Amy the little detective with a magnifying glass and her friends in the yard

Amy the Detective, Chapter 22: April Fool

Amy came down the ladder so fast she nearly landed on David.

Amy came down the ladder so fast she nearly landed on David.

“Whoa,” said David, catching her by the shoulders. “Slowly, detective. This ladder isn’t running away. I tried to make it run away once, and it refused.”

He was holding a paper bag full of screws, and Morris the spider was sitting on his cap like a tiny king on a crown. Amy looked at him. She liked David very much. Since the violin, and since the night she’d found out that he too had once been a child in this house, she liked him even more. And that was what made it hard. Because the mud on the top rung was fresh.

“David,” she said. “There’s mud on your ladder.”

“Really?” David raised one eyebrow. “A dirty ladder. What a terrible crime.”

“It’s the same mud as on the ceiling.”

David was quiet for a moment. He lowered the bag slowly and looked at the ladder, then at Amy, and there was something in his eyes Amy couldn’t read. Not anger. More like someone trying very hard not to laugh.

“I’ll tell you what I know,” he said at last. “Last night, at nine o’clock, someone knocked on my door. A very polite young man. He asked to borrow the ladder, because a bulb had gone in the boys’ bathroom. So I lent it. I like polite young men who change light bulbs.” He picked up the bag. “This morning the ladder was back. The bulb in the bathroom, by the way, is still dead.”

“Who was it?”

“Ah,” said David, starting to walk away. “I’m a caretaker, not a tell-tale. But I’ll tell you one more thing, for free.” He stopped. “In the shoe cupboard, down in the cellar, I keep an old pair of boots. Work boots, size forty-four. This morning they were there. Only they were wet. And full of mud. And with a bit of orange tape on the heels.” He winked. “Boots don’t go out walking on their own at night. Not even here.”

Then he left, whistling, and Morris waved one leg from the top of the cap, as if saying goodbye.

Amy opened the notebook and wrote: Nine p.m.: polite young man borrows the ladder. Size 44 boots from the cellar shoe cupboard. Polite young man. Oliver is not polite. Oliver in bed from half past nine.

Then she slowly wrote one more line: Who at Hilltop House is the strongest, the tallest, and always says “sorry” when he asks for something?

She knew the answer. She just didn’t like it.

The next morning, Hutie brought the next clue without even meaning to.

“Miri’s cross,” she reported at breakfast, spreading chocolate on three slices at once. “I was in the laundry room returning a sock, and Miri was holding up a pair of trousers, complaining that someone had been crawling in mud. ‘The knees!’ she shouted. ‘Look at the knees! Where does a child get that much mud on his knees in April?'”

“Whose trousers were they?” asked Amy.

“Don’t know. Big ones. One of the big boys.” Hutie took a bite. “Why? Is that a clue? Was that a clue? Did I solve something?”

“Maybe,” said Amy.

Leo, sitting opposite, put down his spoon. “Whoever stands on the ladder,” he said, “doesn’t get muddy knees. But whoever holds the ladder at the bottom, and then kneels to pick up the mud that falls off the boots, so there are no marks…” He paused. “He gets muddy knees. And did you notice there wasn’t a single crumb of mud on the dining-hall floor? Only on the ceiling. And in the porridge.”

Amy wrote: Two people. One up, one down. One holds, one stamps.

“But Oliver was ill,” said Hutie for the hundredth time.

“Oliver was ill from half past nine,” said Amy. “David lent the ladder at nine.”

Hutie counted on her fingers. “Half an hour,” she said. “Can you stamp a ceiling in half an hour?”

“Thirty-two stamps,” said Leo. “If each stamp takes half a minute, including moving the ladder… that’s sixteen minutes. Enough time to clean up, return the boots and get to bed.” He looked up. “And start shivering. If you stand on a ladder in the dark for half an hour, with hands wet from mud, in April, you can catch a fever.”

They looked at one another. Then, like three beams of the same lighthouse, they turned to the boys’ table. There sat Benny, cutting his omelette into very small pieces, with enormous concentration, as if this omelette were the most interesting thing that had ever happened to him.

Amy didn’t go over to him in front of everyone. She’d learned that in the case of the shoes. Some things you say in a dining hall, and some things you say by Sugar’s fence.

After school, she found him there. He was standing by the fence stroking Sugar’s nose, while Sugar sniffed his pockets in case there was a banana in them.

“Benny,” she said.

“I know,” said Benny, without turning round. “I knew you’d come. I’ve known since this morning. I saw the way you looked at my knees.”

“I didn’t look at your knees. Miri did.”

Benny gave a sigh so enormous that Sugar pricked up his ears. “Miri,” he said. “It’s always Miri.”

He turned round. He was the tallest child in the house, and standing like that, with his shoulders down, he looked like a giant who was embarrassed to be a giant.

“It was Oliver’s idea,” he said. “But I’m not saying that to blame him. I said yes. Nobody made me.” He was quiet for a moment. “Did you know he planned it for a whole month? He’s got a sheet of squared paper with the whole ceiling drawn on it. He marked every footprint in pencil. Two squares a step. He said if it wasn’t exact, Leo would find out.”

