Hilltop House had seen plenty of mysteries. But this was the first one nobody wanted solved.
“Why solve it?” said Hutie, lying down on her made bed, carefully, so as not to crease it. “Someone’s making our beds. I don’t want to know who. I want it to go on for ever.”
“It isn’t made,” said Amy. “It’s perfect. There’s a difference.”
And she was right. Because it wasn’t only the beds.
On Tuesday, the beds in Room Seven. And the shoes of the entire boys’ wing, polished so brightly that Benny saw his own face in them and got a fright. On Wednesday, someone folded all of Ruti’s laundry, an enormous pile that had been waiting three days, and put a single paper flower on top. On Thursday, every pencil in the homework room was sharpened, all hundred and seven of them; Leo counted. And that evening, in Maya’s slipper, which stood in the corridor, there was a biscuit wrapped in a napkin, with a little note and no name: For bedtime. So it isn’t sad.
“Maya’s always sad at bedtime,” said Hutie quietly. “Only we know that. Room Seven.”
“And Tom,” said Leo, “found all his dinosaurs lined up on the shelf. By height. Smallest to biggest. That’s the order Tom likes. He explained it to me once. For forty minutes.”
“And Omer,” added Amy, “got a new shoelace. To replace the half the mouse took.”
“What about Oliver?” Hutie suggested. “Maybe it’s a prank. A backwards prank. Tidying instead of messing up. To drive everyone mad.”
“I asked him,” said Leo. “He was offended. He said if he did a backwards prank he’d polish all the shoes orange, not black. And that black shoe polish is ‘a waste of talent’.”
Tom, passing with a dinosaur in his hand, stopped and said importantly, “I know who it is. It’s a fairy. A tidying fairy. She comes at night and puts everything in its place. Grandma Rachel told me about her on Thursday, while we were folding birds. She said the fairy especially likes children who tidy up by themselves, so she only visits them, so they don’t get tired.” And he walked on, satisfied, and nobody could bring themselves to tell him otherwise.
They were quiet.
“Whoever’s doing this,” said Amy slowly, “knows everyone. Not just their names. The little things. What each person needs. What each person likes. What each person is afraid of.”
And then, without anyone wanting to, they all thought of the same person.
Ari.
“No,” said Hutie at once. “Not Ari. Ari’s a friend.”
“Nobody said it’s bad,” said Amy. “If it’s Ari, it’s the loveliest thing in the world. But…” She opened her notebook at the first page, where for more than a year it had said, in big letters: No blaming without proof. “No deciding without proof either. Even when it’s something good.”
“And why find out at all?” Hutie asked again. “If someone wants to be good in secret, why not let them?”
Amy thought about it for a long time. Then she said, “Because whoever’s doing this gets up every night, in the middle of the night, and does the work of ten people. Alone. And nobody says thank you. Not once.” She closed the notebook. “I don’t want to catch them. I want to say thank you.”
And so Case Number 32 was opened. The first case in which the detectives went looking for someone in order to give them something.
The first clue was a smell.
Amy noticed it on Wednesday morning in the boys’ wing, when she went to call Leo for breakfast. A sharp, oily smell, a bit like David when he cleans his shoes for a holiday. Shoe polish. And it hung in the corridor by the door of Room Four.
“Who sleeps in Room Four?” Amy asked Leo.
“Benny,” said Leo. “And Omer, and Yonatan, and me. And Ari, since he came.”
Amy wrote: Shoe polish. Room Four. Five suspects.
That evening, Ruti stood in the laundry room in front of the folded pile, holding her coffee mug as always and not drinking from it. “Three days,” she said to Amy. “Three days I’ve been looking at this pile and promising myself tomorrow. And someone…” She touched the paper flower. “Whoever it is, I want to hug them. Hard. Until they beg for mercy.”
Then she lifted the top sheet, a white one, and showed Amy. In the corner, small, almost invisible, was a fingerprint. A black one.
“It won’t come out,” said Ruti, not sounding cross at all. “I’ve tried. Someone folded my laundry with hands covered in something black.”
Amy wrote: Fingerprint. Black. Shoe polish? Same person. Shoes first, laundry after.
The second clue was tiredness.
“Someone round here,” Amy said at lunch, “is yawning too much.”
She looked round. Ari was eating, as always, slowly and quietly, watching people. Leo was counting peas. Omer was thinking. Yonatan was arguing with himself. And Benny…
Benny sat in front of his plate with his chin on his hand, and his eyes were closing. Slowly. And slowly. Until his elbow slipped and his chin dropped, straight into the mashed potato. Splat.
The whole table laughed. Benny woke up with mash on his nose, got cross, and shouted, “Who pushed me?!” Nobody had pushed him.
Ari, Amy noticed, didn’t laugh. He looked at Benny, then at his own plate, and gripped his fork tightly, like someone keeping a secret who is afraid it might escape from his mouth. Amy wrote, without laughing: Benny. Tired. Very. Then, on a separate line: But Benny’s always tired after football.
