At six in the morning, before Kuku, before Zehava, even before the hedgehogs came home, three detectives were crouching by Ruti’s flower bed under the kitchen window.
The cats had gone. But they had left signs. The plants were flattened and squashed, as if someone had slept on them, which is exactly what had happened. There were hairs everywhere. Ginger, black and grey. And in the soil, little paw prints with four round toes, going every which way.
“It’s a playground,” said Hutie. “A playground for cats.”
Leo measured. “From the bed to the dining-room window is one metre fifty,” he announced. “From the window to Shira’s chair, another eighty centimetres. Two metres thirty altogether. That’s close.”
Amy bent and picked one small sprig. Soft grey-green leaves with jagged edges, and tiny white flowers with purple spots. She rubbed a leaf between her fingers and sniffed. The smell was strong and sharp, a bit like mint, and a bit like something else, something dusty and summery.
“What is it?” asked Leo.
“I don’t know,” said Amy. “But someone does.”
They found it in the recycling bin by the shed. Because Ruti, like everyone who plants things, had thrown away the plastic pots the plants came in from the garden centre. Stuck in each pot was a little white plastic label with a picture of a flower and very small writing.
Leo raised the magnifying glass and read aloud:
Catmint. Perennial. Tolerates heat and drought. White-purple flowers. Attracts cats.
“Attracts cats,” Hutie repeated slowly. “Attracts. Cats.”
“It’s a plant cats go mad for,” said Leo, remembering something he’d once read in the encyclopaedia, in the volume for C. “There’s a chemical in it that makes them roll about and purr and be happy. Like chocolate, but for cats.”
“And Ruti didn’t read the small print,” said Amy.
“Nobody reads the small print,” said Leo. “That’s why they print it small.”
“And David knew,” said Amy, remembering. “‘As long as no guests turn up.’ He meant cats.”
“Wait,” said Hutie. “If Shira’s allergic to a cat plant, and she sneezes like a cat, then maybe, actually, she’s a little bit cat?”
Leo opened his mouth to explain, at length, why that was scientifically untrue. Then he closed it. “I can’t,” he said. “I don’t argue about cats at six in the morning.”
But knowing isn’t enough. A detective has to prove it. And Amy knew exactly how.
At half past seven, at breakfast, the whole of Hilltop House sat in the dining room. The big window was shut, for the first time in two weeks, because Amy had asked David to close it. Shira sat in her usual chair by the window, eating porridge.
And didn’t sneeze.
One minute. Two. Five. Leo stood by the chart on the door with the marker in his hand and didn’t draw a single line. The whole dining room watched Shira. And Shira, who didn’t understand why everyone was looking at her, stopped chewing and smiled awkwardly with a mouthful of porridge.
“Ten minutes,” announced Leo. “Zero miaows.”
“Perhaps it’s gone by itself,” said Mrs. Cohen hopefully, from the grown-ups’ table.
“Perhaps it’s gone because today’s porridge is better,” said Zehava proudly, from the kitchen.
“Or perhaps,” said Amy, “it’s gone because the window’s shut.”
Then Amy stood up and went over to Shira, holding a jar. An empty jam jar, closed, and inside it one small sprig of catmint. She set the jar on the table next to Shira’s porridge.
“What’s that?” asked Shira.
“An experiment,” said Amy. And she unscrewed the lid.
Shira sniffed. Her nose wrinkled. Her eyes closed. And she lifted her head, slowly, like someone about to sing the highest note in the song.
“Miaow,” she sneezed. “Miaow. Miaow.”
Amy screwed the lid back on.
Silence.
Then the whole dining room exploded. Benny clapped. Alice and Penny shouted “Miaow!” together, out of habit. Tom stood on his chair waving his spoon and yelled, “The detective wins!” And Noam, in the corner, threw his arms in the air and announced to the entire room, “It’s not the soap! It’s not the soap!” Then he realised what he’d said, went red again, and went off again to check something in the corridor.
“Catmint,” Amy explained when everyone had calmed down. “Ruti planted it two weeks ago under the dining-room window. Three days ago it flowered. Since then, whenever the window’s open, the smell drifts straight in to Shira’s chair. And Shira’s allergic to it. The cats from round about aren’t allergic. They’re in love with it. They come every night for a party.”
“So Shoelace is real,” said Hutie triumphantly. “I said there was a cat.”
“You said she’d swallowed a cat,” said Leo.
“Details,” said Hutie.
Shira, meanwhile, looked at the closed jar, then at Amy, then picked up the guitar that always stood in the corner of the dining room and strummed one chord. “I owe you a song,” she said. “A whole song. No miaows.” And there, beside the porridge, she made up a short song about a detective with a notebook and a pencil behind her ear who finds everything except her own socks. The whole dining room laughed. Amy went pink. It was true, by the way. She hadn’t found her purple sock for a month.
When Ruti heard, she sat in the office with her coffee mug, looked out at her flower bed and sighed. “At last something Sugar won’t eat,” she said, “and now I’ve got to dig it up. I’ve no luck with that bed. Perhaps it’s cursed.”
