, and said, “Allergy.” “To what?” asked Shira. The doctor shrugged. “Something. Something around you. Have a look.” Shira came back to Hilltop House, looked straight at Amy and said, “Hear that? Someone’s got to look. That’s your job.”
Amy, Hutie and Leo were already sitting on the third stair with the notebook.
“It isn’t a cat,” said Amy. “It’s an allergy. When someone sneezes every day, in threes, with an itchy nose and red eyes, it’s something they’re allergic to. The question is what.”
“But the sneeze sounds like a cat,” said Hutie, who wasn’t ready to give up on Shoelace so fast.
“A sneeze sounds like whoever’s sneezing,” said Leo. “Shira has a small nose. A small nose makes a high sneeze.”
Amy opened a new page. “Suspects,” she wrote.
Suspect number one was soap. The week before, on her birthday, Noam, the boys’ counsellor, had given Shira a present. Two bars of soap. Green, scented, wrapped in brown paper, with a strong smell of eucalyptus. Shira was delighted and began washing with them every evening. And Noam, when he heard she was sneezing, went pale.
“It’s the soap,” he told Amy quietly by the sink. “Isn’t it? I’ve done her in with soap.”
“We don’t know yet,” said Amy.
“It’s the soap,” said Noam, in despair. “I bought two. Why did I buy two?”
“Because he loves her,” Hutie whispered to Leo, not quietly enough. Noam turned red and went very quickly to check something in the boys’ corridor that didn’t need checking at all.
Suspect number two was Falafel. Because Falafel, like every rabbit, sheds fur. Lots of fur. On the sofas, on the rugs, on everyone’s jumpers. And in the past week Falafel had discovered that Shira kept bits of carrot in her pocket, for the pony, and had started following her everywhere and sitting on her shoes.
Suspect number three was Kuku. Or rather, Kuku’s feathers. Because this month Shira was in charge of the coop. Every morning at half past six she went in, collected eggs and scattered grain, and Kuku, who adored her, hopped round her flapping his wings, and little feathers flew everywhere.
“Three suspects,” said Amy. “Soap, rabbit, cockerel. And each one has to be tested. Separately.”
“How do you test soap?” asked Hutie.
“You take it away,” said Amy.
The experiment lasted three days, and the whole of Hilltop House took part. Leo made a chart with three columns and space to count sneezes, and stuck it on the kitchen door. Every time Shira sneezed, somebody ran over and drew a line.
On day one, Shira didn’t use Noam’s soap. She washed with the plain white soap, the dullest in the world, which smells of nothing at all. In the evening Leo counted the lines. “Forty-three miaows,” he announced.
“It isn’t the soap,” said Amy. And Noam, in the doorway, breathed out so hard with relief that the curtain moved.
On day two, Falafel stayed in Amy, Hutie and Maya’s room all day, with a basket of lettuce and Maya reading him a story. Shira wore a clean jumper without a single rabbit hair and no carrots in her pocket. In the evening Leo counted. “Forty-one.”
“It isn’t Falafel,” said Amy.
On day three, Benny took over the coop. He went in at half past six, collected the eggs, scattered the grain, and came back with a feather in his hair and the face of someone whose shoe Kuku had pecked, because Kuku wanted Shira, not Benny. Shira didn’t go near the coop all day. In the evening Leo counted. “Forty-six. A record.”
“It isn’t Kuku,” said Amy.
Benny announced after that day that he was never going into the coop again. “That bird hates me,” he said, showing everyone three little beak marks on his shoe. “He looked at me like I was a worm.” And Tom, who was very into worms at that moment, said that was actually a compliment.
The three of them sat on the third stair with the chart, in silence.
“So it’s not soap, not rabbit, not cockerel,” said Hutie. “So it’s a cat. I said so.”
“There’s no cat,” said Leo.
“Maybe there is,” said Amy suddenly. She was looking at the chart. Not at the numbers. At the times. Because Leo, always precise, had written the time beside every line. And the times, Amy saw now, weren’t scattered. They were bunched. Lots of sneezes in the morning, at half past seven. Lots at lunch, at one. Lots in the evening, at half past six.
“Meals,” she said. “She sneezes at mealtimes.”
“So she’s allergic to Zehava’s cooking,” said Hutie in horror. “Zehava mustn’t hear. She’ll resign. Or worse, she’ll cry.”
“Not the cooking,” said Amy. “She eats at parties in the yard too, and at her parents’ on Saturdays. And there she doesn’t sneeze. She sneezes in the dining room. And in the dining room, where does she sit?”
“By the window,” said Leo. “Always by the window. The big one that opens onto the yard. Because she likes watching Sugar.”
They looked at each other, and Amy felt that thing, the tingle at the back of her neck that says something is about to come clear.
That night none of them could sleep. Amy lay in her bed by the window listening to the wind, Hutie tossing and turning, Maya breathing slowly. And at a quarter past eleven she heard something else.
“Miaow.”
She sat up. That wasn’t a sneeze. It was a real miaow. Long and sing-song, a cat’s. And it came from outside. From the kitchen side.
“Hutie,” she whispered. “Are you awake?”
“I’ve never been more awake,” whispered Hutie from the dark.
They crept down the corridor in their socks, Hutie with a torch. On the third stair, as usual, Leo was already waiting, in starry pyjamas, holding the magnifying glass, as if he’d known. Quietly they went to the kitchen’s back door, and Amy opened it just a crack.
Under the kitchen window, where Ruti’s petunias had been before Sugar trampled them, was the new bed. Small grey-green plants with tiny purple-white flowers, which Ruti had planted two weeks ago in place of the petunias. And in the bed, in the moonlight, were cats.
Not one cat. Three. A fat ginger tom, a black she-cat and a little grey kitten with a crooked tail. And they weren’t prowling or hunting for food. They were rolling. On their backs, legs in the air, among the plants, rubbing their cheeks on the leaves and purring as loudly as three little engines, looking happier than any cats Amy had ever seen.
“Shoelace,” whispered Hutie, thrilled. “Three Shoelaces.”
The grey kitten lifted its head and looked at them with round yellow eyes. Then, without the slightest fear, it climbed out of the bed, up the step, through the crack and straight to Leo’s leg. And began to rub against it. Back and forth. Back and forth. Purring.
Leo froze. “What’s it doing?” he whispered in alarm. “Amy. What’s it doing? I’ve never had a cat.”
“It loves you,” whispered Hutie.
“It doesn’t know me,” whispered Leo.
“Cats don’t mind,” whispered Hutie. “Stroke it.”
Slowly, carefully, like someone defusing a bomb, Leo reached out one hand and stroked it. Once. The kitten purred louder. And Leo, for the first time in the whole mystery, smiled a smile with no scientific explanation at all.
In the dark, Amy looked at the plants. Then at the big dining-room window, which was, she noticed now, right above the bed. The open window. Shira’s window.
“Leo,” she whispered. “In the morning, bring the tape measure. And the magnifying glass. And a bag.”
“What are we testing?” whispered Leo.
“What cats love,” whispered Amy, “and Shira doesn’t.”