Amy the little detective with a magnifying glass and her friends in the yard

Amy the Detective, Chapter 71: The Ball on the Desk

The morning after the hailstorm, Hilltop House looked like a cake someone had dusted with icing sugar. The whole lawn was white. On the coop roof, on Sugar's bench and along the fence lay little heaps of ice balls, already starting to melt in the pale sun. And Kuku, who had just spent the most frightening night of his life, stood on the fence and announced hoarsely to the whole world that he was still alive.

The morning after the hailstorm, Hilltop House looked like a cake someone had dusted with icing sugar. The whole lawn was white. On the coop roof, on Sugar’s bench and along the fence lay little heaps of ice balls, already starting to melt in the pale sun. And Kuku, who had just spent the most frightening night of his life, stood on the fence and announced hoarsely to the whole world that he was still alive.

But nobody was looking at the lawn. Everyone was looking at Mrs Cohen’s office.

The big window, the one with the green curtain from which Mrs Cohen could see the whole path and the gate, was smashed. A big jagged hole in the middle of the lower pane, with cracks running out from it in every direction like a spider’s web. Glass on the carpet. Glass on the chair. And on the desk, among Mrs Cohen’s important papers, right in the middle, sat a ball. A football. Black and white, with a long scuff on one side and a B written on it in blue marker.

The whole house knew whose ball it was.

“Benny,” said Mrs Cohen. She didn’t shout. She said it quietly, which was much worse.

Benny stood in the office doorway in his pyjamas, hair all over the place, staring at his ball on the desk, not understanding. “It wasn’t me,” he said. “It wasn’t me! I was asleep! All night!”

“It’s your ball,” said Mrs Cohen.

“Yes, but…” Benny looked round, bewildered. “But my ball was outside. By the goal on the pitch. I forgot it there after practice. I always forget it there. And I didn’t kick it in the night! Who kicks a ball at night, in a hailstorm?”

“Someone who doesn’t want to be seen,” said Omer quietly from the back. And Amy noticed, and wrote down, that Omer wasn’t looking anyone in the eye.

Mrs Cohen took off her glasses. “I’m not saying you did it on purpose, Benny,” she said. “But a ball doesn’t come through a window by itself. And until someone explains how your ball got onto my desk, there is no football at Hilltop House. For anyone. Not on the pitch, not in the yard, not in the corridor.”

A long groan went round all the boys. And Benny, who only a few weeks ago had been the candle nobody counts, who last month had saved two penalties, and who had never cried in front of anyone, turned round, walked out and slammed the office door. The cracked glass shivered, and another little shard fell out.

“Brilliant,” said Oliver. “Now he’s breaking what’s left.”

“Oliver,” said Amy. And Oliver went quiet.

She found Benny in the Quiet Room. That is, she didn’t find him. She saw that the green door was shut and heard someone inside gently kicking the wall, over and over, and she didn’t go in. Because there are no questions here. She just put her casebook on the shelf outside the door, open, and on a blank page wrote in big letters: Case Number 36: The Ball on the Desk. Client: Benny. I believe you.

Half an hour later, when she came back, the notebook was gone. In its place was a note in Benny’s crooked writing: Find out who. And tell everyone. Out loud.

“That’s what I do,” Amy told herself, and folded the note twice, tucked it carefully into the lining of her jumper right beside the blue button, and went to work.

At breakfast none of the boys sat next to Benny. Not out of spite, exactly. They just each found a reason to sit somewhere else. Omer sat furthest away, by the dresser, with his warm feet, staring into his porridge. Yonatan said, too loudly, that because of somebody they wouldn’t be playing at the weekend either. The twins, who played on the pitch too, argued in whispers about whether you were allowed to kick a tennis ball or whether that counted as football. And Benny ate alone at the end of the table, very fast, without looking up from his plate.

Until Ari got up with his plate and his cup, walked over and, without a word, sat down beside him. Right beside him. Shoulder to shoulder. Benny looked at him in surprise. Ari just passed him the jam and said, “You always forget the jam.” And Benny, for the first time that morning, almost smiled.

They started outside. Amy, Leo, Hutie and Ari, in wellies, because the hail had melted into cold mud. Maya stayed indoors with Falafel, who was in shock after the night and refused to come out from under the bed.

“First,” said Leo, “let’s see if it’s even possible. Where’s the goal?”

They went to the goal. It stood on the east side of the house by the tree, a long way from the office. Leo counted paces. “Seventy-eight,” he announced. “Three trees in between. And a corner of the house. To kick from here to Mrs Cohen’s window, you’d have to kick round the corner. Balls don’t turn corners.”

“Maybe someone took the ball, walked to the window and kicked it from there,” said Hutie.

“Then let’s go to the window,” said Amy.

Under Mrs Cohen’s window was a flowerbed. Ruti’s bed, with the lavender bushes. The earth was soft and wet, covered in melted hail and mud. Amy crouched and looked. And saw nothing.

“No footprints,” she said. “Not one. Not even a cat’s.”

“Maybe the hail washed them away,” said Ari.

“If someone stood here before the hail, yes,” said Amy. “But if someone stood here during the hail or after it, there’d be prints. This mud’s as soft as pudding. Look.” She pressed a finger into the earth and left a deep hole. “Nobody stood here last night. Nobody.”

