Yuval was standing outside the girls’ showers holding a purple towel, with the face of a kid who has been given a mission and isn’t sure he understands it.
Daniel passed by at half past seven in the evening, on his way back from the dock, his hair still wet from Kobi’s lesson. He barely noticed Yuval. But Yuval noticed him, and did something nine-year-olds only do when something is wrong. He called him by name.
“Daniel.”
Daniel stopped. “Hey, Yuval. What are you doing here?”
“Guarding,” said Yuval. He held up the towel as evidence. “Maya’s inside. She told me to wait here with the towel and not let anyone in.”
“Okay.”
“She’s crying,” said Yuval.
Daniel didn’t move.
“She says it’s shampoo,” Yuval went on, in the voice of someone reporting facts. “That she got shampoo in her eyes. But she’s been in there twenty minutes, and the water isn’t on. I can hear when the water’s on.” He pushed his glasses back up his nose. The elastic around his head was already stretched. “Shampoo doesn’t get in your eyes when the water’s off. Right?”
“No,” Daniel said slowly. “Not usually.”
Yuval nodded, as if this confirmed something he already suspected. “It’s because of her phone,” he said. “She looked at her phone, and then she said ‘I’m going to shower,’ and took me and the towel, and didn’t take shampoo.”
* * *
Nadav found the video in thirty seconds. Nadav could find anything in thirty seconds, except his inhaler, which was always in the other pocket.
“It’s a gossip account,” he said, handing Daniel the phone. They were sitting on the Pelican steps, Alon beside them, slowly chewing sunflower seeds like someone expecting the worst. “It’s called ‘The Truth About Them.’ It has six hundred thousand followers. It posts clips of famous people and adds nasty captions. That’s… that’s its thing.”
Daniel looked.
It was Family Day. He recognised the dock at once, and the sun, and the row of boats. Someone had filmed from the beach, on a phone, from far away, so the picture was a little shaky. But you could see everything. One boat, with two brothers. The older one standing, explaining something. The younger one sitting in the middle in an orange life jacket. Then, at the end of the dock, a girl with her hair tied back, calling something you couldn’t hear, holding out her hand. And the younger one gets up, climbs out of his brother’s boat, and goes to her.
And above, in big white letters:
Influencer “Maya Maybe” kidnaps someone else’s little brother. For views. 🙄
And below, smaller: Look at the big brother’s face 💔
Daniel looked at the big brother’s face. It was his face. It was, he had to admit, a fairly sad face. He hadn’t known he looked like that.
“The comments,” Nadav said quietly. “Don’t read the comments.”
Daniel read the comments.
she’ll do anything for content, ew
obviously she has no siblings of her own to steal
she has a brother, he’s in her videos, poor kid
fake from start to finish. even her laugh is fake
she thinks she’s everyone’s mom. nobody asked
hope the big brother files a complaint
now we know why her parents are never in her videos. they can’t stand her either
He read the last one twice. The second time, his hand gripped the phone so hard that Nadav reached out and gently extracted it.
“Three thousand two hundred comments,” said Nadav. “In two hours. Most of them like that. A few defend her, but…” He scrolled. “They’re buried. Nobody sees them. The algorithm loves cruelty. It’s documented. There are studies.”
“I don’t want studies,” said Daniel.
“I know,” said Nadav. “But there are.”
“Does she read this?” asked Daniel. “All of it?”
“Everyone reads it,” said Nadav. “Everyone says they don’t read the comments. It’s the least accurate statistic in the world. A hundred percent read them. And the ones who say they don’t read them twice, at night, under the blanket.”
* * *
Daniel sat there in silence.
He thought about that moment on Family Day. About Ben getting out of his boat, in front of the whole camp, and going to Maya. About how he’d felt then. He remembered it very well. It was one of the worst moments of the summer. He had hated Maya at that moment. Really hated her. A hot, salty hatred, like seawater in the throat.
But now he thought about something else. About what happened next. About Ben, in his orange life jacket, sitting in the middle of Maya’s boat, and Maya shouting Now! at exactly the right moment, and Ben leaning, and the wind doing the rest. About Ben winning a sailing race, Ben, who in the first week had thought a boat was something you drowned in.
And about Dad, at the end of that day, in the car park, by the car. Dad hugged him, a hug that went on too long, as always, and then said quietly, so Michal wouldn’t hear: “That girl, with the ponytail. Did you see how she looked at Ben? As if he were the most important thing on the lake.” And after a moment he added: “Michal cried in the car all the way from the dock. From happiness. Don’t tell her I told you.”
Daniel hadn’t told her. But he remembered. He remembered it even on the nights he lay in bed hating Maya Stern with all his strength.
Maya had been wrong about Daniel. Badly wrong, loudly, in front of everyone. But she hadn’t been wrong about Ben. She’d seen a kid standing alone in an orange life jacket, scared, while everyone was watching the boats, and she had looked at him. And gone to him.
