On Friday afternoons, Hilltop House got clean.
Not just the corridors, but everything. Zehava baked challah, and the whole house smelled like a bakery. Ruti went from room to room with an enormous laundry basket. David watered the garden and whistled. And the children, once their beds were made, all went to the big hall to welcome the Sabbath, where they sang, lit candles and ate a cake Zehava always said nobody was to touch before it was time, and everybody always touched.
After the Sabbath gathering, when Leo went back to his room in the boys’ wing, he lifted his pillow to tuck his pyjamas underneath, and found a sheet of paper.
He didn’t tell anyone. He just stood there by his bed, the paper in his hand, and in the boys’ wing, which was always noisy, it suddenly went quiet inside his head.
He didn’t tell anyone that evening, or the next day. Amy knew something had happened, because Leo was quiet all Saturday, quieter than usual, and every few minutes he slipped a hand into his shirt pocket and touched something, the way she touched her blue button. But she didn’t ask. A good detective also knows when not to ask.
On Sunday, at break, under the carob tree, Leo took the paper out of his pocket and spread it on the grass in front of them.
It was a drawing. A drawing in black charcoal on thick, cream-coloured paper. A lighthouse. A tall, slender lighthouse standing on a rock above a stormy sea, with waves crashing below, and one long white beam of light shining from its top right across the page. Whoever drew it had drawn the light without drawing it at all. They had simply left the paper empty, white, in the middle of all that black, and it glowed.
“Wow,” whispered Hutie.
“It was under my pillow,” said Leo. “On Friday. And…” He took a second sheet from his pocket, folded smaller, older. “Last Friday too. I didn’t tell. I thought maybe it was a mistake. That someone had put it in the wrong bed.”
The second sheet was another lighthouse. A different one. Round and stout, with red and white stripes that came out grey and white in charcoal, and in the window at the top a small warm light, like a candle.
“It isn’t a mistake,” Amy said quietly.
“No,” Leo agreed. “It isn’t a mistake.”
He was silent for a long time. Hutie, who usually couldn’t stay quiet for more than half a minute, sat without moving and said nothing. She just braided, slowly, a blue thread.
“My dad loved lighthouses,” Leo said at last. He was looking at the drawing, not at them. “He was a fisherman. He had a small blue boat. He said a lighthouse is the most beautiful thing in the world, because it stands alone all night, in the wind and the rain, just to show the boats the way home. He said I was his lighthouse.” Leo took a breath. “He died when I was seven. After that I came here. And I never told anyone about lighthouses. Ever. Nobody here knows.”
“Somebody knows,” said Amy.
“Yes,” said Leo. “Somebody knows.”
He looked up, and his eyes were serious, as always, but something else as well. Something Amy didn’t often see in him. Hope, perhaps. Or fear. Or both together.
“I want to know who,” he said. “But… quietly. Without everyone knowing. No Points Board and no shouting. It’s not like the spoon.”
“It’s not like the spoon,” Amy agreed. “We’ll do it quietly. I promise.”
“I promise too,” said Hutie, and tied the blue thread she had braided round Leo’s wrist. “It’s a silence bracelet. As long as you’re wearing it, we keep quiet.”
Leo looked at the bracelet and said nothing, but he didn’t take it off.
Amy knew that at night Leo looked at the drawings under his blanket by torchlight, long after everyone else was asleep. She knew because in the mornings he had dark circles under his eyes, and because it was exactly what she would have done.
Amy took the two drawings and studied them for a long time, one detail at a time.
The paper: thick, smooth, cream-coloured. Not like school paper, which was white and thin. When she held it up to the sun she could see inside it, almost invisible, a little shadowy mark: a tiny tree with three branches. A paper-maker’s mark, said Leo. Expensive paper.
The charcoal: black and soft, it smudged a little on your fingers when you touched it. Whoever drew this knew how to draw. Really knew. It was not a child’s drawing.
And the smell.
Amy held the paper to her nose and breathed in. Beneath the smell of charcoal and paper there was another smell, soft and sweet. The smell of dried flowers.
“Lavender,” said Hutie, who had sniffed too. “That’s lavender. Like the soap in the teachers’ toilets.”
“How do you know what the soap in the teachers’ toilets smells like?” asked Leo.
“That’s not important right now.”
Amy opened her notebook and wrote: Expensive paper with a tree mark. Charcoal. Someone who can really draw. Smell of lavender. Gets into the boys’ wing on Friday, during the Sabbath gathering.
“Who can get into the boys’ wing during the gathering?” she asked.
Leo thought. “All the grown-ups. Noam, of course. David, if something needs fixing. Ruti, with the laundry. Mrs. Cohen. Not Zehava, she’s in the kitchen.”
“And Shira?”
“Sometimes. But she usually plays the guitar at the gathering.”
“And which of them can draw?”
Nobody knew.
And so began what Hutie later called Operation Nose.
The operation was very simple: Hutie sniffed everybody.
