The narrow door opened with a long creak.
And in the doorway, a small lamp in one hand and an old violin in the other, stood David the caretaker.
He wore a brown jumper with holes at the elbows, and on his sleeve, just like on the handle, was a smudge of white powder. His hair stuck out in all directions, and he blinked in the beam of the torch Shira had switched on at the last second, like an owl woken in the middle of the day.
He looked at the four of them: Amy with her notebook, Hutie holding her hand, Leo with his compass, and Shira at the back, not looking surprised at all.
“Well,” said David at last, in a croaky voice. “At least it isn’t Omer with the garlic.”
Hutie laughed. She didn’t mean to; it just came out, and she clapped a hand over her mouth. Then Leo laughed, then Shira, then David himself, a deep, big, tired laugh. And Amy felt all the fear of the evening rush out of her at once, like air from a balloon.
“You don’t go home at half past eight,” she said.
“No,” David admitted. “Not for the last two weeks.”
“And you stopped whistling.”
David raised his eyebrows. “You noticed that?”
“Everyone noticed,” said Hutie. “The house is too quiet without it. Like a clock that’s stopped.”
David looked at them a moment longer, then sighed and opened the door wide.
“All right,” he said. “Since you’ve come this far. Five minutes. Shira stays with you. And not a word to anyone.”
They climbed the steep stairs one by one, and the stairs creaked under them like a grumbling old man. At the top, Amy stopped, and her mouth fell open.
The attic wasn’t full of dust and pigeons. Well, there was some dust, and one sleepy pigeon on a beam. But otherwise it was the loveliest place Amy had ever seen in Hilltop House. The ceiling sloped, with old wooden beams, and a little round window showed the stars. On the floor lay a worn rug, and on it stood a rocking chair, an iron music stand and a lamp with a yellow shade. And all around the walls were boxes. Dozens of boxes, each with a year written on it.
“What are those?” whispered Leo.
“The house’s memories,” said David. “Photos, drawings, letters. From every year since it opened. Fifty years.” He laid the violin carefully on the rocking chair. “I’m up here because I’m looking for something in them. And because I’m practising.”
Amy looked at his sleeve. “And the white powder?”
David picked up a small, amber, see-through lump from the stand, like a round boiled sweet. “Rosin,” he said. “It’s made from pine resin. You rub it on the bow so it grips the strings and sings. It crumbles and gets everywhere. On sleeves, on handles, on stairs.” He smiled. “A good detective would track me down by it.”
“A good detective did,” said Hutie.
“She did,” David agreed, looking at Amy. “A very good one.”
He sat on a box, and they all sat on the rug in front of him, Shira at the edge with her knees under her chin.
“You know I was a child here,” said David.
“We knew,” said Amy. “Because of Benny’s boots.”
“Of course.” David chuckled. “I came to Hilltop House when I was eight. Like Leo. I was a small, quiet boy with big ears, and I didn’t talk to anyone. At all. For half a year I didn’t say a word.” He looked at the round window. “Back then there was a woman here called Tova. The wife of the man who built the house. She was a music teacher, and she used to bring children up here, to the attic, and teach them to play. Nobody was made to. Whoever wanted to, came.”
“And you wanted to,” said Leo.
“I didn’t,” said David. “I just stood in the doorway and watched. A whole week I stood in the doorway. The next week Tova held out a violin to me and didn’t say anything. And I took it.” He touched the old violin. “This one. She left it to me.”
He got up, opened one of the boxes, which had a very old year written on it in faded marker, and took out a black-and-white photo. In it stood a small, thin boy with very big ears and a violin almost as big as he was. Behind him stood a woman with white hair pinned up and a wide smile, her hand resting on his shoulder.
“That’s you,” whispered Hutie.
“That’s me,” said David. “That’s what I was looking for. I wanted her with me at the celebration. In my pocket, at least.”
He slipped the photo into his jumper pocket, carefully, and without thinking Amy touched the blue button inside her jumper.
Nobody spoke. The pigeon on the beam stretched a wing and folded it back.
“Tova wrote a song for the house,” David went on. “The Hilltop Song. She said every home needs a song, so the people who leave can take it with them. And I…” He hesitated. “I left at eighteen. I took the violin, but I stopped playing. Life, work, things. But I didn’t want to forget the song. So I started whistling it. Every day. For thirty years.”
“That’s the song,” breathed Hutie. “The one you whistle.”
“That’s the song,” said David.
“And Mrs. Cohen asked you to play it,” said Amy, “at the fiftieth celebration. That’s the surprise. ‘D. – check if ready.'”
David stared at her, then shook his head. “You really are something,” he said. “Yes. She asked. And I said yes, because who says no to Mrs. Cohen? Then I came up here and opened the violin case for the first time in thirty years, and my fingers…” He held up his big, rough hand, the hand of someone who fixes taps and changes bulbs. “They’d forgotten everything. So I started practising at night, when everyone was asleep, so nobody would hear. And I stopped whistling, so nobody would recognise the tune and guess what was going on.” He smiled sadly. “Worked brilliantly, as you can see.”