When Amy went to ask Zehava, she said something had happened to her too. “This morning at half past five I walk into the kitchen and the floor’s been mopped. Gleaming. Like a mirror. And I didn’t mop it.” She lowered her voice. “And I heard someone going out of the back door. Humming. A football song. ‘Olé, olé, olé.’ Very quietly. Like someone trying not to hum, and failing.”
Amy wrote: Football song. And underlined it three times.
That night Amy and Hutie decided not to sleep. To sit up in bed with the torch under the blanket and wait, and see who came into Room Seven. They lasted until twenty past eleven. Then Hutie started snoring, and Amy just had time to think “only one more minute”, and then it was morning.
In the morning, both their pairs of shoes, which had stood overnight in the corridor by the door, were polished. And the laces, always frayed and grubby, were tied in bows. Perfect bows. Double ones.
“He was here!” cried Hutie. “He was here and we were asleep! What kind of detectives are we?”
“Tired ones,” said Amy, looking at the bows. Then, slowly, she understood something else. Boys never come into the girls’ wing. Never. But the girls’ shoes stand outside in the corridor by the door every night to dry, ever since winter began. And from there, anyone can take them. And bring them back.
“Then there are two of them,” she said, pointing at the corners of Hutie’s bed, folded sharp as an envelope. “Only two girls in the whole house fold corners like that. Alice and Penny. They learned it from Shira for the pillow-war inspection, and they’ve been proud of it ever since, as if it were a Nobel Prize.”
“But girls don’t polish boys’ shoes,” said Leo. “And boys don’t go into girls’ rooms. So…”
Amy wrote: Two people? One in the boys’ wing. One in the girls’ wing. And someone who knows everything about everyone. She looked at the line. “Three,” she corrected.
“It’s got to be Benny,” said Hutie that morning on the stair, still wearing her bows. “Shoe polish, tiredness, and Zehava’s potatoes. He peeled twenty potatoes without being asked. When has Benny ever done anything without being asked?”
“Once,” said Leo. “When he ate all of Omer’s birthday cake. Nobody asked him then either.”
“Benny?” said Maya doubtfully. “Benny shouts at us all the time. Benny says girls are annoying. Benny once told me I look like Falafel when I cry.”
“Then maybe it isn’t Benny,” Hutie admitted.
“And how would someone like Benny know that Maya’s sad at bedtime?” asked Amy. “Or that Tom likes his dinosaurs by height? Benny doesn’t listen to anyone. Benny only listens to the referee’s whistle.”
And once again, without wanting to, everyone looked at Ari. Who was sitting at the side, as always, writing something in a small exercise book.
Amy didn’t want to accuse anyone. But she did want to ask. So at break she sat down beside Ari by the cubbies and asked quietly, “Ari. Do you know who’s doing it?”
Ari didn’t answer straight away. He looked at his palm, the way he did when he needed to think. Then he said, “I can’t say.” His ears went red. “I promised.”
“Promised who?”
“I promised not to say that either,” said Ari, looking so miserable that Amy let it go at once.
The third clue was a sheet of paper.
Amy found it on Friday morning, on the corridor floor beside the row of girls’ shoes, where someone had dropped it while bending down to put the biscuit in Maya’s slipper. A folded page torn from a small exercise book. On it, in small, neat, familiar handwriting, was a list.
Maya: sad at bedtime. Likes chocolate biscuits. Scared of the dark but won’t admit it.
Tom: dinosaurs. By height. Cries when people argue.
Omer: missing half a shoelace. Won’t ask, because he’s embarrassed.
Ruti: laundry. Three days. Tired.
Leo: pencils. Likes them sharp.
And more, and more, and more. Forty-one names. Beside each, one small thing that only someone who watched very carefully would know.
Amy knew the handwriting. She had seen it on the Wall of Names. Under every hand. Jam. Dinosaur. Notebook.
It was Ari’s.
She took the page down to the third stair and sat there alone for a long time. She didn’t show it to anyone. Not even Hutie. Because something about it bothered her, like a small stone in a shoe. Something didn’t fit.
“If it’s Ari,” she whispered to herself, “why does he need a list? Ari remembers everything. Ari doesn’t need to write things down. Ari remembers what Benny ate on a Tuesday three weeks ago.”
She looked at the page again. And this time she saw it. In the bottom corner, in different handwriting, big and crooked, in pencil pressed too hard, like someone not used to writing much, was one more line. A line Ari hadn’t written. Someone else had added it later.
Tuesday: my shoes too. And shout loud “Who polished mine?!” So nobody suspects.
Amy looked up from the page. And at that very moment, at the bottom of the stairs, someone walked past. Tall, broad, with a goalkeeper’s shoulders, and fingers… his fingers were black. Completely black. Like someone who had polished a great many shoes last night.
He stopped. He saw Amy on the stair. He saw the page in her hand. And his own crooked writing in the corner.
And the face of Benny, tough Benny, shouting Benny, girls-are-annoying Benny, went red. Red as jam. From his chin to his ears.