Amy looked everywhere.
Under the pillow, of course, three times. Under the mattress. Between the sheets. Under the bed, where she found one sock, two hairgrips and a biscuit crumb she didn’t remember eating. She searched the pockets of her jumper and the pockets of her coat, inside her shoes, and inside Falafel’s basket, in case he had started eating paper again.
Falafel gave her a deeply offended look, like a rabbit who remembered very well being accused once before, and went on chewing a lettuce leaf. There was no notebook in his sock nest.
“Sorry,” Amy told him. “I had to check.”
She sat down on the floor in the middle of Room 7 and felt something she hadn’t felt for a long time. She felt empty.
It was only a notebook, she told herself. A small notebook with a brown cover and dog-eared corners. But it wasn’t only a notebook. Ruti had given it to her on her first night at Hilltop House, a year ago, when Amy sat on this very bed with one small bag and couldn’t fall asleep. “When you’re frightened,” Ruti had told her, “it helps to look carefully at what’s around you. And write it down. That way the fear gets smaller and the world gets bigger.”
And Amy wrote. From that night on, she wrote everything. Zehava’s spoon. The ghost in the linen cupboard. Tom’s Points Board, the jay, Leo’s drawings, the hundred puddings, Sugar’s bolt, Benny’s shoes, David’s violin. Nine cases. And between the cases, in the margins, in tiny writing, she had written other things too. Things she had never told anyone. What her mother’s voice sounded like. What her coat smelled like. What she wanted to say to her, if one day she saw her again.
And now it was all gone.
“Amy?” Hutie stood in the doorway with a towel over her shoulder. “What’s wrong?”
“My notebook,” said Amy, and her voice came out small. “It’s gone.”
Hutie said nothing. That was strange, because Hutie always said something. Instead she went red, from her neck to her forehead, and then said, far too quickly, “I’ll… I’ll look in the bathroom!” and vanished.
Amy stared after her. Without thinking, her hand went to her pocket, to the notebook, to write it down. And the pocket was empty.
That was the hardest part, she discovered that day. Not knowing where the notebook was, but not knowing what to do with her hands. Every time she noticed something, she wanted to write it down. And there was nowhere to write.
By breakfast, the whole table knew.
“Maybe the ghost took it,” said Omer, winking at Yonatan. “The attic ghost. Revenge for the garlic.”
“There’s no ghost,” said Maya firmly, before Amy could open her mouth. “It was David. Everybody knows that.”
“Maybe Oliver,” suggested a fifth grader.
Oliver threw up both hands, one of them holding a spoonful of porridge. “Me? I never touch Amy’s notebook! I’m scared of it! It’s always writing about me!”
“No blaming without proof,” said Amy quietly. The whole table went silent, because everyone knew those words, but nobody had ever heard them said so sadly.
She looked round. Hutie sat at the end of the table and didn’t lift her eyes from her plate. Leo sat beside her, and something about him was odd. At first Amy couldn’t tell what. Then she saw it: a ruler sticking out of his pocket. Leo always carried a notebook and a compass. Never a ruler.
“Leo,” she said, “why have you got a ruler?”
Leo jumped so hard he knocked over his cup. “For maths!” he said. “We’re doing… geometry.”
“We’re not in the same class,” said Amy. “And you hate geometry.”
“I’ve started liking it,” said Leo, and looked at Hutie, and Hutie looked at her plate.
Amy said nothing. But something small and prickly began to grow in her stomach.
After school, the girls of Room 7 decided they knew who was to blame.
“The boys,” said Penny, folding her arms. “It’s revenge. For the shoes, the slippers, the garlic. They’ve taken our detective’s notebook so she can’t solve anything.”
“So we go to their wing,” said Alice, “and look under every bed.”
“No,” said Amy.
They all looked at her.
“No more wars,” she said. “We’ve had a pillow war and a shoe war. And every time, in the end, it turned out nobody was bad. So we’re not starting a war over a notebook. Even if it’s mine.”
Alice and Penny looked at each other. Then, slowly, Penny nodded. “All right,” she said. “But if you need an army, we’re here.”
Later, before supper, Amy found out she was still a detective, even without a notebook. Little Tom came to her in tears because his dinosaur pillow had disappeared. And Amy, without writing anything, closed her eyes and remembered: that morning, in the laundry room, she had seen Miri load a pile of pillowcases into the machine. And among them, she was sure, had been something green and spiky. They ran to the laundry room together and found the dinosaur on the line, clean and sweet-smelling and smiling.
“How did you know?” asked Tom.
“I remembered,” said Amy, a little surprised herself.
Tom hugged the dinosaur, then hugged Amy, hard, with the dinosaur squashed in between. “You’re the best detective in the world,” he said. “Even without a notebook.” And Amy, for the first time since the morning, smiled.
