The Hilltop House Winter Party was the most important evening of the year. More important than anyone’s birthday, more important than the seaside trip, and, according to Hutie, more important than life itself.
At the Winter Party, strings of tiny lights were hung in the dining hall. At the Winter Party, you were allowed to stay up until ten. At the Winter Party, children who had once lived at Hilltop House and had since grown up came to visit, and now they had beards, and babies, and glasses, and they told funny stories about David from twenty years ago, when he still had hair.
And at the Winter Party, always, every single year, there was the pudding.
Zehava’s pudding was not just any pudding. It was deep, dark chocolate pudding, smooth as silk, in little glass cups, with a layer of whipped cream on top and a single chocolate flake in the middle, like a crown. Zehava made it once a year, only for the party. Exactly a hundred cups. For every child, every grown-up and every guest. And never, ever, was there a single cup left at the end, because anyone who didn’t finish their pudding discovered that someone else had finished it for them.
“A hundred,” said Zehava on Wednesday evening, as she shut the big kitchen fridge and laid her hand on it the way you’d pat a child’s head. “I counted twice. By tomorrow evening they’ll be perfectly set.”
There was no school that Thursday. It was a holiday for all the schools in the area, and the whole of Hilltop House woke up early, even before Kuku crowed, because nobody could sleep for excitement. Tom had been sitting up in bed since five, fully dressed, in his flashing trainers, asking every ten minutes whether it was evening yet.
On Thursday morning, Zehava opened the fridge.
Her scream could be heard all the way to town.
At least, that was what the bus driver claimed, who happened to stop at the gate just then, and said afterwards that he’d thought someone had trodden on an enormous cat.
By the time Amy, Hutie and Leo came running into the kitchen, half the house was already there. Zehava stood in front of the open fridge with the Queen in her hand, and the shelves before her were empty. Completely empty. Not one cup. Not one spoonful of cream. Not a single flake of chocolate.
“A hundred!” said Zehava, and her voice shook. “A hundred cups! Six hours I stood at that pot! Six hours I stirred! Who? Who has done this to me? On the day of the party?”
“Maybe they evaporated,” suggested Noam, who always suggested things at the wrong moment.
“Pudding does not evaporate, Noam! Pudding gets eaten!”
And then, as always, everyone began to work out who had eaten it.
“Who could eat a hundred puddings?” asked Penny.
“The big ones,” said Alice at once. “Sixth grade. They eat all the time. I saw Benny eat four slices of bread at once. Four. Stacked up, like a building.”
Every head turned towards Benny.
Benny stood by the door with his hands in his pockets, tall and broad as ever. He needed to say something. But he said nothing. He just went red and took a hand out of his pocket to scratch his head.
And then everyone saw it.
On the sleeve of Benny’s grey jumper, right by his wrist, was a stain. A dark brown, smeary stain. Exactly the colour of chocolate pudding.
“Chocolate!” shrieked Penny. “He’s got chocolate on his sleeve!”
“It’s not what you think,” Benny said quickly.
“Then what is it?”
Benny opened his mouth. Then he closed it. “I can’t say,” he said.
“He can’t say!” Penny repeated, as though this were the greatest proof in the world. “Did you hear? He can’t say!”
“Benny,” said Zehava, and her voice wasn’t angry any more. It was sad, which was worse. “I’ve known you since you were the height of this table. I don’t believe it. Tell me it wasn’t you.”
“It wasn’t me,” said Benny. “But the chocolate… I can’t explain. Not now.”
Mrs. Cohen, who had come in quietly halfway through, put on her glasses. “Benny, come with me to the office, please,” she said. “Not because I’m blaming you. Because I want to listen. Quietly.”
Benny followed her with his head down. The girls in Penny’s class whispered. The boys in Benny’s class stared at the floor. And behind them all, Amy saw, stood little Maya, biting her lip, as if she knew something too and couldn’t say it.
Amy wrote in her notebook: Benny – chocolate on his sleeve. Won’t explain. Maya – frightened. Why?
Then she closed the notebook, because she had realised something. Everyone was looking at Benny. Nobody was looking at the fridge.
“Zehava,” she said. “May I see?”
Zehava stepped aside, still holding the Queen, and Amy stood in front of the open fridge.
The first thing she noticed was the quiet. Usually Zehava’s big fridge hummed all the time, a deep hum, like a giant bee asleep. Now it didn’t hum. Or it did, but faintly, and every so often it gave a little click, followed by silence.
Next she put her hand inside, on the empty shelf.
“Leo,” she said. “Put your hand in.”
Leo did, and raised his eyebrows. “It’s not cold,” he said. “It’s barely cool. It’s like… like outside in the morning.”
“A fridge that isn’t cold,” said Hutie, “is basically a cupboard.”
Amy knelt down. Under the fridge, on the floor, was a small puddle of water. Not big. The size of a plate. She touched it with one finger. Plain water. Not chocolate.
“This fridge is broken,” she said.
