Two red-haired twin girls meeting on a trip – My Other Half

My Other Half Chapter 42: The Next Suspect

The ceremony was set for nine in the morning, and Libby insisted it be a ceremony.

The ceremony was set for nine in the morning, and Libby insisted it be a ceremony.

“You can’t just cross a name off a board,” she explained, when everyone had gathered in Room 17. “It’s a historic moment. In movies, at moments like this, there’s music. And someone gives a speech. And someone cries.”

“I’m not crying,” said Greta.

“I’ll cry,” Libby offered. “No problem. I can cry in three seconds. Want to see?”

“No,” said everyone.

Greta stood before the board with the red marker, like a judge with a gavel. On the right side of the board was still the old pink note with the name “Benny Kaplan,” and beneath it, attached by faded red string, everything that had once been evidence: the photocopy of the log, the form, the corridor photo. Strings leading nowhere.

Then the door opened and Benny himself came in, in a light-blue shirt and with a very solemn face.

“I heard there’s a ceremony,” he said. “I want to cross it off myself.”

Greta hesitated. Then, for the first time in the history of the board, she handed someone else the red marker.

Benny took it in both hands, like an Olympic torch. He went up to the board. He raised the marker. And he tried to take off the cap.

The cap didn’t move.

He pulled. He twisted. He tried his teeth. Lukas offered to help and reached out, and Benny heroically refused, pulled again, and the cap suddenly shot off, flew across the room, hit the ceiling, and landed exactly in Jess’s mug.

Libby drummed a suspense-movie drumroll on the nightstand. Benny put the marker to his name and drew one long, red, thick line from end to end. Then, to be safe, another one, making an X.

“Well,” he said, stepping back to admire his crossed-out name the way you admire a painting in a museum. “I must say, I look much better like this.”

“I’d like to make a speech,” Benny announced, clearing his throat. “Friends, detectives, nieces. Two weeks ago I was suspect number one in Vienna. Today I’m just an uncle. And I want to say it was an honor. Not pleasant. But an honor.” He handed the marker back to Greta. “And if you ever need another suspect, I’m available. I know the part.”

Tom, standing in the doorway, asked if he could be a suspect too, just for a little while, because it sounded interesting. Greta told him he’d first have to do something suspicious. Tom thought, went to his parents’ room, came back a minute later with his face smeared in chocolate, and asked if that was enough.

Everyone clapped. Libby cried, as promised, within three seconds. Jess fished the cap out of her mug with a teaspoon and announced she wasn’t drinking that anymore.

* * *

After the ceremony, the board looked strangely empty.

On the right, where the red sun had once been, there was only a crossed-out name. And in the middle, under the first law, were three pink notes with three code names: The Neighbor. The Mouse. The Camera.

“Three,” said Greta. “We need to narrow it down.”

“How do you narrow it down?” asked Ella.

“You ask,” said Noa, touching the first law as if to make sure it was still there.

“Ask who?”

And as if in answer, there was a knock at the door, and up the stairs drifted a smell of butter and vanilla and something else, something tangy, that Ella already knew. The smell of lemon drops.

* * *

Margareta came with two bags. One held moon cookies, arranged in circles as always. The other held lemon drops wrapped in clear paper, with a yellow ribbon for each child.

“For the bravest detectives in Vienna,” she said, smiling her soft smile, the glasses on their chain bouncing on her chest. “I heard what happened with your poor uncle. Oh, what a story. How lucky it all worked out.”

“He’s fine,” said Noa. “He even crossed himself off.”

“What a sweet man,” said Margareta. “I always said he looked like a sweet man.” She sat on the edge of Libby’s bed and looked at the board, at the crossed-out name, at the three pink notes. Her eyes paused on each of them a moment, like someone reading a menu.

“The originals?” asked Jess. “Of the log and the form? Did you find them?”

Margareta shook her head sadly. “Gone, dear. As if the earth swallowed them. I asked Herr Gruber again, and he shouted that I was wasting his time.”

“Herr Gruber,” said Ella, pointing at the Mouse note. “We think it might be him.”

Margareta looked at the note. And then, to everyone’s surprise, she laughed. A small, rolling laugh, like a grandmother hearing that her grandson thinks there’s a monster under the bed.

“Gruber? Oh, dear, no. Gruber is a grumpy old man, that’s true. But that night? The night of the storm? There was a power cut. The elevators didn’t work until morning.” She patted her knee. “And Gruber has knees like mine, only worse. He sits in the basement under the laundry, and to get to the third floor he needs the elevator. I’ve never seen him on the stairs. Never. He couldn’t have reached our ward if you’d paid him a million.”

Greta looked at her, then at the note. She didn’t cross it out. But she moved it slowly to the corner of the board and wrote underneath, in small letters: “Can’t climb stairs?”

Jess had already checked on her phone, in an old Viennese newspaper archive, and confirmed that there really had been a power cut across the whole district that night, from eleven until morning. “At least that’s true,” she said, and put her phone away.

“Two left,” said Libby, in a narrator’s voice. “The photographer. And the doctor.”