Most people don’t do that. Daniel knew. Because he hadn’t done it fast enough either, in a year and a half in that apartment.
“Give me the phone,” he said.
Nadav looked at him. “What are you going to do?”
“Write something.”
“You don’t have TikTok.”
“Right. You do.”
Nadav held the phone close to his chest, the way you hold a pet. “I have twelve followers,” he said. “Seven are relatives. One is a bot. My account is called ‘nadav_stats.’ I post videos of clouds and explain what type they are.”
“Perfect,” said Daniel, and held out his hand.
Alon, without a word, took the phone from Nadav and put it in Daniel’s hand. Nadav gave Alon a look of betrayal. Alon chewed a seed.
* * *
It took Daniel twenty minutes.
He wrote and deleted. Wrote and deleted. He wasn’t good with words. He was good with waves, and knots, and reaching a capsized boat before anyone else. Words were Nadav’s field, and Shira’s, and Mom’s, who had once left him a note on the fridge, Dani, the sea isn’t going anywhere. Dinner is, which he still kept in his wallet.
In the end, this is what he wrote:
I was there. That day, on the dock. Everyone was watching the boats, the race, who’d win. One kid was standing alone in an orange life jacket, scared. She was the only one who looked at him. She didn’t kidnap anyone. She saw someone alone, and went to him. Most people don’t do that. I know, because I didn’t do it fast enough either.
You don’t know her. I thought I knew her too, and I was wrong about a lot of things. But not about this.
And one last thing: if you’re writing about someone else’s parents, who you know nothing about, you should probably call your own.
He stopped. He looked at it. It seemed too long, and too short, and terrible, and true.
Then, because Mom had taught him that if you say something important, you sign it, he went down two lines and wrote:
— Daniel Carmeli
And pressed “Post.”
* * *
Nadav took the phone back with both hands, as if it were hot.
“You signed it,” he said. “Your full name.”
“Yes.”
“Maya knows your name.”
“Yes.”
Nadav looked at the screen. Then he made a strange face, like someone deciding whether to say something. “TikTok cuts off long comments,” he said. “It shows the beginning, then it says ‘…more,’ and you have to tap. Most people don’t tap. Eighty-seven percent, according to one study, but it was a small study.”
“So?”
“So your name,” said Nadav, “is after the ‘…more.'”
Daniel thought about it. He thought that this was, maybe, exactly right. Item 2, in someone else’s version. For nobody to see when someone helps. He hadn’t written it so Maya would know. He’d written it because it was true. If she tapped, she’d know. If not, not.
“That’s fine,” he said.
“But it’s on my account,” said Nadav in rising panic. “She’ll think that—”
Then the phone buzzed.
And buzzed again. And again, and again, and again, until it wasn’t buzzing anymore but one long hum, like a bee that had got into a pocket.
Nadav looked at the screen and went pale.
“A hundred likes,” he said. “Two hundred. Four hundred. It… the comment’s gone to the top. It’s first. People are replying to it.” He scrolled with a trembling finger. “‘Finally someone normal.’ ‘Who is this Nadav? A saint.’ ‘Nadav for president.’ ‘Bro, that last line 🔥🔥🔥.'” He looked up. “Daniel. Everyone thinks it’s me.“
Alon, for the first time that evening, laughed. A short, dry laugh, like a seed cracking.
* * *
At half past eight, Maya came out of the showers.
Daniel saw her from a distance, from the steps. She took the towel from Yuval and wrapped him in it, though he wasn’t wet, and said something to him, and he pointed at her phone, which was in her hand again. She looked at the screen. Daniel saw her stop. Saw her shoulders, hunched all evening, loosen a little. Saw her scroll, and stop, and read. And read again.
She didn’t tap “more.” He knew, because after a moment she looked up and searched for someone with her eyes, and her eyes passed over the Pelican steps, over Daniel, without stopping, and came to rest on Nadav.
And Nadav, who had the most sensitive conscience at Camp Green Waves, looked back like a rabbit looking at headlights.
“Oh no,” Nadav said quietly. “Oh no, oh no, oh no.”
Maya smiled at him. A small, tired smile, completely real, no camera. Then she took Yuval by the hand and walked toward Heron.
Daniel watched her go. Under his ribs, something ached and was glad at the same time, like a muscle after a long swim. He said nothing. Item 2.
“Tomorrow,” said Nadav, in the voice of a man foreseeing the end of the world, “she’ll thank me. In front of everyone. And I can’t lie. You know I can’t lie. When I lie, I start giving the wrong percentages.”
“Then don’t lie,” said Daniel.
“And don’t tell the truth,” said Alon.
Nadav looked at both of them. Then he took out his inhaler and used it, for the first time that week, for real.