She did it subtly, or so she thought. Which is to say, not subtly at all. She stood next to Noam in the lunch queue and breathed in so deeply that Noam turned round and asked if she was feeling all right.
“Noam smells of lemon deodorant,” she reported. “And a bit of football.”
She walked past David in the storeroom. “David smells of machine oil and tomatoes from the garden.”
She went into the laundry to help Ruti fold towels. “Ruti smells of coffee. Just coffee. She’s probably made of coffee.”
She went up to Shira, who was sitting on the steps tuning her guitar. “Shira smells of apples, and she’s got apple hand oil on, and she asked me why I was sniffing her, and I said I was checking whether she’d be right for the part of an apple tree in the play.”
“There’s a play?” asked Leo.
“There is now,” said Hutie. “I have to invent it by Thursday.”
Oliver was tested too, although Leo said it was pointless. “Oliver smells of orange paint,” Hutie reported. “And also, if I may say so, Oliver can’t draw a lighthouse without orange. I’ve seen his pictures. Even his sun is orange. So is his sea.”
“His sea?” said Amy.
“He said it’s the sea at sunset. All day.”
Zehava was tested as well, even though she’d been in the kitchen during the gathering. “Just to be sure,” Hutie explained. She went into the kitchen on the excuse of wanting to learn to braid challah, and Zehava, so delighted that someone wanted to learn, let her braid three loaves, then two more, and finally sent her away floured to the elbows.
“Zehava smells of cinnamon, yeast and fried onions,” Hutie reported, coughing out a small cloud of flour. “And now I can braid a six-strand challah. It’s exactly like a bracelet, except you eat it at the end.”
“And Mrs. Cohen?” asked Leo.
Hutie went quiet.
She had tried, she really had. On Tuesday she stood by the office door for ten minutes, nose at the ready. But when Mrs. Cohen came out, put on her glasses and said, “Hannah, do you need something?”, Hutie heard her real name, which nobody had said for years, and panicked so badly that she answered, “No thank you, I’m just checking the door,” and fled.
“Checking the door?” Leo repeated.
“That’s what came out! She called me Hannah! Nobody calls me Hannah!”
On Wednesday evening they sat on Amy’s bed in Room Seven, notebook open, Falafel between them, studying the list. Every name was crossed out. Noam, David, Ruti, Shira, Oliver, Zehava. Nobody smelled of lavender. Nobody, as far as they knew, could draw in charcoal.
“Maybe it’s someone from outside,” said Hutie. “A lighthouse fairy.”
“There aren’t any fairies,” said Leo.
“There aren’t any ghosts either, and we still went looking for one.”
Amy didn’t answer. She was looking at the last name on the list, the only one not crossed out. The only one Hutie hadn’t dared go near.
Mrs. Cohen.
“No,” said Hutie, seeing where she was looking. “No, no, no. Amy. She’s the principal. She doesn’t draw. She signs forms. She puts her glasses on to frighten people. She hasn’t got time to draw lighthouses.”
“And she has a drawer,” Amy said slowly, “whose key was with the jay for a whole year. And since the key came back…”
“…drawings have started appearing,” Leo finished softly. He counted on his fingers. “The key came back two and a half weeks ago. The first drawing was two weeks ago.”
They looked at one another.
At that moment there was a knock on the door. It was Shira. “Amy? Mrs. Cohen would like you to come to the office. Something about a school form.”
Hutie grabbed Amy’s hand. “Maybe she knows we’re investigating,” she whispered. “Maybe she’ll punish us. Maybe she’ll make us fold the whole house’s pyjamas.”
“It’s only a form,” said Amy. But her heart was pounding, and she walked down the corridor slowly, like someone going to meet an answer.
Mrs. Cohen’s office was a very tidy room. Shelves of files, a loudly ticking wall clock, and a heavy wooden desk with drawers. Behind it, in the light of a small lamp, sat Mrs. Cohen, glasses on her nose, writing.
“Sit down, Amy,” she said. “I need you to sign here, for the seaside trip. I need every child’s signature.”
Amy had been in this office many times, but she had never really looked at it. Now she looked. On the wall, between a framed certificate and a calendar, hung a small, faded black-and-white photograph. In it a young woman stood on a beach, her long hair blowing in the wind, an easel in front of her. She was laughing. Amy didn’t know who she was. But something about the nose, and the way the woman held her head so straight, seemed very familiar.
Amy sat down and signed. But while her pen moved across the page, her eyes did not rest.
She saw that the bottom drawer of the desk was open, just a little. Only a centimetre.
And she smelled. In the room, beneath the smell of paper and files, was a soft, sweet smell of dried flowers. On the desk, next to the pen, stood a small tube of hand cream. Purple. With a little flower printed on it.
Then Mrs. Cohen reached out to take back the form.
And on the tip of her index finger, right at the very tip, like a mark that hadn’t quite washed away, was a small smudge. Black. Soft.
A smudge of charcoal.