Margareta took a cookie from the bag and held it out to Lukas, who took it without thinking. “The doctor,” she said, and her voice dropped a little, like someone telling a secret she wasn’t sure she was allowed to tell. “You know, there’s something I didn’t tell you. Because I didn’t think it mattered. But now, seeing the board…”

Everyone leaned in. Even Lukas stopped chewing.

“That night,” said Margareta, “Dr. Fuchs wasn’t on duty. She wasn’t even supposed to be at the hospital. And yet I saw her go into your mother’s room, Noa. In the middle of the night. Without anyone calling her.” She made a small gesture, as if brushing away a fly. “But perhaps it’s nothing. She was always strange, that doctor. Cold. Closed. Didn’t like people. And…” She hesitated. “And she lived right next to your family that year. In the building across the street. So perhaps she just wanted to check on the neighbor.”

Noa felt something cold run down her back. Because that was exactly what Mom had said. “Came to check on the pregnant neighbor.” And stood ten minutes in front of the fridge with the postcards.

“Why didn’t you tell us before?” asked Greta. Quietly. Without accusation. Just in the voice of someone collecting data.

“Because I didn’t want to accuse anyone,” said Margareta, a hand on her heart. “She’s a doctor. And I’m only a nurse. And a nurse doesn’t speak badly of doctors. That’s how we were raised, back then.” She stood and smoothed her skirt. “But you’re clever children. You’ll decide for yourselves.” At the door she turned and added: “Only… don’t tell your parents I said so. All right? I don’t want trouble.”

And she left, leaving behind a smell of lemon and vanilla and a silence full of thoughts.

* * *

“The next suspect,” said Libby, sounding almost happy.

“Don’t be happy,” said Noa. “Last time we were happy, a cake flew.”

Greta was already at the board. She took down the Neighbor’s pink note and pinned it in the middle, where Benny had once been. And beneath it, in neat handwriting, she wrote: “Entered Room 312 off duty. Saw the postcards. Lived across the street.”

Lukas, still holding Margareta’s cookie, was looking suspiciously, not at the cookie, but at the door Margareta had left through.

“She didn’t eat again,” he said.

“Who?”

“Margareta. She brought forty cookies, gave one to everyone, and didn’t eat a single one. She never eats them.” He shook his head in deep sorrow, like someone discussing a tragedy. “How can you bake cookies like that and not eat them? It’s not natural.”

“Maybe she’s on a diet,” Libby suggested.

“Maybe she bakes for other people,” said Ella. “Like Aunt Klara. Aunt Klara never eats what she bakes. She says bakers eat with their eyes.”

Lukas thought about it, nodded slowly, and seemed satisfied with the explanation. Then he ate the cookie, and Libby’s too, since she didn’t want it.

Greta said nothing. But she opened the green notebook, and on a page nobody saw, she wrote one small line, without knowing why: “Doesn’t eat her own cookies.”

* * *

That evening after dinner, Noa and Ella went down to ask Shira. Because the law says ask.

Shira was sitting in the garden with Adam under the apple tree, and when they asked about Dr. Fuchs she made the same face as last time. A bitter-medicine face.

“I never liked her,” she said. “I know it isn’t nice to say. But she was… strict. Like a math teacher walking around with a ruler. Once she saw me carrying shopping bags from the supermarket in my eighth month, and she stopped me in the middle of the street, took the bags right out of my hands, and told me I was ‘behaving like a child’ and ‘endangering the babies.’ In front of all the neighbors.”

“She carried your bags?” asked Ella.

“To the door,” Shira admitted. “Without a word. Then she left.”

Adam, who had been quiet until then, cleared his throat. “And there was the book,” he said.

“What book?” asked Noa.

“One day we found a book on the mat outside our door. ‘A Guide for Parents of Twins.’ In German. No note. Nothing.” Adam shrugged. “We knew it was from her, because she was the only one in the building who read books about babies. Shira said it was creepy.”

“It was creepy!” said Shira. “Who leaves books for people without a note?”

“Someone who doesn’t know how to talk,” Adam said quietly.

Shira looked at him a moment, surprised, as if she’d never thought of it that way. Then she shook her head. “No,” she said. “She was just strange. And that night she was there. That’s all I know.”

The twins climbed back upstairs slowly, step by step.

“So what is she?” asked Ella. “Bad, or strange?”

“Maybe both,” said Noa.

“Maybe neither,” said Ella.

Noa stopped on the step. “Last time,” she said slowly, “we were sure. And we were wrong.”

“So this time,” said Ella, “we’ll only be sure after we’ve asked.”

They went into Room 17. Greta was already at the board with the red string, and at the bottom of the Neighbor’s note she had added two new lines: “Carried Shira’s bags.” “Left a book about twins.”

Then, after long thought, she ran a red string from the Neighbor’s note past the edge of the board to a map of Vienna that Jess had stuck on the wall. To one small street, circled in pen.

“Tomorrow,” said Greta, “we go and see where she lives.”

My Other Half Chapter 42: The Next Suspect - Like Likro - books to read online