“It worked for three nights,” said Leo fairly.
“And the mistake?” Amy asked gently. “In the middle?”
David sighed. “The broken step,” he said. “That’s what Tova called it. There’s a hard jump there, from a low note to a high one. I never managed it. Not even as a boy. And now, not at all.” He looked at his hands. “In two weeks the Great Hall will be full. All the children, all the staff, all the former residents, people who lived here forty years ago. And I’ll stand there with Tova’s violin, and I’ll reach the broken step, and…”
He didn’t finish. He didn’t need to.
Amy looked at him, this giant in a brown jumper with a spider called Morris, who fixed everything in Hilltop House. She thought of Benny, who didn’t know how to ask. Of Tom, who was afraid of shouting. Of Maya, who wasn’t afraid any more. And she thought that grown-ups, too, sometimes need someone to hold their hand on the broken step.
“David,” she said, “what if you weren’t alone on the step?”
“What do you mean?”
“What if, right there, the whole house sang?”
David looked at her. At the edge of the rug, Shira lifted her head, and her eyes shone.
“A choir,” said Shira. “A secret choir. I’ll play guitar. We’ll rehearse in the laundry room, where nobody can hear anything over the machines.”
“And we won’t tell Mrs. Cohen,” said Hutie excitedly. “A surprise inside a surprise!”
“Like a Russian doll,” said Leo.
And David, for the first time that night, laughed properly.
For two weeks, after supper, Hilltop House vanished into the laundry room.
It wasn’t easy. On the first evening the boys stood on one side and the girls on the other, and each side tried to sing louder. Omer shouted so hard his voice cracked, and Alice and Penny sang so high that Falafel, who had come along in his basket, hid under the socks. Shira stopped playing.
“It isn’t a contest,” she said. “It’s a song. You don’t sing a song against anybody. You sing it together.”
On the second evening she arranged them differently: boy, girl, boy, girl. At first everyone complained. Then, halfway through the song, something happened. The voices mixed, high and low, and the little room filled with one big, warm sound, like a blanket. When they finished, nobody said anything. Not even Omer.
Oliver painted an enormous banner, orange of course, and hid it behind the tumble dryer. Tom learned all the words by heart, even the hard ones. And Zehava, who discovered the secret on the third day because she heard singing coming out of a washing machine, joined the rehearsals with the Queen in her hand and sang in a deep, beautiful voice nobody knew she had.
And Thursday came.
The Great Hall was packed. Children, staff, and former residents from every year, grey-haired people who looked at the walls and smiled like people coming home. Benny’s gran sat in the front row. Mrs. Cohen gave a speech, and Ruti gave a speech, and then Mrs. Cohen said, “And now, a surprise.”
David walked onto the stage. In a suit. Nobody had ever seen David in a suit, and there was a moment of total silence, and then someone at the back shouted “Davey!” and everyone laughed, and David went red to the ears.
He lifted Tova’s violin, and played.
The tune rose, and fell, and rose again. It was even lovelier than at night. Amy, waiting with the choir behind the curtain, saw the former residents begin to hum softly, because they remembered. And then, as David reached the broken step, she saw his hand tremble.
Shira strummed her guitar, the curtain swept open, and the whole of Hilltop House sang.
Boys and girls, little ones and big ones, first graders and sixth graders, with Zehava in the middle. They sang right at the hard part, and their voices wrapped round the violin like hands, and David crossed the broken step without even noticing. He turned, saw them, and stopped playing for a moment, because he couldn’t play and cry at the same time. Then he went on.
When the song ended, the whole hall rose to its feet. Then someone started to dance. Amy didn’t see who; Tom, perhaps, or Maya. Within a minute everyone was dancing, children and grown-ups, David with his violin, Zehava with Ruti, and even Mrs. Cohen, wiping her eyes under the glasses on their chain, danced with Leo.
In the middle of it all, David slipped out. A minute later, from the coop outside, came the thin ring of the brass bell, and at once, through the open windows, Kuku answered with the longest, proudest crow anyone had ever heard from him. Sugar whinnied over the fence as if he wanted to join in. The hall burst out laughing, and the former residents, who remembered other roosters and other ponies, laughed loudest.
As the guests were leaving, an elderly woman stopped by Amy, stroked her hair and said, “You sang the way we used to. Look after that song.”
Mrs. Cohen wrote twenty points in the Together column. “For the song,” she said. “And for the house.”
That night, Amy wrote in her notebook:
Case Number 9: A Tune From the Attic. Solved. Who was playing: David. Why in secret: he was afraid of the broken step. What I learned: nobody should have to cross the broken step alone.
She slid the notebook under her pillow, as she did every night, and fell asleep with the tune in her head.
But in the morning, when she put her hand under the pillow, the notebook wasn’t there.