“And Falafel was here last night,” said a small voice from the door. It was Tom, in his flashing trainers. “I saw him. I got up for a drink, and he was hopping down the corridor towards the kitchen. Fast. Like someone with an appointment.”
“Falafel likes his night walks,” said Hutie. “Since he moved into Room Seven we leave the door open a crack, and he does his rounds.”
“Broken?” Zehava stared at the fridge as if it had betrayed her. “Last night it was working! I put my hand in, it was as cold as the North Pole!”
“Last night,” said Amy slowly. “And when exactly did you close it?”
“At eight. I went home at half past eight. And Miri stayed on to clean.”
“Who’s Miri?” asked Hutie.
“Miri,” said Zehava, as if everyone knew. “My helper. She comes twice a week, Wednesdays and Sundays. She cleans the kitchen in the evening and makes the dough for Thursday. A good girl. Quiet. Never eats so much as a crumb without asking.”
“So maybe Miri took them,” whispered Penny from the back.
Zehava spun round so fast her apron twirled. “Miri? My Miri? Miri, who once brought me back ten pence change she’d found in the street? Miri doesn’t take. Miri gives back.”
“And where is Miri now?”
“Where is she now? At home in the village, asleep probably. She won’t be back until Sunday.” Zehava shrugged. “And she hasn’t got a phone. She doesn’t believe in phones. She says they’re noisy.”
Amy wrote: Miri – in the kitchen after half past eight. Can’t ask her until Sunday.
“And the party,” said Leo quietly, “starts at six today.”
Everyone fell silent.
Then Amy saw it. On the fridge door, at a grown-up’s eye level, was a small clean square. The whole door was a bit grubby, with fingerprints and little spots of oil, like any door in a busy kitchen. But in the middle was a square, the size of a hand, where the door was perfectly clean. And in its corner, still stuck there, was a tiny scrap of sticky tape.
“Something was hanging here,” said Amy.
“What?” asked Zehava.
“A note, maybe. A piece of paper.”
“I didn’t hang any note.”
“Then someone else did.”
Hutie was already down on her knees, searching. She crawled under the table, behind the bin, along by the back door. Then she shouted “Found it!” and pulled something small and white out of the corner, right against the wall.
It was a scrap of paper. Very small, the size of a stamp. Its edges were strange, not torn in a straight line but full of little curved bites, as if someone had nibbled them.
And on the scrap, in blue pen, in round, tidy handwriting, were only a few letters:
“…ld cel…”
“Ld cel?” read Hutie. “What’s ld cel? Is that alien language?”
“It’s the end of one word and the start of another,” said Leo. “The beginning’s missing, and so is the end.”
“Old cello!” cried Hutie. “Someone carried the puddings away in an old cello!”
“A hundred puddings in one cello?” said Leo.
“Then gold cell! ‘The puddings are locked in a gold cell!'”
“That’s not a sentence,” said Leo.
“It is for aliens.”
Amy looked at the edges. At the little curved bites, round and neat. She had seen bites like that before. On Hutie’s threads. On the shoelace by the door. On one lettuce leaf, every morning, in Room Seven.
“Someone ate the note,” she said slowly. “And I think I know who. But I still don’t know what it said.”
On their way out of the kitchen they passed Mrs. Cohen’s office. The door was shut, and there was no shouting inside. Only Mrs. Cohen’s low, quiet voice, and every now and then, even quieter, Benny’s.
On the bench outside sat Maya. She was holding the bracelet Hutie had braided for her, with its glass bead, and turning it round and round her wrist.
“Maya,” said Amy, sitting down beside her. “Are you waiting for Benny?”
Maya nodded without looking at her.
“Do you know something about the chocolate?”
Maya turned the bracelet again. “I promised,” she whispered. “I promised not to tell. It’s Benny’s secret. But…” She looked up at last, and her eyes were full of tears. “But he didn’t take the puddings. I know he didn’t. He was with me.”
“When?”
“Last night,” said Maya. “And I can’t say any more.”
Amy didn’t push. She just took Maya’s hand, like on the night of the ghost, and said, “All right. You don’t have to say. I’ll find the truth another way. That way the secret stays safe, and so does Benny.”
Maya took a deep breath, as though something heavy had been lifted off her, and leaned against Amy’s shoulder.
In the dining hall the strings of lights were already up. Noam stood on a ladder hanging paper stars. Shira was tuning her guitar. And through the window, by the gate, Amy saw the first guests’ car pull up, and an old man with a grey beard climb out, look up at the house, and smile like someone coming home.
“Soon everyone will be here,” said Hutie. “And there won’t be any pudding.”
Amy looked at the tiny scrap, at its few letters, and at the big clock on the wall, which said, with its seven slow minutes, ten in the morning.
Eight hours until six. A hundred puddings. And Benny, big quiet Benny, sitting in the office with chocolate on his sleeve and a secret he wouldn’t tell.
“Hutie,” said Amy. “Leo. We need to find the rest of that note.”