Daniel, Ben and Maya at camp – What Happens at Camp

What Happens at Camp Chapter 48: Shira Watches

By the age of sixteen, Shira Barak had read four hundred and thirty books. She knew the exact number because Nadav counted them for her every year on their shared birthday, as a present he believed she appreciated. She didn't. But she kept the lists. On the latest one, Nadav had sorted the books by type: two hundred and twelve novels, ninety-one thrillers, forty fantasy books, and three cookbooks, "which you read only for the plot." That was true. The second cookbook had an excellent twist in the chapter on dough.

By the age of sixteen, Shira Barak had read four hundred and thirty books. She knew the exact number because Nadav counted them for her every year on their shared birthday, as a present he believed she appreciated. She didn’t. But she kept the lists. On the latest one, Nadav had sorted the books by type: two hundred and twelve novels, ninety-one thrillers, forty fantasy books, and three cookbooks, “which you read only for the plot.” That was true. The second cookbook had an excellent twist in the chapter on dough.

And four hundred and thirty books had taught her one thing more than anything else: the most interesting people in a story are never the ones who shout. They’re the ones standing to the side. The ones who do something small when they think nobody’s watching. Who tape a cable to the floor so someone won’t trip. Who leave a water bottle by a goalpost. Who follow someone at a safe distance all the way to the door, then turn around and walk back alone.

In books, that’s always the clue. And in books, she always got it before anyone else.

In real life it had taken her three weeks and three days. She wasn’t proud of it.

* * *

On the twenty-fourth day, after the cloud lecture, Shira sat on the steps of Heron with her book closed on her knees and the little note in her hand.

The note was already crumpled from being opened and closed so often. At the top, in her small, sharp handwriting, it said Things that don’t add up. And underneath, four items:

1. Nadav floats.

That one added up now. She knew who had taught him. She’d seen, yesterday at water polo, how Daniel looked at the sky when she asked. People who have nothing to do with anything don’t look at the sky like that.

2. Daniel tapes cables.

The talent-night rehearsal. Ben caught his foot in the microphone cable and nearly fell off the stage, and almost nobody noticed. And at sunset, when everyone had gone, Daniel knelt on the stage with a roll of black tape and taped the cable to the floor, a piece every half metre, all the way to the edge. Nobody asked him to. Nobody saw. Except her, because she’d forgotten a book under a bench.

3. Ben took the bus alone in third grade. (Omer told us, proudly.) So why does Daniel follow him everywhere with his eyes, like someone walking a little kid somewhere for the first time?

4. “I don’t need you.” People don’t shout that at someone they really don’t need. They shout it at someone they’re afraid they’ll start needing.

She read the four items and took a pen out of her bag. A red one, not her favourite. Her favourite, the blue one, Lihi had given to Ben two days ago with the label, and Ben still hadn’t returned it. She made a mental note to collect.

Then she started remembering this day. All of it, from the beginning.

* * *

At twenty to six in the morning she’d woken up because Lihi was talking in her sleep (“No, no, a red label, I said red“), and she couldn’t fall asleep again. She got up and stood by the window of Heron, which faced the field.

On the field was Ben. Alone. Kicking the ball against the storeroom wall, over and over, at the same pace, like a clock.

And on the hill above the field, among the eucalyptus trees, sat Daniel.

He wasn’t doing anything. He sat with his knees pulled to his chest, in a hoodie, with a cup of tea he didn’t drink, and watched. When Ben went for a drink, Daniel came down quickly, on quiet feet, left something by the goalpost, and went back up before Ben returned. Shira narrowed her eyes. It was a water bottle. Full. Cold, judging by the drops on it.

Ben came back, saw the bottle, and stopped. He looked around. At the empty field. At the storeroom. At the hill. Daniel was already lying on his back among the trees, vanished into the shade.

Ben drank from the bottle. All of it. Then he put it to one side, carefully, like something you keep.

So it’s him, thought Shira. Every morning. Every morning, that bottle.

She’d seen that bottle before. Yesterday, by the post. And the day before. She’d thought someone on staff kept forgetting bottles on the field. She’d thought it was a coincidence. Four hundred and thirty books, and she’d thought it was a coincidence.

* * *

At sailing, after the ten o’clock snack, she saw more.

She saw Daniel walk past Ben’s boat while Ben was busy arguing with Roy over an oar, and tighten the knot on his sail. Three seconds. Without stopping. Without Ben noticing. Like someone straightening a crooked picture on the wall in someone else’s house.

At the break, when everyone came out of the water, she sat down next to Daniel on the dock. He was wringing water out of his shirt and watching, of course, Ben, who was dragging his boat up the beach alone because he’d refused Omer’s help.

“Tell me,” said Shira, in her most casual voice, the one she used to ask Nadav the time, “does Ben look more like your mom or your dad?”

Daniel froze. It was very small. Half a second. The hand wringing the shirt stopped midway, and water dripped from it onto the planks, drip, drip, drip. Then it went on wringing.

“He looks like himself,” said Daniel.

“That’s not an answer.”