But she did see something else. On the outside windowsill, on the white paint, there were dents. Lots of little round dents, as if someone had hit the wood with a small hammer again and again. There were dimples in the drainpipe above the window. And Leo, walking along the wall, suddenly shouted, “Amy! Come here!”

He was standing by Ruti’s greenhouse on the north side of the house, exactly the same side as the office. Two clear panels in the greenhouse roof were cracked. And a small window in the laundry room, in the same wall, had a hole in it. A small round hole the size of an egg.

“Nobody kicked a ball at the greenhouse,” said Leo. “Or the laundry.”

“The hail,” said Amy. “The wind came from the north. I saw it from our window; the hailstones were falling slantways. Everything on the north side of the house got hit full in the face. The greenhouse, the laundry room and Mrs Cohen’s window.”

Tom, who had followed them out in someone else’s wellies, three sizes too big, picked a hailstone off the bench, held it in his palm and gazed at it in admiration. “Are these the clouds’ marbles?” he asked. “Were the clouds playing marbles and dropped them?”

“Sort of,” said Leo, who didn’t have the heart to correct him. Then he took out a ruler and measured the biggest hailstone he could find in the flowerbed. “Four centimetres,” he announced. “That’s huge. The book says hail like that can break glass and dent cars.” Hutie filled a jar with hailstones “as evidence” and put it in Zehava’s freezer beside the peas, and Zehava said that if the evidence touched her cakes, she’d be the first witness against Hutie at any trial.

“But the laundry window got a small hole,” said Ari. “And Mrs Cohen’s got a huge one.”

“Mrs Cohen’s window is old,” said Hutie. “David said once it’s the oldest in the house. And the thinnest. He said it needed replacing and there wasn’t any money.”

Amy wrote it all down. No footprints. Dented sill. Greenhouse. Laundry. North wind. Then she shut the notebook. “Now,” she said, “we need to get into the office.”

Getting into Mrs Cohen’s office wasn’t simple. Not when Mrs Cohen was cross. But Amy knocked and went in, and Mrs Cohen, who was sitting in the corner with a dustpan and brush, sweeping up the glass herself because she didn’t want any child touching it, looked at her over her glasses.

“I know why you’ve come,” said Mrs Cohen. “And I understand. He’s your friend. But a ball, Amy, is a ball.”

“I only want to look,” said Amy. “Without touching. Five minutes.”

Mrs Cohen considered. Then she put down the brush. “Five,” she said. “I’m counting.”

Amy stood in the middle of the office and didn’t move. She just looked. The way David had taught her to look at wood, and the way her mother had taught her to look at people, once, long ago.

The carpet was wet. Not everywhere. In patches. Dark round patches scattered about, some by the window, some far away by the bookcase, one even under Mrs Cohen’s chair. And in the middle of each patch, if she bent down, Amy could see something small and clear that hadn’t quite melted. A hailstone. The size of a walnut.

“The hail came in,” she said quietly. “Through the hole. Lots of it. And rolled all over the office.”

Then the bookcase by the window. On it were books and files and a few things Mrs Cohen collected: a shell, a little owl statue and a photo of all the children of the house ten years ago. The books on the top shelf had fallen, some on the floor. The owl lay on its side. And on the top shelf, in the dust, which Mrs Cohen never cleaned because you couldn’t reach it without a chair, Amy saw a circle. A clean circle, exactly the size of a ball, with no dust on it. As if something round had stood there a long time and now didn’t.

And the glass. Most of it lay inside, on the carpet, with very little outside on the sill. So something had hit the window from outside and pushed it in. That fitted a ball. But it fitted hail too. Amy wrote it down honestly, in both columns, because a good detective doesn’t hide evidence just because it’s inconvenient.

“Two more minutes,” said Mrs Cohen.

That left the ball.

It still sat on the desk, because Mrs Cohen had said it was evidence and nobody was to touch it. Amy went closer, leaned over and didn’t touch. She just looked. And she saw two things.

The first: the ball was sitting on the papers. And on the papers, underneath it, were splinters of glass. The ball was on top of the glass. Not underneath.

The second made her hold her breath.

“Mrs Cohen,” she said, without taking her eyes off the ball. “Could you touch the ball? Just touch it. On top.”

Mrs Cohen raised an eyebrow. But she got up and laid her hand on the ball. She kept it there a long moment. Then another. As if she didn’t believe her own hand and wanted to ask it again. And her expression changed.

“It’s dry,” she said.

“Completely dry,” said Amy. “The whole world outside is wet. The grass, the mud, the fence, even the carpet in here. A ball kicked from outside, in a hailstorm, through a window, would be wet and muddy, maybe with ice on it. This ball is dry and clean, and it’s sitting on top of the glass. So it got onto the desk after the window broke. And not from outside.”

Mrs Cohen looked at the ball. Then at the window. Then, slowly, at the top shelf of the bookcase. At the clean circle in the dust.

“This ball,” said Amy quietly, “didn’t come into the office last night. It was here all along.”

Amy the Detective, Chapter 71: The Ball on the Desk - Like Likro - books to read online