Amy the little detective with a magnifying glass and her friends in the yard

Amy the Detective, Chapter 12: The Eaten Note

"If you were a rabbit," said Amy, "and you'd eaten a note, what would you do with the leftovers?"

“If you were a rabbit,” said Amy, “and you’d eaten a note, what would you do with the leftovers?”

“I’m not a rabbit,” said Leo.

“Imagine.”

Leo shut his eyes in concentration, like someone imagining with all his might that he had long ears. “I’d… take it home?”

“Exactly,” said Amy. “Falafel takes everything home. Socks, shoelaces, Hutie’s threads. He collects.”

“Like the jay,” said Hutie.

“Like the jay. Only with more teeth.”

They ran to Room Seven. Falafel was sitting in his basket beside Maya’s bed, on the pink spotted sock, calmly munching a lettuce leaf, one and a half of them, just as Zehava had promised. When they burst in, he raised his left ear and gave them the look of someone who realises his house is about to be searched.

“Sorry, Falafel,” said Hutie, lifting him gently. “It’s for the pudding. You’ll understand.”

Falafel did not understand. He kicked the air with his back legs, like someone demanding to speak to the manager.

Amy slid her hands into the basket, between the socks, slowly and carefully, the way she had searched for the spoon in Sugar’s straw. A sock. Another sock. A blue shoelace. A red thread, half eaten, which Hutie recognised at once and cried “There it is!” Another sock. And then, down at the bottom, in the corner, her fingers touched paper.

She drew out two scraps. Bigger than the first, but they too had nibbled edges, little curved bites all along their borders.

She spread them on Maya’s bed and laid the scrap from the kitchen beside them. All three of them bent over. Even Falafel, in Hutie’s arms, stretched out his nose.

The first scrap said, in the same blue pen and the same round, tidy handwriting: “Zehava, the fridge’s bro…”

The second: “…I’ve moved the puddings to the co…”

And the scrap from the kitchen: “…ld cel…”

They laid them side by side, shuffled them, swapped them round, like a three-piece jigsaw. Then Hutie read aloud, slowly, her eyes getting bigger with every word:

“Zehava… the fridge’s bro… broken! …I’ve moved the puddings to the co… ld cel…”

“To the cold cellar,” said Leo.

“To the cold cellar!” yelled Hutie, and Falafel leapt out of her arms and fled under the bed. “They’re in the cellar! The puddings are in the cold cellar! And Miri wrote it! Miri’s not a thief, Miri’s a hero!”

Amy was already at the door. “The fridge broke in the night, after Zehava went home,” she said as they ran. “Miri noticed it wasn’t cooling. She knew the puddings would spoil by morning. So she carried them all down to the cellar, because it’s cold down there all night, and stuck a note on the fridge so Zehava would know. And then…”

“And then Falafel went out on his night walk,” panted Leo. “And found a tasty piece of paper on a door. Too high for him to reach.”

“But the tape didn’t hold,” said Amy. “Because the door was wet from the broken fridge. The note fell down. And Falafel…”

“…ate Miri,” finished Hutie. “I mean, Miri’s note.”

The cellar of Hilltop House was just as Amy remembered it from the night of the pillows: cold, dark, smelling of potatoes, with creaking stone steps. David switched on the light, a single yellow bulb swinging on its flex. And there, on the long shelves against the wall, beside Zehava’s crates, the sacks of onions and the jars of jam, they saw them.

Little glass cups. Row upon row. Full of dark chocolate pudding as smooth as silk, with whipped cream on top and a single chocolate flake in the middle, like a crown.

Zehava, who had come down the steps after them faster than anyone had ever seen her move, stopped dead. She put her hand on her heart.

“Miri,” she whispered. “My Miri.”

Then she did what any real cook would do. She counted.

“Ten, twenty, thirty…” She ran her finger along the rows, lips moving. “…seventy, eighty, ninety… ninety-six, ninety-seven, ninety-eight, ninety-nine.”

She stopped.

“Ninety-nine,” she said again.

Everyone looked at the shelf. There were ninety-nine full cups. And at the very end of the shelf, behind a jar of fig jam, was cup number one hundred.

Empty.

Completely empty, licked clean, with a little spoon inside. And on the glass, quite clearly, was a single fingerprint. An orange one.

Everyone turned slowly, all together, just like in a film, towards the steps. And there, at exactly that moment, as if he’d been booked for it, came Oliver, down the stairs with a tin of orange paint in one hand and a brush in the other, whistling.

He saw everyone. He saw the empty cup. He stopped whistling.

“Oh,” said Oliver. “You found the puddings.”

“Oliver,” said Zehava.

“I can explain,” said Oliver.

“You can always explain,” said Leo.

“Yes, it’s one of my talents.” Oliver set the paint down on a step. “This morning at six I came down here to get paint, because I keep my paints down here, because Mum says there’s no room in the flat for any more orange. And suddenly I saw a hundred puddings. In the cellar. And I thought, oh, Zehava’s hidden them here for the party. What a good idea. And then I thought, a hundred’s a lot. Nobody’ll notice one.” He swallowed. “Then I went up and painted the back of the hen-house fence, and I didn’t hear any screaming. I didn’t know everyone was looking for them. Honestly. I swear on all the colours.”

