Gili kept the lottery in his guitar case. Nobody knew why. Nadav had a theory that the guitar case was where Gili kept everything important, including, possibly, his lunch.
“Talent night is in five days,” Gili announced to the sixteen-year-olds on the lawn, strumming a dramatic chord. “And this year, every act is a duet. Two people, two minutes, one stage. And the pairs…” He opened the case with a flourish. “…are chosen by fate.”
“Fate is a guitar case?” said Shira.
“Fate,” said Gili solemnly, “comes in many shapes.”
He drew two slips of paper. “Shira Barak and… Alon Peretz!”
Shira closed her book very slowly. Alon nodded. Everyone agreed it would be either the best act or the quietest one in the history of the camp.
“Lihi Ben-Ami and Nadav Barak!” Lihi screamed. Nadav reached for his inhaler.
Gili drew again, and looked at the slips, and smiled the specific smile of a man who writes ballads about clothespins and has just been handed a gift.
“Daniel Carmeli,” he said, “and Maya Stern.”
There was a groan from two directions at once. It was perfectly synchronized. Gili wrote something in a notebook. It looked like the first line of a song.
* * *
The first rehearsal took place in the boathouse, among the canoes, because it was the only place in camp where nobody could see you fail.
“We’ll do a song,” said Maya. She was sitting on an upturned kayak with her legs crossed and her phone in her lap, as if she were chairing a meeting.
“I can’t sing.”
“Everyone can sing.”
Daniel sang one line of the clothespin ballad.
Maya listened with her head tilted. When he finished, there was a long, respectful silence.
“Okay,” she said. “Not everyone.”
“We could do a knot demonstration,” said Daniel. “I tie, you explain. It’s educational.”
Maya laughed. Not her video laugh, but a short, surprised bark, as if he’d stepped on its foot. “A knot demonstration. At talent night. In front of a hundred kids. Who are you, Nadav?”
“Nadav would have a slideshow.”
“Nadav would have a slideshow,” she agreed, and for a moment they almost smiled at each other, and then both of them remembered and stopped.
It was Maya who had the idea in the end. She stood up on the kayak, looked down at him and said, “A sailing lesson. You’re the instructor. I’m the worst student in the world. On dry land.”
“That’s not acting,” said Daniel. “That’s a documentary.”
“Exactly,” said Maya. “It’s going to kill.”
And it did, at least in the boathouse. They worked it out over the next hour, piece by piece. Maya, sitting in an imaginary boat, capsizing in slow motion with a long, operatic scream. Daniel, the instructor, trying to rescue her with a life ring and hitting himself in the head, in honor of Kobi. Maya climbing onto an imaginary centerboard and announcing, “I’m not listening to you!” while doing exactly what he said. Daniel shouting, “Your back foot!” and Maya shouting back, “There’s no back foot in sailing!” and Daniel shouting, “Then you’re perfect!”
The first time they ran it all the way through, they had to stop twice because they were both laughing too hard to go on. Daniel was lying on the floor of the boathouse. Maya was sitting on the kayak with her face in her hands.
It was very easy, Daniel thought, lying there. That was the strange part. Making her laugh was the easiest thing he’d done all summer.
Then Maya lifted her face out of her hands, and it was serious.
* * *
“Can I ask you something?” she said.
Daniel sat up. “You’re going to anyway.”
“Why does he hate you?” She leaned forward. “The real answer. Not ‘it’s complicated.’ Not ‘family stuff.’ You’ve got two minutes.” She held up her phone and opened the timer. “That’s the length of our act. Go.”
The seconds started to run. Daniel looked at them. One fifty-eight. One fifty-seven.
He thought about everything he could say. That Ben wasn’t really his brother, and was, and both things were true. That Ben’s father had a new baby in Berlin and gray ticks that never turned blue. That Ben was waiting for a birthday call that probably wasn’t coming. That Ben thought everything was his fault because someone had taught him that, a long time ago, in a classroom with a broken window.
He thought about a surfboard in a storage room, behind the Passover dishes. I swear.
One thirty. One twenty-nine.
“I can’t tell you,” said Daniel.
Maya stopped the timer. “Why not?”
“Because it’s not my secret.”
She sat back on the kayak, and her face closed again, slowly this time, like a shop pulling down its shutters for the night. “You know who says that? People whose fault it is.”
“Sometimes,” said Daniel. “And sometimes people whose fault it isn’t.”
They looked at each other across the dusty boathouse. Somewhere outside, the Admiral honked, once, like a referee calling time.
“Same time tomorrow,” said Maya, and left.
Daniel waited a minute, so they wouldn’t have to walk up the path together, then stepped out into the late sunshine.
Something rustled under the boathouse window.
He looked down. Crouched in the weeds beneath the window, so close to the wall that they were practically part of it, were Ben and Omer. Omer had a twig in his hair and the expression of a burglar caught holding the television. Ben had his arms folded and the expression of someone who had meant to be caught.
“You sing,” said Ben, “like a goose with a cold.”
