Amy the little detective with a magnifying glass and her friends in the yard

Amy the Detective, Chapter 23: The Vanishing Carrots

The carrots had been planted in winter, on a cold, rainy day, when the whole of Hilltop House went out to the vegetable patch in boots and gloves with little packets of seeds.

The carrots had been planted in winter, on a cold, rainy day, when the whole of Hilltop House went out to the vegetable patch in boots and gloves with little packets of seeds.

Every child got half a row. Tom planted his seeds in the shape of a dinosaur. Omer planted his in the shape of his name, OMER, which in the end looked more like OMEN. Hutie marked her row with red thread at both ends, “so the carrots know where the border is.” And Leo measured the gap between every seed with a ruler, and a month later his carrots came up the straightest in the garden, like tiny soldiers in green hats.

All winter, and all through the beginning of spring, the carrots grew. And the house waited.

Because these weren’t just carrots. Zehava had promised that when the Together column on the points board reached a hundred, she would bake the biggest carrot cake in the history of Hilltop House. With cream cheese icing. And walnuts. And a little marzipan carrot on every slice. And last week, after Oliver and Benny had cleaned the ceiling, Mrs. Cohen had written ten more points in the Together column, “for exemplary cleaning and a story I will never forget.” The column stood at ninety-six.

Four points. And cake.

And then, on Sunday morning, the first row vanished.

Hutie discovered it. She’d gone out to the garden early, having decided to check whether her carrots were big enough to taste just one, just a small one, just for science. She came running back to the dining hall, muddy to the knees and wide-eyed.

“The carrots!” she shouted. “Tom’s carrots! The dinosaur! It’s got no head!”

Everyone ran outside. And it was true. Where yesterday a happy green dinosaur of carrot tops had stood, there were now holes. Small, messy holes, with soil scattered around them. And here and there, tossed on the ground, lay green leaves, wilted, with no carrot underneath.

Tom stood in front of his row, and his bottom lip trembled like a leaf.

“Somebody ate my dinosaur,” he said.

And then, almost together, several children turned and looked at the same spot. At the steps of the girls’ wing, where, in the sunshine, with one left ear up, sat a brown rabbit with a white tail.

Falafel.

Falafel was chewing something.

“Falafel!” said Omer. “Carrot murderer!”

“It’s a lettuce leaf,” said Maya quickly. She ran to the steps and picked Falafel up, and he went on chewing peacefully. “Look. Lettuce. I gave it to him myself. This morning.”

“Yes, but what did he eat last night?” asked Yonatan.

Nobody answered, because everyone knew what rabbits like to eat more than anything else in the world. It’s written in every book and drawn in every cartoon. Rabbits eat carrots.

On the second night, another row vanished. Omer’s row, the one that said OMEN. Now only the O was left, and only just.

“He hates me,” said Omer tragically, pointing at Falafel. “He ate my name.”

And at lunch, Mrs. Cohen stood in the doorway of the dining hall.

“I am fond of Falafel,” she said. Everyone was surprised, because nobody knew Mrs. Cohen was fond of anything except peace and order. “He is a good rabbit. He found the puddings. He uncovered the socks. But this garden belongs to everyone. If one more row disappears, Falafel will move into a cage in David’s shed. Until the carrots are grown.”

Maya went as white as her plate.

That evening she ate nothing. She sat on her bed in Room Seven with Falafel in her lap, stroking his ears, one up and one down, and didn’t say a word. And at night Amy heard her crying under the blanket, quietly, like in her first weeks at the house, before she became the bravest girl in the wing.

Amy lay in the dark looking at the ceiling. Without writing anything down, she already knew what she had to do.

In the morning she gathered Hutie and Leo behind the carob tree.

“No blaming without proof,” she said. “But no clearing anyone without proof either. If we want to save Falafel, we have to prove it wasn’t him. Not say it. Prove it.”

“How do you prove a rabbit didn’t eat a carrot?” asked Hutie. “He’s a rabbit. It’s like proving I didn’t eat a biscuit. Everyone knows I ate it.”

“First,” said Amy, “we check where Falafel was at night.”

That was the problem. Ever since Falafel had moved into Room Seven, the girls left the door open a crack so he could do his rounds. He went out, wandered the corridors, visited Zehava in the kitchen, and in the morning came back to his basket beside Maya’s bed. Nobody knew exactly where he went. So nobody could say he didn’t go to the garden.

“Tonight,” said Amy, “the door will be shut.”

“And the window?” asked Leo. “Rabbits jump high. A rabbit can jump up to a metre.”

“The window’s on the first floor,” said Amy. “If Falafel jumps out of a first-floor window, he isn’t a rabbit. He’s a super-rabbit, and he deserves all the carrots he wants.”

“And how do we prove nobody opened the door in the middle of the night?” asked Leo.

Hutie grinned. She put a hand in her pocket and pulled out a thin white thread, almost see-through.

“With this,” she said.

That night, after everyone was in bed, Hutie tied the thread from the door handle to the leg of Amy’s bed, in a special knot she had invented, “the Detective Knot”, with three loops and a bow in the middle. “If anyone opens the door, even one centimetre,” she explained, “the knot comes undone. And you can’t tie it again the same way. Only I know how. I tried to teach Leo, and he tied his own sleeves together.”

