Tom woke up on his seventh birthday at half past five in the morning, sat up in bed and waited for someone to notice.
Nobody noticed. Everyone was asleep. So he got up, put on his best T-shirt, the one with the dinosaur holding a balloon, stood in the doorway and announced loudly to the dark room: “I’m seven.”
Under his duvet, Oliver mumbled something that sounded like “Happy birthday, let me sleep.” And Benny threw a pillow at him, gently, the way you throw a pillow at someone whose birthday it is.
But the first surprise was waiting for Tom in the bathroom.
On the low mirror by the little sinks, when he turned on the hot water, three words appeared in the steam, with a little cake underneath.
SZKKB YRIGSWZB GLN
Tom stared at them, mouth open. Then he ran, toothbrush in hand, to Maya, who was already waiting for him at the door of the wing. And the two of them, with Leo’s page of two alphabets, sat on the third stair and decoded it, letter by letter. Maya read, and Tom wrote, in big wobbly capitals.
“Happy… birthday… Tom,” read Tom. And he looked at Maya with the biggest eyes in the world. “The ghost knows it’s my birthday!”
“It isn’t a ghost,” said Maya, with the importance of someone who knows a secret. “It’s Amy and Leo. But I’m not allowed to say.”
At breakfast, the whole of Hilltop House sang him “Happy Birthday”, forty children at forty different speeds, while Zehava beat the Queen on a saucepan for drums. Then came presents. Hutie gave him a bracelet with seven knots, “a knot for every year”. Leo gave him a little book he had written himself, by hand, with pictures: Seventy Dinosaur Facts Nobody Knows. “Only forty-three, actually,” Leo admitted. “But seventy sounds better.” And Oliver gave him a certificate, painted orange, which said: Tom – aged seven. Officially qualified not to be afraid of ghosts.
Tom held all his presents on his lap for the whole of breakfast and refused to put any of them down.
It was, Tom said afterwards, the best morning of his whole life. Until lunchtime.
Because at lunchtime, Zehava baked the cake.
It wasn’t just any cake. It was a cake with three layers. The bottom layer, the widest, was chocolate. The middle layer was vanilla, with strawberry jam inside. And the top layer, small and round, was the most important thing of all: banana cake, covered in thick, yellow, shiny banana cream, with seven slices of banana arranged in a circle like a crown. Because Tom loved bananas more than anything in the world. Apart from dinosaurs.
Tom didn’t leave the kitchen all lunchtime. Every ten minutes he peeped round the door and asked, “Is it ready yet?” And the eighth time, Zehava sighed, put down the Queen and said, “Come here. I’ve got a job for you. A job for a seven-year-old.”
And she gave him the bananas. And Tom, tongue poking out, concentrating like a surgeon, arranged the seven slices on the cream himself, in a circle, one by one, adjusting each one three times until the crown was perfect. “That’s your layer,” Zehava told him. “You built it.” And Tom looked at the yellow crown and was so proud he forgot to breathe.
“The cream has to cool,” Zehava announced at three o’clock, “or it’ll melt like snow in the sun.” And she set the cake, on a big plate, on the sill of the kitchen window, the one facing the yard, and opened the window wide so the breeze would cool it. “The party’s at five. Until then, nobody touches it. Not with a finger. Not even with a look.”
Oliver, standing in the doorway, instantly looked away.
Then Zehava went down to the cellar to fetch the candles. Seven candles, plus one to grow on, as they do at Hilltop House. It took her five minutes. Because the cellar is dark, and the candles were in the box under the box under the box. Then she came back up, box in hand, and walked into the kitchen.
And her scream was heard as far as the coop.
On the windowsill stood the plate. And on the plate stood the bottom layer, the chocolate. And on top of it, the middle layer, the vanilla. And on top of the middle layer… nothing. Just a smear of yellow cream. And two slices of banana that had fallen to one side, like wounded soldiers.
The top layer had vanished. All of it. Cream, crown and all.
Within a minute, the whole of Hilltop House was standing in the kitchen. And Tom stood in the middle, facing the unfinished cake, his bottom lip trembling. “That was my layer,” he said in a very small voice. “The banana one.”
Then he started to cry. Not loudly. Quietly, with big tears, the way you cry when something is truly sad. And Maya held his hand, and nearly cried too, for him.
Zehava sat down on the stool with the box of candles in her hand and suddenly looked small. “I left the window open,” she said. “Five minutes. Only five minutes. Thirty years I’ve been cooling cakes on that sill, and never once…” She didn’t finish.
Mrs. Cohen put a hand on her shoulder. “Nobody is to blame until our detective says so,” she said, looking at Amy. “Isn’t that right?”
“That’s right,” said Amy.
Amy looked at Tom. Then she took out her notebook.
“Tom,” she said, crouching down to him. “It’s your birthday. And on birthdays you deserve something special. So I’m going to give you a present. I’ll solve this for you before the party. I promise.”
Tom wiped his nose on the sleeve of his dinosaur T-shirt and nodded.
“An hour and three-quarters,” whispered Leo, checking his watch. “That’s hardly anything.”
