The snow fell slowly. Flake after flake, like someone trying not to wake anybody. It landed on the fence, on the shed roof and on everyone’s shoulders, and melted. And Benny stood by the paddock gate with his hands in his pockets and didn’t move.
“I can’t,” he said again. “I just can’t. I don’t know how, and I don’t want to mess it up.”
“You don’t have to do it alone,” said Amy. “Nobody here does things alone. It’s the rule of the house. Mrs Cohen says so every day.”
“Mrs Cohen says lots of things,” said Benny. But he took his hands out of his pockets.
David gave out jobs, like before a match. “Leo, you hold the book and the torch and read out what to do, step by step. Ari, you run to the kitchen and get a bucket of water from Zehava, warm, not hot, warm, and salt, and a towel. Maya, you hold the rope of his head collar, by his head, with a carrot. Just hold. Don’t pull. Hutie…”
“I’ll sing,” said Hutie at once. “Horses like songs. I saw a film.”
“You’ll sing,” agreed David, to everyone’s surprise. “A quiet song. Amy, you’re on the hoof pick, and on eyes. You see things other people don’t. And Benny…” He looked at Benny. “Benny lifts the leg.”
“And you?” asked Benny.
“I’m behind you,” said David. “With my hands over yours. The whole time. I won’t let go for a second.”
Benny took a deep breath. Then he did something nobody expected. He didn’t go to Sugar. He went to the corner of the fence, turned over the old bucket and sat on it. Back to the fence. Like before. Like in his first months. And waited.
Amy knew why the bucket. Benny had told her once, only once, on the evening of the candle nobody counts, sitting on the third stair. “In the first months,” he’d said, “everyone asked me questions. How I felt, whether I missed home, whether I wanted to talk. Only Sugar didn’t ask anything. He just chewed my hair. So I sat with him. Every evening. Until I stopped wanting to shout.”
“What’s he doing?” whispered Maya.
“What he did every evening in his first months here,” whispered Amy. “He’s waiting for Sugar to come to him. That’s how it worked then. Benny didn’t go to Sugar. Sugar went to Benny.”
In the quiet snow, everyone waited. One minute. Two. Five. Snow began to build up on Benny’s hat like a white cap. He didn’t move. Then from the manger came a snort. One hoof, another, a light one, another. Sugar limped slowly all the way across the paddock to the fence. He stopped behind Benny. He lowered his head. And gently took between his lips a bit of hair poking out under the hat. And chewed.
Benny didn’t turn round. But Amy saw from the side that he had closed his eyes. “Hi, Sugar,” he whispered. “Remember me?”
And Sugar, by way of answer, chewed a bit more.
“Now,” whispered David. “Slowly.”
Benny got up from the bucket. He didn’t hurry. He ran a hand down Sugar’s neck, his shoulder, his leg, from top to bottom, as Leo read from the book in a low voice: “Run your hand down the leg so the horse knows where you are. Never surprise him.” David stood close behind Benny with his big hands over Benny’s, as he’d promised.
And Hutie began to sing. Quietly. The Hilltop Song. Tova’s song. And without planning it, everyone joined in, whispering. Maya with the carrot. Ari, back with the steaming bucket. Leo behind the torch. Even David, behind Benny, hummed. And the snow fell on them all.
Tom, who refused to be left out of anything, got a job too. “You’re the gatekeeper,” David told him. “Nobody comes in and nobody shouts. And if Kuku turns up, ask him politely to leave.” Tom stood by the gate as straight as a soldier and whispered “Shhh!” at anyone who came near, including the snow.
“Now,” whispered Leo, from the book. “Press gently behind the knee. And say ‘foot’.”
“Foot,” whispered Benny. And pressed. Gently, the way you’d ring the doorbell of someone asleep.
And Sugar, after a long second, a very long one, in which nobody breathed, lifted his foot.
Benny caught it in both hands and held on. David held on above him. Sugar’s leg trembled a little, but didn’t kick. Amy knelt beside them with the curved pick, and Leo brought the torch close.