“It’s the only answer Ben would agree to,” said Daniel, and got up and went to help Kobi fold a sail, although Kobi hadn’t asked for help, and nobody folded sails in the middle of the day.

Shira stayed sitting on the dock. She knew a lot about answers. She knew the most interesting answers aren’t the ones people give. They’re the half-second before.

Lihi flopped down beside her, wet and happy, the label maker in its plastic bag. “What were you talking about?” she asked.

“Genetics,” said Shira.

“Oh, I love genetics,” said Lihi. “Did you know Itamar and I both hate coriander? It’s genetic! I printed him a label!”

Later, out on the water, Shira saw Ben with his nose red from the sun. And she saw Daniel looking at that nose and frowning, like someone remembering something he’d forgotten. And at lunch, when Ben went back to Catfish to change his shirt, there was a tube of sunscreen on his bed, factor fifty, with a Lihi label on it that said Nobody’s. Shira had seen Lihi print that label. She had seen Daniel ask for it. Quietly, with his back to everyone.

She saw Daniel’s left shoulder go up when Roy said something to Ben in the lunch queue. The left shoulder, always the left. The movement Daniel made when he wanted to say something and decided not to.

And she saw, at the Catfish table, Ben watching Omer’s video. Three seconds. And again. She saw his face when Omer paused it. Ben didn’t cry. Ben never cried. But his face did what people’s faces do just before.

And at the cloud lecture, she saw Ben sitting in the back row, looking at the back of Daniel’s head the entire lecture. And not at the sky. Not once. Which was impressive, because Nadav projected a cloud shaped like a goose, and the whole camp, Zehava included, shouted “Admiral!”

* * *

Shira opened the note and began to write.

5. Carmeli. Navon.

She looked at it for a long time. It was so simple she was angry with herself. On the second day, when Zehava read out “the Carmeli-Navon family” in the draw, the whole camp laughed because it sounded like a law firm. Nobody asked why two brothers had two surnames. Everyone was too busy discovering they were brothers.

She hadn’t asked either. She’d been reading Jane Eyre.

6. “My mom.” Daniel says it in the past tense. Ben says it in the present.

On treasure-hunt day, Daniel had said, without noticing, “My mom used to say the Kinneret is a sea that’s shy.” Used to. And on relay day, Ben had yelled at Omer, “My mom will kill me if I lose this.” Will. Two brothers. Two mothers. One in the past, one in the present.

And suddenly the other thing, which had been sitting in her head for two weeks, fell into place. That day, four days ago, when Daniel disappeared to the dock at dawn and didn’t come to a single activity, and Maya said he was “sulking.” It wasn’t sulking. Shira remembered his face when he came back that evening. She’d seen a face like that once before, on her grandfather, on the anniversary of her grandmother’s death.

She wrote it, and crossed it out, and wrote it again, and didn’t add it as an item. Some things don’t go on a list. But she knew.

7. Daniel kicked Nadav under the table. And Nadav ate only half a pastry.

She wrote that item with a small smile. Nadav was her brother. She’d known him four minutes longer than anyone else in the world. She knew Nadav would never have written “if you’re writing about someone else’s parents, you should call your own.” Nadav would have written “according to Central Bureau of Statistics data.” And that line, “I didn’t do it fast enough either,” wasn’t Nadav’s. Nadav had never been slow at anything in his life, except swimming.

It was the line of someone who had watched a kid alone for a long time and didn’t know how to get closer.

* * *

“Shira?”

Maya was standing at the bottom of the steps, Yuval in one hand and her phone in the other. She looked better than yesterday. Her eyes weren’t puffy anymore. But she had a strange expression, the expression of someone trying to solve something and failing.

“Nadav,” said Maya. “Was he always like this? He wrote… he wrote ‘I was wrong about a lot of things too.’ What was Nadav wrong about with me? I’ve barely talked to him all summer.”

Shira closed the note inside her book, naturally, the way you close a bookmark.

“Nadav’s wrong about lots of things,” she said. “Mostly when he’s sure.”

Maya laughed, but not completely. She stood there a moment longer. “And Daniel?” she asked suddenly, in a voice trying to be casual. “Was he with him when he wrote it? Did you see?”

Shira looked at her friend. At Maya, who had been so sure, for so long, so loudly. Shira loved her. That was the thing. She loved her enough to know Maya wouldn’t forgive herself when she found out. And that she would find out. Because that’s how it goes in books. And in real life, it turns out, too.

“I didn’t see,” said Shira. Which was true. She hadn’t seen. She just knew.

Maya nodded and walked off with Yuval toward Gull. Shira watched her go.

Then she opened the book again, took out the note, and at the bottom, beneath the seven items, wrote one line, and drew a line under it. Not an item. A decision.

Tonight I ask.

And then, because she was Shira Barak and would never under any circumstances give up a chapter, she opened the book where she’d stopped and read a whole chapter more, to the end. When she finished, she discovered she didn’t remember a single word of it. It was the first time in her life that had happened.

What Happens at Camp Chapter 48: Shira Watches - Like Likro - books to read online