Daniel, Ben and Maya at camp – What Happens at Camp

What Happens at Camp Chapter 40: A Letter Never Sent

The seed was Alon's.

The seed was Alon’s.

It was the seed from the dock, from the morning of Mom’s day. The I’m in seed. Daniel had kept it in the pocket of his gray sweater for two days, and in the evening, after the field, when he pulled off the sweater and threw it on the bed, the seed jumped out of the pocket, rolled across the yellow-and-blue blanket, fell, and disappeared into the gap between the bed and the wall.

Daniel could have let it go. It was a seed. Alon had a hundred thousand of them, in a bag, in every pocket, probably in his socks too.

He didn’t let it go. He lay down on the floor, on his stomach, switched on his phone’s flashlight, and reached into the darkness under the bed.

He found: one of Nadav’s socks. A chocolate wrapper. The first label Lihi had ever stuck on him, on the first day, on his cup, Daniel, which had fallen off at some point. A piece of blue rope the Admiral must have missed. The seed.

And a page.

A page folded four times, wedged between the mattress and the wall, as if someone had rolled over onto it in his sleep and pushed it there without knowing. Daniel pulled it out and shone the light on it.

On the outside, in crooked handwriting, with a pen pressed too hard, it said: To Amir.

* * *

Daniel sat on the floor with the page in his hand for a long time.

Nadav was in the showers. Alon was at a card game in the Sharks’ cabin, where, according to rumor, he was winning everyone’s sweets without saying a word. The cabin was quiet. Outside, the frogs were starting their shift.

To Amir.

He knew whose it was. He knew the handwriting. The A that looked like an upside-down chair. The r that trailed off past the line. It was the handwriting on the note on the blanket, you’ve got sun on your nose. And it was the handwriting on the sign on the door at home, Keep out, especially you.

And Ben had slept here, on the floor, on the night of the blackout. In his hoodie.

He shouldn’t read it. He knew he shouldn’t read it. It wasn’t his. It wasn’t his secret. He had said that very sentence to Maya three times this summer, it’s not my secret, and meant it every time.

But it was a letter to his father.

And it hadn’t been sent. It had fallen. Out of a pocket, under a bed. Maybe Ben had forgotten it. Maybe Ben had wanted to send it, and forgot. Maybe, Daniel thought, and hated himself a little for thinking it, maybe he needed to check whether it was something Dad ought to get.

He unfolded the page.

* * *

The handwriting inside was worse than on the outside. The pen had torn the paper in one place. Some words were crossed out, with other words written over them, harder. The first line didn’t say Dear Amir. It didn’t say Hi. It only said:

Amir,

Zehava says we have to write a letter to someone at home. So I’m writing to you. Not because you’re home. Because you’re in my home, and that’s the problem.

You’re not my father. I want that to be clear. My father lives in Berlin and has a baby called Leon who has a striped hat. My father doesn’t call, but he’s my father. You’re just someone my mom married.

So stop.

Stop knocking on my door at night to say good night. I can hear you standing there. You stand there for five seconds before you knock. I count. Don’t knock.

Stop making pancakes on Fridays, like we’re a family in an ad. I don’t like pancakes. (I do. But not yours.) (Yours come out better than Mom’s. Don’t tell her.)

Stop shaking my hand. Man to man. I’m not your man.

Stop asking how school was. You don’t really want to know. My father never asked, and at least he was honest.

And stop putting the Maccabi games on the TV in the living room and then going into the kitchen, like it’s by chance, so I can watch on my own. I know you do it on purpose. I’m not stupid. You’re a Hapoel fan. I saw the scarf in the storage room.

And your son. Tell him to stop too. Tell him to stop being nice. To stop putting sunscreen on my window, and eating chili, and sitting outside the cabin. I know how this ends. It always ends the same way. At first everyone’s nice, and then they go to Berlin.

Daniel stopped to breathe. He didn’t know he had stopped to breathe until his lungs asked him to.

The next line was crossed out. With a very hard line, over and over, until the paper tore there. But he could just read the beginning of it: And if I start to love

And then, under the line, in smaller letters, as if someone had decided to say this only quietly:

And stop making my mom laugh like that. Because then I can’t hate you properly.

Ben.

* * *

Daniel sat on the floor with the page. Outside, the frogs carried on as if nothing had happened. From somewhere on the hill came Gili’s guitar, and over it, for a moment, a small laugh, from someone who never laughs.

And stop making my mom laugh like that.

He thought about Dad. About Dad coming home from work at night with the face of someone who has carried something heavy all day, and who, in the first year after Mom, didn’t laugh at all. And about Dad now, standing in the kitchen on Fridays with a frying pan, singing eighties songs wrong so that Michal will laugh, and Michal laughs, and it’s the best thing in the house, and also the thing Ben hates him for.