“It isn’t cursed,” said Amy. “It’s just in the wrong place.”
“And where’s the right place for a plant that attracts cats?” asked Ruti.
Amy didn’t answer at once. She looked out of the office window. Across the yard. Over the fence. Into Mr. Ben-Ami’s garden, where the old man was sitting just then on his chair by the door, alone, with a cup of tea, watching his hens. And Amy remembered something he had once told her quietly, on the day of the floodlight. That he used to have a cat. An old ginger cat called Apricot, who sat on his lap every evening. And that last winter Apricot had died. And since then, the evenings had been long.
“I think,” said Amy slowly, “I know exactly where.”
Before that, Hutie had suggested other solutions. “Shira could wear a mask,” she said. “For ever.” Leo suggested moving the dining room. “Only two metres thirty,” he explained, “the other way.” And Tom suggested asking the cats what they wanted, because “nobody ever asks the cats”. In the end, he was closest of all.
They asked Mr. Ben-Ami first. Because that’s how it’s done. You don’t give someone cats as a surprise. Amy, Hutie and Leo stood at the fence and Amy explained everything. Shira, the sneezes, the plant, the three cats who came every night.
“And your hens,” added Leo, honestly, because Leo is always honest, “might be scared.”
Mr. Ben-Ami laughed. A deep, creaky laugh they had hardly ever heard from him. “My hens?” he said. “Lad, my hens once saw off a fox. The cats will be scared of them.”
Then he went quiet for a moment and looked at the empty chair beside him, the one Apricot must once have jumped onto. “Bring it,” he said softly. “Bring the plant. Let the guests come.”
That afternoon the whole of Hilltop House helped move the flower bed. David lifted the plants one by one, with the soil round their roots so they wouldn’t be hurt. The children carried them in buckets, in a long line, over the fence, like firefighters passing water. And Mr. Ben-Ami dug them a new bed with his hoe, along the wall of his house, well away from the coop, right under the window by his chair. Shira, in a mask and gloves, stood at a distance and clapped, and didn’t sneeze once.
There was one especially awkward moment when Tom’s bucket, which was almost bigger than he was, got stuck between the fence boards, and Tom got stuck with it, half on the Hilltop House side and half on Mr. Ben-Ami’s, and announced, without crying at all, that he now “lived in two houses”. Benny got him out. The bucket stayed in the fence till evening, and Tom visited it twice.
And Falafel, following everyone as usual, sniffed one of the plants, stood still for a moment, and sneezed. A tiny rabbit sneeze. Everyone froze. “No,” said Leo at once, in the voice of a worried scientist. “Not another one.” But Falafel sneezed only once, hopped on, helped himself to a lettuce leaf from Shira’s pocket and looked extremely pleased with himself.
In place of the old bed under the kitchen window, Ruti planted something new. Lavender. And before she planted it, Leo read the small print aloud, word by word, with the magnifying glass. Lavender. Fragrant. Attracts bees and butterflies. “Bees,” said Leo, “are fine. Bees don’t roll about.”
That night Amy couldn’t resist. She got up and padded in her socks to the Room Seven window beside her bed, from which, if you lean a little, you can see Mr. Ben-Ami’s garden. And she saw. In the moonlight, in the new bed, three cats rolled on their backs, purring. On the chair by the door sat Mr. Ben-Ami, a blanket over his knees. And on the blanket, curled up asleep, was the little grey kitten with the crooked tail.
Behind Amy someone breathed softly. Hutie, awake of course, leaning on the windowsill too with her blanket round her shoulders. “He’s not alone,” she whispered.
“No,” whispered Amy. “Not any more.”
In the morning Mr. Ben-Ami announced over the fence, loudly so everyone could hear, that the grey kitten had moved in with him. “He decided,” he said. “Not me. With cats, they decide.” And when they asked what he was called, he looked at Hutie, then at Leo, shrugged and said, “I hear he’s already got a name. Shoelace.”
Hutie nearly fainted with happiness. And Leo asked, quietly, whether he might visit Shoelace. Once a day. Just to check he was all right. Mr. Ben-Ami said he might. Twice, even.
That evening, at the sing-song, Shira played the moon song from start to finish without a single miaow. When it ended there was an odd silence. The girls looked at one another, a little disappointed. Then Alice said, out loud, “Miaow.” Penny answered, “Miaow.” And in a moment the whole girls’ wing choir was singing again, right from the start, with a miaow at the end of every line. Because some mysteries, even once solved, leave a song behind.
That week Noam gave Shira another soap. Just one. White. No smell at all. Shira laughed, said thank you, and put it on the shelf beside the two green ones, which she was keeping, she said, “as a souvenir”.
Amy opened her notebook and wrote: Case Number 24: The Counsellor Who Miaows. Solved. The culprit: a plant. The guests: moved house.
And on the noticeboard, beside Leo’s chart, which nobody dared take down, a new sheet appeared that day in Mrs. Cohen’s big handwriting: Sukkot Trip! Three days in the north. The bus leaves Monday at 7 a.m. Driver: Shimon. Do not be late!
And underneath, in small pencil letters, someone had added: And this time, let’s not get lost.