“Leo did find out,” said Amy.

“Of course Leo found out.” Benny almost smiled. “So I asked David for the ladder, Oliver fetched the boots from the cellar, and we taped them upside down onto the double broom. He stood at the top and stamped, and I held the ladder and picked up the mud that fell. Except the last lump. We didn’t see the last lump.” He went red. “It fell later. Into the porridge. Zehava will never forgive me.”

“And then Oliver got a fever.”

“He shivered all the way back,” said Benny, and his voice went soft. “His hands were frozen. I left him by the sick room and ran to put the boots back. He told me not to tell anyone, even if he got caught. So I didn’t.” He looked at Amy. “But I don’t want the whole house to miss films till the end of the year because of us.”

Amy wrote something, then closed the notebook.

“Benny,” she said, “why did Oliver want to do it? He never pulls a prank without a reason. Even the spoon was for Zehava.”

Benny gave her a strange look. “You really don’t know?”

“No.”

“Then ask him,” said Benny. “His fever’s gone. And Ruti says visitors are allowed.”

Oliver was sitting up in bed in the sick room, wrapped in a blanket to his chin, drawing something in orange pencil. When Amy came in, he looked up with a huge grin, the grin of someone who had been waiting two whole days for her to arrive.

“Well?” he said. “Did you solve it?”

“I solved it,” said Amy. “David’s boots. The double broom. The orange tape. The squared paper. And Benny holding the ladder.”

“Benny told you?” Oliver looked disappointed for a moment. “He promised.”

“His knees told me. And Miri. And you.” She sat on the end of the bed. “You smiled at me through the window. Someone who’s ill and did nothing doesn’t smile like that. But Oliver, why?”

Oliver was quiet. Then, slowly, he pulled a sheet of paper from under his pillow. Squared paper, crumpled, with a drawing of a ceiling and thirty-two tiny pencil footprints. And at the top, in orange letters, it said: Case Number 11. For Amy.

“I saw your new notebook,” he said, looking at the blanket. “On Arrival Day. It’s so beautiful. And I thought, a new notebook with empty pages, that’s sad. A new notebook needs a first case. And I thought, if there’s going to be a case, it should be the craziest case there’s ever been here. Footprints on the ceiling.” He sniffed. “I wanted the first case in your new notebook to be from me. Because I’m your usual suspect. I wrote it for you, remember?”

Amy didn’t know what to say. So she said the only thing that came to her.

“Oliver, you’re bonkers.”

“Thank you,” said Oliver proudly.

That evening she told Hutie and Leo everything, on the windowsill of Room Seven. Hutie was silent for a long moment, which happened to her about once a year, and then said, “That’s the stupidest and sweetest thing I’ve ever heard.” Leo said that, scientifically speaking, stamping a ceiling in sixteen minutes was very impressive, and if Oliver used his talent for good he could be an engineer. “Or a villain,” added Hutie. “An engineer villain.” And they laughed until Maya politely asked them to be quiet, because she was trying to dream.

On Friday, at breakfast, Mrs. Cohen stood in the dining-hall doorway and asked whether anyone had anything to say. Amy didn’t point at anybody. She didn’t need to. Because Oliver, still pale, and Benny, red as a tomato, stood up together.

“Us,” they said.

And Oliver added, “Happy April Fool’s.”

Mrs. Cohen looked at them for a long time. The whole room held its breath. Then she said, in her quiet voice, “The two of you will clean the ceiling. Every single footprint. With a sponge and a bucket. David will hold the ladder. And Zehava will supervise.”

“With the Queen,” said Zehava, raising the giant spoon like a sceptre.

And the Friday film? The film stayed.

All afternoon, Oliver and Benny stood on the ladder above the tables, scrubbing the ceiling, while the whole house stood beneath them giving advice. “You missed one!” shouted Omer. “Left!” shouted Hutie. “Mind the porridge!” shouted Zehava, although there was no porridge anywhere. And Maya and Tom sat on the floor and clapped for every footprint that disappeared.

When the last footprint was gone, and Benny climbed down with a brown sponge and a happy face, Amy saw something nobody else did. Mrs. Cohen was standing in the doorway with her back to the corridor, looking up at the place where the footprints had been. And she said quietly, only to herself, “The steps were very neat. Very.” And the corner of her mouth trembled.

Then she noticed Amy watching, put on her glasses and walked off quickly.

That night Amy sat on her bed in Room Seven and opened the new notebook. On the page for Case Number 11, she carefully stuck in Oliver’s squared paper. Underneath she wrote:

Case Number 11: Footprints on the Ceiling. Solved. Who: Oliver and Benny. How: upside-down boots on a bald broom. Why: so the new notebook would have a first case. What I learned: even a usual suspect can be a friend.

Falafel hopped onto the bed, sniffed the squared paper, and looked disappointed that it couldn’t be eaten.

She didn’t know that on that very night, in the vegetable patch, someone small and quiet had already started digging. And that in the morning, the first row of carrots, the carrots the whole house had planted for Zehava’s spring carrot cake, simply wouldn’t be there.

Amy the Detective, Chapter 22: April Fool - Like Likro - books to read online