He thought about the five seconds by the door. He hadn’t known Dad did that. He hadn’t known Dad put the Maccabi games on and went into the kitchen. He hadn’t known that Dad had been trying, every evening, quietly, in ways that Ben counted and Daniel never saw.

And if I start to love

He read it again. The crossed-out part. The part Ben had written and then tried to make disappear, until the pen tore the paper.

And then he understood why Ben had shouted at him today on the field. I don’t need you. It wasn’t I don’t love you. It was the opposite. It was someone in the water, seeing someone throw him a rope, and so afraid the rope would hold that he would rather drown.

* * *

He had two options. He could see them both, clearly, like two directions of wind.

He could take the page to Ben. Knock on the Catfish door and say I found this, and maybe sit with him, and tell him I’m not going to Berlin. I’m not going anywhere. And my father isn’t going anywhere. And you can love, and nothing bad will happen.

But he saw Ben’s face, today, on the field. Do you know what it’s like when everyone sees someone has to rescue you?

And if Ben knew that Daniel had read this, this of all things, And if I start to love, he would never forgive him. Not because Daniel had read it. Because Daniel had seen. And that was what Ben couldn’t bear: being seen.

So he chose the second option.

He folded the page. Exactly along the old folds, four times, with the care of someone putting a broken thing back on a shelf. He checked that the torn corner was tucked inside. He lay on his stomach again, reached under the bed, and put the page back in its place, between the mattress and the wall, exactly where he had found it.

The seed he kept in his pocket. He had a strange feeling that Alon would agree, and that even if he didn’t, Alon wouldn’t say.

* * *

At a quarter past ten, someone knocked on the door.

One knock. Small. Barely a knock. Daniel knew who it was before he opened.

Ben was standing there. Not in pajamas this time. In clothes, with his hoodie, his hands in his pockets, and the face of someone who would rather be anywhere else in the world, including inside the Admiral’s nest.

“I’m not here to apologize,” said Ben at once.

“Okay.”

“I just… I think I forgot something here. That night. The blackout.” He looked past Daniel’s shoulder, into the cabin, toward the corner, toward the bed. “It’s not important. It’s just paper.”

Daniel stepped aside.

Ben came in. He didn’t look at Daniel. He got down on his knees by the bed, reached in, searched. Daniel saw his shoulders tense, and then relax, when his hand found it.

Ben pulled out the page. He looked at it. He checked the folds, Daniel saw, with his fingers, one by one, like someone checking whether a drawer has been opened. Four folds. Clean. Exactly as they had been.

He looked up.

“Did you read it?” he asked.

Daniel looked at him. He thought about all the possible answers. No would be a lie. Yes would be a truth Ben couldn’t carry. And he had already lied once today, in the dining hall, with the pillow, and that lie was still stuck in his throat like a fish bone.

“It’s yours,” said Daniel. “It was always yours.”

Ben looked at him for a long time. Daniel didn’t know what he saw. Maybe nothing. Maybe everything.

Then Ben put the page in the pocket of his hoodie, deep down, and went out. At the door he stopped, with his back to Daniel, one hand on the door frame. The Pelican door frame was low. Ben reached it easily.

“On the field,” he said, to the dark. “What I said.”

Daniel waited.

“It was true,” said Ben. “I don’t need you.”

“I know.”

“But…” Ben stopped. His hand pressed on the frame, then let go. “But Messi was good. Roy didn’t know what to say. I’ve never seen Roy with nothing to say.”

And he left.

* * *

Daniel sat on the bed. Outside, he heard Ben’s footsteps going down the path, and the Catfish door opening and closing, and Omer starting to snore, as if he had been waiting for Ben to come back before he began.

He took out the blue notebook.

He went through the rules. One, don’t drown. Two, don’t drown anyone else. Three, if someone forgets, someone else has to remember. Four, don’t like the enemy, crossed out, and written again, and eight seconds in the margin.

He turned to a new page. A completely blank page.

At the top of the page, he wrote a heading. Slowly. In neat letters, like Lihi’s:

What Ben needs to feel at home.

He looked at it for a long time, the way you look at a map of a place you’ve never been. Then, underneath, he wrote the first item. It was the only thing he was completely sure of.

1. That Dad keeps making Michal laugh. Even if it ruins things for him.

He closed the notebook, put it under his pillow, and switched off the flashlight. And in the dark, with Alon’s seed in his pocket, and the words And if I start to love burned behind his eyes like a light you’ve stared at for too long, he lay and listened to the tractor through the wall until he fell asleep.

What Happens at Camp Chapter 40: A Letter Never Sent - Like Likro - books to read online