There are things you can do with one shoe. You can hop. You can use it as a flowerpot. You can, as Oliver suggested, turn it into a telephone. But you can’t play football in it, and you can’t walk to school in it.
Which was exactly the boys’ wing’s problem on Tuesday morning.
“My shoe!” yelled Itai from fifth grade, hopping down the corridor on one foot. “My right one! It was here! By my bed!”
“Mine too!” yelled Omer. “My left!”
“And mine!”
“And mine!”
Noam went from room to room with a list, counting. Room Three was missing one shoe. Room Four, two. Room Five, one, and Room Six, two more. Six shoes from six different pairs. Never a whole pair.
“Who takes one shoe?” Noam asked the ceiling. “What do you do with one shoe?”
“Flowerpot,” suggested Oliver.
“Oliver, not now.”
The boys came to breakfast in slippers, flip-flops and socks. Itai arrived in one trainer and one welly, looking like someone heading to two different parties at once.
And the girls laughed.
That was the mistake. Because the boys looked at the laughing girls, and the girls looked at the furious boys, and everyone remembered, all at once, the night of the pillows.
“It’s you,” said Omer slowly. “Again. Like the pillows.”
“Us?” Alice put down her spoon. “We signed a peace treaty! We folded your pyjamas for ten days!”
“And ever since, you’ve been waiting for your chance.”
“Nobody’s waiting for any chance! We don’t touch your shoes. They stink!”
“Then why are you laughing?”
“Because Itai’s wearing one welly!”
Amy, at the end of the table, watched it happen. She saw Omer’s cheeks go red, and Alice sit up straighter, and Penny’s look, the look of a twin already plotting something. She saw it the way you see a heavy cloud rolling closer before rain.
“Leo,” she whispered. “We have to stop this.”
“You can’t stop it,” said Leo, who had thought about it seriously. “It’s like a wheel rolling downhill. You can only get out of the way.”
He was right.
That evening, when the girls came back from their showers, they found that all their slippers had vanished. Every single pair. Bunny slippers, star slippers, Roni’s fluffy slippers that looked like two small puppies. In their place, on every bed, was a note: “Now you know how it feels. – The Boys.”
And in the morning, the boys found that every lace in every shoe they had left had been swapped for pink thread. Every lace. Pink. Tied in especially complicated knots, the kind only one person in the house knew how to tie.
“Hutie!” said Amy.
“I’m only a supplier,” said Hutie, turning pink herself. “Alice ordered them. I didn’t ask why.”
“Hutie.”
“All right, all right. I knew why.”
And so began the Great Shoe War of Hilltop House.
On Wednesday every boy went to school in pink laces, because there was no time to change them. They marched in a line, heads high, as if pink were the toughest colour in the world, and nobody at school dared laugh, except the PE teacher, who laughed until he had to sit down.
The girls, meanwhile, padded around the house in socks, and their feet froze on the tiles. Roni said she couldn’t feel her toes any more. Maya said she could, but only her little toe, and that frightened her.
Zehava stood in the kitchen doorway watching it all, the pink laces and the frozen socks, shaking her head.
“In my day,” she said, “we fought about important things. The ball. The window seat. Who got to sit next to the counselor. Not shoes. Shoes are for walking, not for fighting.”
“What did you do in your day when someone started it?” asked Hutie.
“We got the cook’s broom,” said Zehava, raising the Queen threateningly. “You tell them that.”
Mrs. Cohen said nothing. She simply walked down the corridor, looked at the pink laces and the socks, put on her glasses, and said to Shira and Noam, in a voice everyone could hear: “I am giving them until Friday. If by Friday every shoe, every slipper and every lace has not been returned, there will be no final.”
And Amy saw, in a corner, one person who wasn’t laughing, wasn’t angry and wasn’t joining in. Someone sitting alone by the window with his feet tucked under his chair, like someone hiding something. But just then Hutie dragged her off to lunch, and she forgot.
And the war had come at the worst possible time.
Because on Friday was the final.
The inter-house football final. Once a year, Hilltop House played Pine House from the next town, for the small shiny cup that had stood on the shelf in their office for three years running. And this year, for the first time, Hilltop House had a mixed team: boys and girls together. Mrs. Cohen had decided it, “for the Together column.” Alice and Penny were the strikers, the fastest in the house. Benny was in goal. And Benny, everyone knew, was the best goalkeeper Hilltop House had ever had.
But now half the team wasn’t speaking to the other half. The boys were training in flip-flops. And the girls were training in socks, because they had no slippers to walk to the pitch in.
“This is a disaster,” Shira told Noam by the pitch on Wednesday.
“It’s worse than a disaster,” said Noam. “It’s football.”
Amy sat on the bench beside the pitch with her notebook, Hutie and Leo next to her, and watched the training. Or what was left of it. Alice shot at goal, and Benny saved it. Penny shot, and Benny saved it. Nobody said “Nice one.” Nobody said anything.