“It’s enough,” said Amy.
Tom tugged her sleeve. “Amy,” he whispered, “even if you don’t find the layer, that’s all right. Just find out who. Because I want to tell them it wasn’t nice.” He thought for a moment and, for some reason, went pink. “And then, maybe, invite them to the party. Because maybe they were just hungry.”
Amy looked at him, at the tears that hadn’t dried yet and the bracelet with seven knots, and thought that a seven-year-old can be wiser than a lot of grown-ups.
The first suspect was obvious to everyone. Not because of anything he had done. Because of his finger.
“Oliver,” said Penny, pointing. “Show me your finger.”
Oliver hid his hand behind his back. Fast. Too fast.
“Oliver.”
Slowly, with the face of someone who knows there’s no way out, Oliver brought out his hand. And on his index finger was cream. Yellow. Banana.
The whole kitchen gasped. Tom stopped crying and stared at Oliver with wide-open eyes, like someone who has discovered that his hero is really the villain.
“It’s not what you think!” said Oliver. “It’s from the bowl! Zehava left the cream bowl in the sink! And I… cleaned it. With my finger. It’s a public service!”
Zehava looked in the sink. The bowl was there. Empty. Clean. Too clean, the way a bowl only gets after Oliver has been at it. “He’s telling the truth,” she said, half smiling and half cross. “The bowl, he finished. Thoroughly.”
“Besides,” said Amy, who was already standing by the window, “look at the cake.”
Everyone looked.
“Whoever took the top layer didn’t take it with their hands,” said Amy. “Look at the cream on the middle layer. It’s smeared. Not cut. And look at the edge of the middle layer.” She pointed. On one side of the vanilla sponge, a half-circle was missing. An enormous half-circle. With small, neat marks all along the curve.
“A bite,” whispered Leo. “That’s a bite.”
“An enormous bite,” said Amy. “Open your mouth, Oliver.”
Oliver opened his mouth as wide as he could. Leo measured it with his tape measure, as seriously as a dentist. Then he measured the bite in the cake.
“Oliver’s mouth: five centimetres,” he announced. “The bite: twelve.”
“So it isn’t Oliver,” said Amy. Oliver breathed out in relief, and promptly licked his finger, because it seemed a shame to waste it.
“Then it’s the jay,” said Benny. “It’s stolen things here before. It always comes back.”
“Jays don’t bite,” said Leo. “They peck. And a jay can’t lift a whole cake layer. It must weigh a kilo.”
“Maybe aliens,” suggested Oliver, who had recovered quickly. “They love bananas. Everybody knows that.”
“Nobody knows that,” said Alice.
“Because it’s a secret,” said Oliver.
“Then Falafel,” said Omer. “He ate the ghost’s pancake. He eats everything.”
Everyone looked at Falafel, who was sitting by the kitchen door nibbling a lettuce leaf with the most innocent face in the world. His mouth was the size of a button.
“Falafel would need ten years to eat a layer like that,” said Hutie. “And then he’d explode.”
Amy didn’t answer. Her face was already pressed close to the windowsill. And on the white wood of the sill, she found two more things.
The first was a hair. One very long hair, brown and thick, almost like a thread. It was stuck in the smeared cream at the edge of the plate. Amy lifted it carefully and held it up to the light. It was as long as Tom’s whole arm.
“That’s not a child’s hair,” said Hutie. “And not Zehava’s either. Zehava’s hair is grey.”
“And Ruti’s is short,” said Leo.
The second thing was wet. On the sill, next to the plate, was a patch. A big, shiny, wet, sticky patch. As if someone had left a bit of dribble. Quite a lot of dribble, actually.
“Yuck,” said Penny.
“A clue,” said Amy, writing. Long, thick brown hair. Bite: 12 cm. Dribble. Lots.
Then she leaned out of the window and looked down.
Under the kitchen window was Ruti’s flower bed. A bed of purple petunias, which Ruti watered every morning, talked to, and forbade every child to step in. And today, the petunias were trampled. And among them, in the soft earth still damp from the morning watering, were prints.
They weren’t shoe prints. They weren’t bare footprints. They were round. Shaped like a half-moon, with a little notch in the middle. Four prints, deep, as if someone heavy had stood there on all fours, stretching for a long, long time towards the window.
Hutie was already running outside, round the building, to the flower bed. And beside the prints, on the path, she found something else: one slice of banana, with a little cream, fallen on a stone. And three metres further towards the yard, another one. And another, by the tap. Like a trail of crumbs in a fairy tale, only with bananas.
“Three,” Hutie counted aloud. “Plus two on the plate. And two missing.” She looked at the trail, which went straight, without a single turn, to the far end of the yard. “Whoever took it walked slowly. And enjoyed it.”
Leo leaned out beside Amy. And looked. And his glasses nearly fell into the flower bed.
“Amy,” he whispered. “There’s only one person at Hilltop House with prints like that.”
Amy didn’t answer. She just looked, past the flower bed, past the yard, to the little shed at the far end, and the fence, and the paddock gate.
And the gate was open.