Zehava looked at him for a long time. Then, to everyone’s astonishment, she began to laugh. A big, deep laugh that rattled the jars on the shelves.

“Of course,” she said, wiping her eyes with her apron. “Of course it’s you. Who else finds a hundred puddings in a cellar and eats only one? Any other child would have eaten ten.”

“I’m very disciplined,” said Oliver modestly.

“You will wash all one hundred cups after the party,” said Zehava. “On your own. By hand. And on Sunday you’ll come with me to say thank you to Miri.”

“Fair enough,” Oliver agreed.

David, who had been standing quietly by the steps all this time, crouched by the shelf and checked a cup. “Cold,” he said. “Exactly cold enough. This cellar’s better than any fridge. My grandmother used to keep butter down here, back when the house was still a farm.”

“This was a farm?” asked Hutie.

“Once,” said David. “Before there were children here. There were cows and hens and two horses. Sugar’s actually the great-great-great-grandson of one of them. But that’s a story for another day.”

Amy wrote in the margin, very small: David – his grandmother lived here? Ask.

Then they got organised. Leo arranged everyone into a chain, like an old-fashioned bucket brigade: a child on the first step, a child on the second, a child at the door, a child in the corridor, and the cups passed from hand to hand, very carefully, all the way to the kitchen. Boys and girls together, and not a single cup broke. When Mrs. Cohen heard, she added three points to the Together column and called it “the first Pudding Chain in the history of Hilltop House, and I hope the last.”

But there was one more thing, and Amy hadn’t forgotten it for a moment. Because pudding can be found in a cellar, but a good name that’s been hurt has to be given back out loud, in front of everyone.

By the time the last cup reached the kitchen safely, Benny had come out of the office. He was standing in the corridor by the bench, with Maya beside him. And Penny, and Alice, and all the girls from Penny’s class were watching him from a distance.

Amy went over to him.

“Benny,” she said, in a voice everyone could hear. “The puddings have been found. All of them. Miri moved them to the cellar because the fridge broke, and Falafel ate the note she left. You had nothing to do with it. You never did.”

Silence fell over the corridor.

“But the chocolate,” said Penny quietly. “On his sleeve.”

Amy didn’t answer. It wasn’t her secret. She looked at Benny, and at Maya, and waited.

Maya tugged Benny’s sleeve. Benny looked at her, and she nodded. Then Benny sighed, the sigh of someone about to reveal something he’s slightly embarrassed about.

“Maya’s mum is coming to the party today,” he said. “For the first time since Maya came here. And Maya wanted to give her something. Something she’d made herself.” He shrugged, and suddenly looked smaller. “So last night at nine we went down to the kitchen. Miri was still there, and she gave us a corner of the table. We baked a chocolate cake. My gran taught me, back when… when I still lived with her.” He cleared his throat. “Maya wanted it to be a secret. A surprise for her mum. So I didn’t say. Even when everyone thought I was a thief. Because I’d promised.”

Maya hugged him round the middle, because that was as high as she reached.

Penny stood still for a long moment. Then she walked up to Benny, held out her hand and said, “Sorry. I said it was you without proof. For the second time this year. I need to stop doing that.”

Benny shook her hand. “You do,” he agreed.

Later, when everyone had drifted away, he stopped next to Amy and said quietly, without looking at her, “Thanks, detective. For not giving up.”

“No blaming without proof,” said Amy.

“Yeah,” said Benny. “But you’re the only one who actually does it.”

That evening, at six o’clock sharp, the Hilltop House Winter Party began.

The little lights glowed across the ceiling. Shira played, and Noam, who couldn’t sing, sang loudest of all. The guests, the grown-up children of long ago, told stories about David twenty years back, and David blushed right down to his moustache. The kitchen fridge was humming again like a giant, contented bee, because David had fixed it that afternoon. And Falafel, in a festive collar of red ribbon that Hutie had tied for him, sat on the little ones’ table being stroked by everyone who passed, like a star.

At seven, a young woman in a green coat appeared in the doorway of the dining hall and looked around with frightened eyes, like someone not sure she was allowed in.

“Mum!”

Maya ran to her so fast she nearly knocked Noam off his chair. And when they hugged, in the middle of the dining hall, under all the little lights, Amy saw the woman in the green coat crying and smiling at the same time, and Maya pulling her by the hand to the table, where a slightly lopsided chocolate cake was waiting, with cream letters on top: “For Mum, from Maya (Benny helped).”

Amy touched her blue button. For one moment, just a moment, her throat ached. Hutie, sitting next to her, said nothing. She just leaned her head on Amy’s shoulder. And Amy knew that Hutie felt exactly the same.

Then Zehava served the pudding. A hundred cups. Well, ninety-nine. And Oliver, who got the last one, announced that he was giving it up for the oldest guest, and everyone clapped, and he said it was the best moment of his life, and then went off to wash cups.

At the end of the evening, Amy wrote in her notebook:

Case Number 6: Pudding for a Hundred. Solved. Who moved them: Miri (a hero). Who ate the note: Falafel. Who ate one pudding: Oliver. Who kept a secret even when he was blamed: Benny.

And from outside, from the yard, there suddenly came a whinny, followed by the crash of something falling over in the vegetable patch. Nobody noticed. Nobody except Amy.

Amy the Detective, Chapter 12: The Eaten Note - Like Likro - books to read online