Amy the little detective with a magnifying glass and her friends in the yard

Amy the Detective, Chapter 14: Night Watch

Nobody in the storeroom breathed. Not Amy, not Hutie, not Leo, and certainly not Oliver.

Nobody in the storeroom breathed. Not Amy, not Hutie, not Leo, and certainly not Oliver.

Even Morris the spider, Amy would have sworn, stopped moving on his beam.

In the moonlight they could see Sugar standing by the paddock gate. His head was raised, and he was holding something in his mouth. Not just something. The bolt’s small, shiny handle. He held it between his lips with astonishing gentleness, like someone holding a thin biscuit they don’t want to snap.

Then he lifted it a little. And pulled.

The bolt slid sideways, slowly, out of its ring. Click.

“It can’t be,” whispered Leo, and his pencil fell out of his hand.

“Shhh,” whispered everyone.

Sugar pushed the gate with his forehead. It swung open with a small creak, and Sugar stepped out into the yard with quiet, contented steps, like someone setting off on his usual evening stroll.

And then he did the thing nobody expected.

He stopped. He turned round. He pushed the gate shut again with his bottom. Then he took the handle in his lips once more and slid the bolt back into its ring. Click. And then, and this was the part Hutie told the whole of Hilltop House about for a month afterwards, he touched the bolt with his nose. Once. And once more.

“He’s checking,” Oliver whispered in a strangled voice. “He’s checking twice. Like David.”

“Six years he’s watched David do it every evening,” Amy whispered. “Every evening at eight, the same movement. He learned. He simply learned.”

Hutie stuffed her entire blanket into her mouth so as not to laugh out loud.

Amy glanced at Noam to see if he’d seen. Noam hadn’t seen. Noam was asleep. He sat with his back against the wall, his cocoa mug on his knees, his mouth open, snoring a small, gentle snore, like a faraway kettle.

“Shouldn’t we wake him?” whispered Leo.

“In a minute,” said Amy. “First let’s see where Sugar goes.”

Sugar walked slowly across the grass in the silver light. He didn’t run. He didn’t leap. He didn’t look like a pony escaping. He looked like someone searching for something.

First he went to the vegetable patch. There, in the middle of the beds, stood the scarecrow. David had stood it up again after it fell and tied it more firmly to its pole, and now it was upright once more, with its orange nose and its coloured-thread arms stirring a little in the breeze. Sugar went up to it and stood beside it. Right up close. He rested his head on the scarecrow’s shoulder and let out a long breath.

He didn’t eat any carrots. He just stood there.

“What’s he doing?” whispered Hutie, and this time she wasn’t laughing.

Amy didn’t answer. She was watching.

After a few minutes Sugar left the scarecrow and went to the washing line. It was empty except for one forgotten towel, a little pink towel belonging to one of the girls. Sugar put his nose to it and sniffed it for a long time. Then he moved on, to the main gate, to the spot where Mrs. Cohen’s car was parked during the day. It wasn’t there now, because Mrs. Cohen had driven to town that evening. But Sugar stood in the empty space, under the big dining-hall window, and lifted his head towards the dark glass, like someone waiting for a light to come on.

And Amy understood.

She understood all at once, the way you suddenly get a joke. Only this wasn’t a joke.

“He isn’t escaping,” she whispered. “He’s looking for people.”

“What?” whispered Oliver.

“Think about it,” said Amy, quietly and quickly. “The scarecrow: it looks like a person, and it smells of our old clothes. The washing line: it smells of children. And Mrs. Cohen’s car parks right under the dining-hall window. That’s where you can hear everyone in the evening. The voices, the laughing, Zehava singing.”

“And David,” Leo said suddenly. “David said that in winter he goes home early. Half past eight. He used to sit out here by the storeroom till ten, with the radio.”

“With the radio,” Amy repeated. “Six years, every evening, Sugar stood by the fence listening to David and his radio. And now winter’s come, and David goes home early, and the yard gets dark and quiet. And he hasn’t got anyone.”

“He’s lonely,” whispered Hutie.

They looked at Sugar, the small, plump pony standing alone in the moonlight under a dark window, and suddenly nobody wanted to laugh at all.

Then Sugar lowered his head, turned, and began to walk. Straight towards them.

“He’s coming,” whispered Leo. “He’s seen us.”

“He hasn’t seen us,” said Amy. “He’s heard us. Or smelled the cocoa.”

Sugar reached the open storeroom door, stopped, and put his head inside. He looked at each of them in turn: Amy, Hutie, Leo, sleeping Noam. And then he came to Oliver.

He lowered his head slowly and laid it in Oliver’s lap, on the blanket. And he breathed out a long, warm breath, the breath of someone who has finally found what he was looking for.

Oliver didn’t move. He just put a hand on the white mane, and Amy saw his lip tremble.

“Hey, Sugar,” he whispered. “Hey. I’m here.”

They sat like that for a long time. Four children, one pony and one spider, in a small storeroom in the middle of a winter night. Then Noam gave a snore so enormous that Sugar threw up his head in alarm, and Noam woke with a jolt and spilled all his cocoa down his trousers.

“What? What’s happened? Has he got out?” Noam leapt to his feet. “I’m awake! I’m completely awake!”