“We heard everything!” said Omer, and then clapped his hand over his mouth, because Ben had glared at him.
Daniel felt his stomach drop. Everything. The two minutes. The timer. “How long have you been there?”
“Long enough,” said Ben. He stood up and brushed the dust off his Maccabi socks. For a moment he didn’t look at Daniel at all. He looked at the boathouse wall, at the place behind it where the kayak was, where Maya had been sitting with her timer running down.
It’s not my secret.
Ben had heard it. Daniel could see that he had heard it. It was in the way he was standing, very still, as if someone had handed him something heavy and he didn’t know where to put it down.
Then Ben shrugged, the magnificent bored shrug, and the moment was gone.
“You really can’t sing,” he said, and walked off up the path with Omer trotting behind him.
Halfway up, Omer looked back at Daniel and gave him a small, secret thumbs-up. Daniel had no idea what it was for. He was fairly sure Omer didn’t know either.
* * *
That night, in Pelican, Nadav held a meeting.
He held it without telling anyone it was a meeting, which was the most dangerous kind. He simply turned on his flashlight, sat up in bed with a notebook, cleared his throat, and said, “I’ve been collecting data.”
“On birds?” said Daniel hopefully.
“On you.” Nadav adjusted his glasses. “Exhibit one. On day four, a bottle of sunscreen, factor fifty, with a label that said BEN, appeared on Ben’s windowsill. Lihi confirms she made the label. She also confirms you asked for it.”
“Lihi talks too much,” said Daniel.
“Lihi talks exactly the right amount for science,” said Nadav. “Exhibit two. On day five, Ben put your flip-flops on the roof of the dining hall. You did not retaliate. Statistically, among brothers aged thirteen to sixteen, the retaliation rate for roof-related incidents is extremely high. Exhibit three.” He turned a page. “Yesterday, a pair of Maccabi soccer socks, yellow and blue, appeared on Ben’s bunk. The camp shop sells exactly one pair. The camp shop lady says a tall boy with a sunburned nose bought them and asked her not to tell anyone.” Nadav looked up. “You have a sunburned nose.”
“Lots of people have sunburned noses.”
“Exhibit four,” said Nadav relentlessly. “Shimon says you asked him whether he could get the cereal with the little chocolate balls, because ‘someone’ only eats breakfast when there’s that cereal. Exhibit five: Operation Goose. We all know about Operation Goose.” He closed the notebook. “Conclusion. Your behavior is not statistically consistent with a person who treats his brother like garbage. It is consistent with the opposite.”
There was a silence in Pelican.
“Brother,” said Alon from the dark.
It was just one word. But the way he said it, it sounded like a whole sentence. It sounded like: I see you. Nadav didn’t even write it down.
Daniel lay on his back and looked at the ceiling fan. “You can’t tell anyone,” he said finally. “Not Maya. Not anyone. I promised him.”
“Promised what?”
“I can’t tell you that either.”
Nadav sighed, the sigh of a scientist forced to stop halfway through an experiment. “Fine,” he said. “But I’m keeping the data.”
The next morning Lihi arrived at breakfast with her label maker and solemnly stuck a label on each of their wrists. It said TOP SECRET. Shira looked at hers for a long time, then looked at Daniel, then across the hall at Ben. She didn’t say anything. But she didn’t take the label off, either.
* * *
At the second rehearsal, Maya was already in the boathouse when Daniel arrived. She was sitting on the same kayak, looking out of the open door toward the field, where a game was going on.
“Ben’s got new socks,” she said, without turning around.
Daniel followed her gaze. Ben was running down the wing with the ball at his feet, and on his legs, pulled up to the knee, were a pair of bright yellow-and-blue Maccabi socks. He wore them as if they were armor.
“He says he found them on his bed,” said Maya. “He thinks Omer did it. Omer says he didn’t, but Ben thinks he’s just being modest.” She was quiet for a moment. “At least somebody in this camp is nice to him.”
Daniel didn’t say anything. He just looked at Ben’s socks flashing across the field, and he smiled. He couldn’t help it. It came up from somewhere deep in his chest, all on its own.
Maya turned and saw the smile, and her eyes narrowed.
“What’s so funny?”
“Nothing,” said Daniel.
“You’re smiling like you know something.”
“I’m smiling,” said Daniel, “because they’re very nice socks.”
She looked at him for a long moment, suspicious, trying to read him the way he read the wind. Then she shook her head, as if he was a puzzle with a piece missing, and climbed into her imaginary boat.
They rehearsed for an hour. It was even funnier than the day before. At the end, when Daniel hit himself in the head with the life ring for the third time, Maya laughed so hard she actually fell off the kayak, a real fall, not a rehearsed one, and lay on the boathouse floor laughing at the ceiling.
Then she sat up. She brushed off her knees. She remembered.
“This doesn’t mean anything,” she said. “You know that, right? Just because we’re funny together doesn’t mean I like you.”
“Distant neighbors,” said Daniel.
Maya frowned. “What?”
“Nothing.” He coiled the rope that was their imaginary sail. “Family joke.”