Falafel sat in his basket eyeing the thread with deep suspicion. Then he fell asleep.

In the morning, the very first thing Amy did, before her eyes were even fully open, was look at the door.

The thread was there. Tight. The knot was whole, with three loops and a bow in the middle. And Falafel was asleep in his basket, exactly where he’d been the night before, one ear up, with the look of a rabbit who had slept extremely well.

Amy leapt out of bed, barefoot, and ran to the window.

In the vegetable patch, Alice and Penny’s row, the longest one, which they had planted together and always argued over whose half was whose, was full of holes.

“Maya,” said Amy, her voice trembling with excitement. “Maya, wake up. Falafel is innocent.”

All of Room Seven went down to the garden in pyjamas. And so did Leo, who was already waiting by the gate with his exercise book, because he “couldn’t sleep for all the hypotheses.”

“Now,” said Amy, “we look.”

They all crouched by the holes, like a team of small detectives in pyjamas. And now that they knew it wasn’t Falafel, they began to see things they hadn’t seen before.

The holes, for example. A rabbit digs fast, with two feet, and makes a big neat hole with a heap of soil behind it. But these holes were small and messy, as if someone had rooted around in them with a nose, from every side.

“Look,” whispered Leo, pointing at the soft soil between the rows. There were tracks. Tiny ones. Each with five little toes and five even littler claws, like a doll’s hand. “Rabbits have long back feet,” he explained. “Their tracks look like two sticks and two dots. These don’t look like a rabbit’s at all.”

Then Maya, who finally understood she had a reason to hope, found the next clue and held it up on a leaf, at arm’s length, with the face of someone proud and disgusted at the same time.

“This,” she said, “is not rabbit poo.”

Everyone leaned in. It really wasn’t. Rabbit poo is round and small, like chickpeas. This was long and black and shiny, and something inside it glittered.

“What’s glittering?” asked Hutie, leaning closer, then leaning away very fast.

Leo came closer, with a stick. “Wings,” he said. “Bits of beetle wings. Whoever did this eats insects.”

“Yuck,” said Hutie. “That’s the most disgusting clue we’ve ever had.”

“Last time you said the bald broom was the funniest,” said Amy.

“It can be both.”

Amy wrote: Small messy holes. Five-toed tracks. Poo with beetle wings. Someone small who eats insects, and carrots too.

“Maybe it’s Kuku,” suggested Penny. “Roosters eat insects.”

“Kuku doesn’t have five toes,” said Leo. “He has four. And three of them point forward.”

“Maybe the jay’s back,” said Alice.

“Jays don’t dig,” said Leo. “And they collect shiny things. Carrots aren’t shiny.”

“Then maybe Oliver’s scarecrow came to life,” said Hutie, “and at night it climbs off its pole and eats beetles and carrots, and gets back before morning so nobody notices.”

Everyone looked at the scarecrow. The scarecrow, with its orange hat and painted smile, looked back at them. And for one second, not even Leo was sure.

“Scarecrows don’t have toes at all,” he said at last. “They have straw.”

Then Tom, who had been standing quietly to one side the whole time, said something they had almost forgotten.

“I heard it,” he said.

Everyone turned.

“On the dinosaur night,” said Tom. “I went to get some water, and the kitchen window was open. And something outside went like this.” And he made a funny noise, a sort of tiny snore, with a sniff through his nose: “Hrrrrr. Pfff. Hrrrr.” He went pink. “I thought it was David snoring. But David doesn’t sleep in the garden.”

Hutie rolled on the ground laughing. But Amy didn’t laugh. She wrote the noise in the notebook exactly the way Tom had made it, with four r’s and three f’s. Because every clue is a clue, even if it sounds like David snoring.

That day Amy went to Ruti and told her they had proof Falafel wasn’t guilty. Ruti listened, and looked at the thread, and the notebook, and the drawing of the tracks. She said she’d talk to Mrs. Cohen, and that meanwhile Falafel would stay in Room Seven.

“But,” she added, sipping her coffee, “the carrots are still vanishing. And someone still has a tummy full of carrot. You’d better find out who, before there’s nothing left to bake.”

Three rows were left in the garden. Hutie’s row, with the red thread. Maya’s row. And Leo’s straight row.

That evening they asked Noam for a night watch, and Noam said, “Tomorrow, I promise, tonight I’m on kitchen duty.” So they went to bed with their hearts pounding.

“And what if tonight it eats my row?” asked Hutie in alarm. “I marked it with red thread! It has borders!”

“Maybe it can’t read thread,” said Leo.

But Amy couldn’t fall asleep. At about eleven o’clock she got up quietly, stood by the window of Room Seven and looked at the garden. The moon was nearly full, and everything was silver and still. The rows. Oliver’s scarecrow in its orange hat. David’s shed, with the black shadow beneath it.

And then, in the black shadow under the shed, something moved.

Amy held her breath.

In the darkness under the floor of the shed, two small bright dots lit up, like two beads of light. Eyes. They were looking at the garden. And then, beside them, two more dots lit up, smaller. And two more. And two more.

Eight little eyes in the dark, looking at the carrots.

Amy the Detective, Chapter 23: The Vanishing Carrots - Like Likro - books to read online