Meanwhile, the strange things kept piling up. And without her notebook, Amy had to do something she had never done before: remember. She lined the clues up in her head, one after another, like beads on a string.
Bead one: at lunchtime, Leo came up to her in the yard and, for no reason at all, measured the pocket of her jumper with his ruler. “For science,” he explained, wrote something in his notebook, and walked off.
Bead two: in the afternoon, Hutie wasn’t braiding bracelets. For the first time since Amy had known her, her pockets weren’t stuffed with coloured string. When Amy asked why, she hid her hands behind her back. But not quickly enough. On two fingers of her left hand were little plasters.
Bead three: in the evening, Hutie and Leo disappeared. They weren’t in Room 7, or the dining hall, or the games room. When Amy asked Shira where they were, Shira said “No idea” and smiled, and it was the least convincing smile Amy had seen since Oliver’s on the day of the spoon.
And then came bead four, and that one hurt most of all.
At night, when Amy got into bed, she found on the sheet, right where her pillow had been that morning, a thread. A thin embroidery thread, as long as a finger. Blue. Exactly the blue of the button inside her jumper.
Amy held it up to the little lamp. There was no doubt. In all of Hilltop House, only one person had pockets full of thread.
She looked at Hutie’s bed. Hutie was already asleep, or pretending to be, with her back turned.
Amy lay in the dark with the blue thread in her hand and felt the prickly thing in her stomach grow and grow. Hutie. Her best friend. The one who had shared Room 7 with her from the very first day, who had climbed into her bed when she was homesick, who had held her hand at the attic door. Why would Hutie take her notebook? And why was Leo helping? And why wouldn’t they say anything?
Sometimes, Amy thought, the hardest thing isn’t not knowing. The hardest thing is knowing a little, and not understanding.
To fall asleep, she did what she had done on her first night: she looked carefully at what she had. Only this time, she looked inside. She went through the cases one by one, without a notebook. The spoon. The ghost. The board. The jay. The drawings. The puddings. The bolt. The shoes. The violin. She remembered all of it. Every clue, every face, every laugh. Then, quietly, she tried to remember the things in the margins too. Her mother’s voice. The smell of the coat. And they were there. Not in the notebook. In her.
That helped a bit. But only a bit.
She didn’t cry. Almost not. Just a little, into her pillow, quietly, so nobody would hear.
The next morning, she went to Sugar.
She didn’t know why. Her feet just took her there. She sat on the upturned bucket where Benny used to sit, rested her head on the fence, and Sugar chewed her braid, the way he did to anyone who sat there. And David, passing with a wheelbarrow full of leaves, stopped.
He was whistling. Since the celebration he had gone back to whistling the Hilltop Song, every day, loudly, without hiding. But when he saw Amy’s face, he stopped.
“What’s up, detective?”
Amy told him. About the notebook. The ruler. The plasters. The blue thread. She didn’t say any names, but David was no fool.
He was quiet for a long time, stroking Sugar’s nose.
“Do you remember,” he said at last, “the Points Board? Tom’s?”
“Yes.”
“And when everyone thought someone was cheating, what turned out to be true?”
“That he wanted nobody to lose,” Amy said slowly.
“And Benny’s shoes? And the drawings under Leo’s pillow? And my violin?” David rested a big hand on her shoulder. “You’ve taught this whole house something this year, Amy. That when someone does something strange, sometimes there’s a good reason. Even a lovely one. You never judge before you know why.” He smiled. “Don’t forget that now, of all times. Now that it’s about you.”
Amy lifted her head from the fence.
“David,” she said, “you know something.”
“I know lots of things,” said David, picking up the wheelbarrow. “I know how to fix taps, change bulbs, and play one song on the violin with a broken step in the middle.” And off he went, whistling, and it was the least innocent whistle she had ever heard.
Amy sat a moment longer and lined the beads up again. But this time she didn’t ask “who”. She asked “why”.
Why was Leo measuring her pocket? Because he needed to know how big something could be and still fit inside.
Why did Hutie have plasters on her fingers? Because whoever sews a lot gets pricked a lot.
And why was the thread blue? Because someone wanted something to be the colour of her mother’s button.
And there was one more thing, something she had seen the morning before and not paid attention to, because she’d had nowhere to write it down. Passing Ruti’s office, she had seen the calendar on the wall. And someone, in red pen, had circled tomorrow’s date.
Amy knew that date. She knew it the way you know your own name. It was the day she had arrived at Hilltop House, with one small bag, exactly a year ago.
She got up from the bucket, and her heart was racing, the way it always did when a mystery began to open. But this time it was a different kind of racing. A warm kind.
“I think I know who took my notebook,” she whispered to Sugar. “And I think I know why.”
Sugar gave a small whinny, as if to say: at last.