“He got out,” said Hutie. “And he came back. And he shut the gate. And checked it twice. And you were asleep.”

Noam looked at Sugar standing in the doorway, at his own soggy trousers, and at four children gazing at him with very serious faces.

“Nobody tells Mrs. Cohen I fell asleep,” he said.

“It’ll cost you,” said Hutie.

“How much?”

“Three orange bottle caps.”

When they got back to Room Seven after midnight, Amy and Hutie walked slowly down the corridor, wrapped in blankets, their feet frozen. The house was silent. Only Falafel, in his basket by Maya’s bed, raised one ear as they came in.

“Amy,” Hutie whispered once they were lying down. “Do you think what happened to Sugar happens to us too?”

“What do you mean?”

“That we look for people. At night. Even when we don’t know we’re looking.”

Amy was quiet for a moment. She thought about the blue button. About the moments before sleep when the room was full of girls and yet something in it was empty.

“Sometimes,” she said.

Hutie stretched out a hand from her bed, across the little gap between them, and found Amy’s hand in the dark.

“Then you should know,” she whispered, “that I’m here. Like the scarecrow. Only with more string.”

Amy laughed softly and held her hand until they both fell asleep.

The next morning, before breakfast, everyone gathered by the paddock. Ruti, David, Mrs. Cohen, Shira, Zehava with the Queen, and half the children. And Noam, in clean trousers, with the face of a man who had never fallen asleep in his life.

Leo demonstrated with his notebook. Amy explained. And Hutie, of course, acted out Sugar shutting the gate and checking it twice, with her nostrils, and three children rolled about on the grass laughing.

But when Amy got to the part about being lonely, everyone went quiet.

David took off his cap. “Oh, Sugar,” he said softly. “Oh, my old friend. I never noticed.”

“None of us noticed,” said Ruti. Then she turned to Oliver. For the first time anyone could remember, her mug wasn’t in her hand. She’d put it down on the fence.

“Oliver,” she said. “I’m sorry. I said I’d take your paints without knowing. I was tired, and cross, and I’m… I’m your mum. I should have believed you.”

Oliver looked at her, and Amy waited for the wrong-sized smile, the demand for a written apology, in orange, on the board. But he didn’t ask for anything. He just hugged her. Hard. In the middle of the yard, in front of everyone, and nobody laughed.

“It’s all right, Mum,” he said into her jumper. “It really did look like me.”

“It always looks like you,” said Ruti, and laughed, and wiped her eyes.

Mrs. Cohen cleared her throat and put on her glasses. “So we have two problems,” she said. “Problem one: we have a pony who can open a bolt. Problem two: we have a lonely pony. David?”

“Problem one I’ll fix today,” said David. “A spring clip, the kind you need two hands to open. Sugar has many talents, but hands aren’t one of them.”

“And problem two?”

Nobody spoke. Then little Tom, in his flashing trainers, put up his hand.

“We could say good night to him,” he said. “Every evening. A different child each time. Then he’s not alone.”

“And the radio,” said Leo. “We could leave him a radio. Quietly. With music.”

“And the scarecrow,” said Hutie. “We’ll move the scarecrow next to him. So he’s got a friend at night. I’ll braid it a scarf.”

Mrs. Cohen looked at them, and her mouth moved, just a little, on one side. “Approved,” she said. “All three. Boys and girls, every evening, taking turns. Shira, make a list.”

“And I,” announced Zehava, raising the Queen like a sceptre, “will make sure there’s an apple waiting in the kitchen every evening. A red one. A good one. Not a sad one.” She looked at Sugar. “And you, sir, will stop eating Ruti’s carrots. If you’re hungry, you come to me. Like everyone else.”

And so the Hilltop House Good Night Rota was born.

Every evening at a quarter past eight, after David had fastened the new spring clip, one child went out into the yard with an apple and said good night to Sugar. Some told him about their day. Some sang to him. Tom read him a story, although he couldn’t read yet, so he made it up. And Benny, who said he had no intention of joining in such nonsense, stayed out for forty minutes on his turn, and Shira found him sitting on a bucket with Sugar’s head on his shoulder, telling him about his gran.

In the shed, on a shelf, David left a little old radio that played all night, very softly, gentle music. And the scarecrow stood by the fence in an orange scarf Hutie had braided, with a little sign Oliver had painted: “SUGAR’S RADIO STATION. DO NOT DISTURB. PRESENTER ASLEEP.”

And every morning, Sugar was exactly where he should be. Inside his paddock, calm, head on the fence, waiting for his morning apple.

Amy wrote:

Case Number 7: Sugar on the Loose. Solved. Who opened it: Sugar. Who shut it: Sugar. Who checked it twice: Sugar. Why: he was lonely. What I learned: sometimes whoever runs away doesn’t want to leave. He wants to be found.

She looked at that last sentence for a moment and thought about the blue button. Then she closed her notebook.

The next morning, in the boys’ wing, there was a shout. Then another. And another. And within five minutes it turned out that lots of pairs of shoes in the wing were missing one shoe. Just one.

Amy the Detective, Chapter 14: Night Watch - Like Likro - books to read online