Amy opened her notebook and began to write down what she knew.
Missing shoes: Itai, Omer, Yonatan, Shahar, Roy, Aviv.
“Leo,” she asked, “do you have the shoe sizes?”
Leo took out his notebook. Of course he did. On Tuesday, while everyone was shouting, he had gone quietly from room to room copying the number from inside every shoe that had been left on its own.
“Itai, thirty-seven. Omer, thirty-six. Yonatan, thirty-seven. Shahar, thirty-seven. Roy, thirty-six. Aviv, thirty-seven.”
“They’re all thirty-six or thirty-seven,” Amy said slowly.
“And mine are thirty-three, and nobody touched them,” said Leo. “Nobody touched Tom’s flashing ones either. Or Oliver’s boots, size forty, because he bought them big to leave room for paint.”
“So whoever took them,” said Hutie, “wasn’t just taking shoes. They were looking for a size.”
“And the girls,” said Amy, “why would the girls look for a size? If you want revenge, you take everything. Like the boys with the slippers. Like Alice and Penny with the pillows.”
She wrote: Sizes 36–37 only. Someone looking for shoes that fit. Not revenge.
Then she got up, walked to the edge of the pitch, and stood in front of Alice, who had just come off red-faced from running.
“Alice,” she said. “One question. And I want a true answer. Did you girls take the boys’ shoes?”
Alice looked at her, then at Penny, who came closer. The twins exchanged a look. Amy knew that look. It was the we’ve-got-a-secret look. But this time, something about it was different.
“We took the pillows,” said Alice. “And we swapped the laces, fine. But not the shoes. I swear on Sugar.”
“And on Falafel,” added Penny.
“And on the cup,” said Alice.
Amy believed her. Not because of the swearing. Because whenever Alice lied, she touched her ear. And this time her hands stayed on her hips.
“There’s something else,” said Leo, when Amy came back to the bench. “This morning, two shoes came back.”
“Came back?”
“Omer’s and Shahar’s. They were at the entrance to the wing, by the door, side by side. But…” He hesitated. “They were covered in mud. Wet mud. As if someone had walked in them in the rain. And Omer says his lace was tied differently. In a strange double knot he doesn’t know how to do.”
Amy looked up from her notebook. “Mud,” she said. “Did it rain last night?”
Leo checked his weather notebook. “A bit. Between eleven and midnight.”
“And where is there mud at Hilltop House after rain?”
“In the vegetable patch,” said Hutie. “By Sugar’s paddock. And…”
All three of them looked at the pitch. At the smooth green grass David watered every day. And at the two goals at either end. In front of the goal where Benny stood right now, exactly where a goalkeeper stands, the grass had worn away long ago, and all that was left was a big square of bare earth. Earth that turned to mud every time it rained.
After training, when everyone had gone, Amy, Hutie and Leo went down onto the pitch.
They walked to the goal. Benny’s goal. The sun was low now, and the shadows of the goalposts stretched across the grass like two tall thin people lying down for a rest.
The mud in front of the goal had started to dry, but it was still soft. And in it, right in front of the white line, were prints. Lots of shoeprints. Prints from today’s training, of flip-flops and socks. But under them, deeper, older, Amy could see more prints. Prints made when the mud was very wet. At night.
She crouched and studied them.
“There’s a sole with triangles,” she said. “And here, one with straight lines. And here, little circles. And here…” She stopped. “Leo. These prints are all the same size, but different soles. A different person each night?”
Leo crouched beside her and measured with his fingers. “Or one person,” he said slowly, “in different shoes.”
“And he stood here,” said Hutie. “In goal. And jumped. Look. The prints go to one side, then the other, as if he was diving.”
“Like a goalkeeper,” said Leo.
Amy said nothing. She stood and searched further. By the goalpost, by the net, something silver gleamed in the mud. She picked it up. It was a long, sticky strip of silver tape, the strong kind David used to mend pipes. It was crumpled and dirty, as if someone had ripped it off something.
And underneath it, caught in the net, was a shoelace. An old white lace, tied in a strange double knot. A knot Amy had seen before, she knew, but couldn’t remember where.
“That’s the knot Omer described,” whispered Leo.
Hutie took the lace and turned it in her fingers, and an expression came over her face, the serious look of a true expert.
“That’s not just any knot,” she said. “It’s a goalkeeper’s knot. A double knot that doesn’t come undone even when you dive. Someone taught it to me once. Someone in this house.” She swallowed. “In third grade.”
“Who?” asked Amy, although she could already see the answer in Hutie’s eyes.
And at that moment, Amy remembered. She remembered the morning of the pudding. Benny, standing by the door with his hands in his pockets. And something she had seen then and not written down, because her head was full of chocolate: Benny’s right shoe. Its sole had come away at the front, like a crocodile’s mouth, and someone had tried to stick it back with silver tape.
She looked at the silver strip in her hand.
“I know whose knot this is,” she whispered.