The hoof was packed. Frozen mud, straw and gravel, all pressed together, hard as concrete. “Gently,” whispered David. “Heel towards toe. Never towards the frog.”
Amy scraped. Slowly. A lump of mud fell out. Then another. Warm water that Ari poured from a mug softened the rest. Sugar snorted but didn’t move. Maya gave him the carrot, and Hutie kept singing, for the third time, because she couldn’t remember the second verse.
Then Amy saw it.
By the frog, in the groove, wedged deep, was a stone. A small grey stone the size of a tooth, with a sharp triangular point that had gone into the soft sole. Around it the hoof looked a little red.
“Found it,” whispered Amy. “It’s here. I can see it.”
“Take it out,” whispered David. “One movement. Quick and gentle.”
But Amy hesitated. Her hand shook. Because if she hurt him, and he kicked, and Benny got hurt… Then she felt a hand on hers. A dirty, cold hand with short nails. Benny’s. He let go of the leg with one hand, David held it in his place, and Benny put his fingers on the pick, together with hers.
“Together,” he said. “One. Two…”
On three, they pulled.
The stone popped out, flew and dropped into the snow, and vanished. Sugar gave a long snort, a very long one, like someone putting down a heavy rucksack after a hike. And his leg, in Benny’s and David’s hands, went soft.
“There it is!” shouted Tom, who had stood beyond the fence the whole time with the face of someone waiting for a goal. He dived into the snow, searched with his hands and held up the stone like a cup. “I found it! I found the frog!”
“It’s a stone, Tom,” said Leo.
“I know,” said Tom. “But that sounds better.”
Ari brought the bucket. They put the hoof in the warm salty water, as the book said, “to clean it”. Sugar stood with one foot in the bucket, waited patiently, ate another carrot and looked as if he were in a hotel bath.
While Sugar stood in the bucket, Leo shut the book and found his hands were shaking. “I was scared the whole time I’d read something wrong,” he admitted. “Skip a line. And because of me…” “You didn’t skip anything,” said Ari, and gave him the empty mug to hold, because Ari knows that sometimes shaking hands just need something to hold. Leo held the mug and calmed down. Then, being Leo, he opened the book again, checked again, and found that he really hadn’t. “Not a single word,” he announced, very relieved. Amy wrote in the margin: Leo: best reader in the world. And: Ari: knows what hands need.
Then came the most important thing. When they took the hoof out of the bucket, dried it with the towel, and Benny lowered it slowly, slowly to the ground, Sugar leaned on it. With his whole weight. And didn’t lift it. He walked, a step, another step, to the manger. Almost normally. Just a slight limp. Like someone who remembers it hurt but isn’t sure why any more.
Everyone cheered. Hutie, who still couldn’t remember the second verse, made one up about horses and snow, and nobody corrected her. Maya hugged Sugar round the neck and Falafel at the same time, and neither of them liked it much. And David, right there in the snow, hugged Benny. A big bear hug. Benny, who doesn’t like hugs, stayed in it and didn’t move.
“Goalkeeper,” said David, his voice a little hoarse. “Sugar’s goalkeeper. The best he’s ever had.”
That evening the road opened for an hour, and Dr Shapiro arrived in a jeep with chains on its wheels. She examined the hoof, tapped it, looked into Sugar’s eyes and said there was no abscess, and that whoever had taken out the stone had done a real vet’s job. “Who was it?” she asked. Benny pointed at Amy, Amy pointed at Benny, everyone pointed at everyone, and Dr Shapiro laughed and said it was the first house she’d seen where the whole house looked after a horse. She bandaged the hoof, and Oliver, appearing from nowhere, contributed a roll of orange tape, “from the old days”, so the bandage would hold in the snow.
Mrs Cohen, in tall boots and a coat with a fur collar, reached the fence just as the jeep drove out of the gate. She looked at Sugar eating, at the orange bandage, at seven wet, muddy, happy children and at David in the middle. “Seven points to the Together column,” she said. “And three more for the goalkeeper.” Benny said it was the most points he’d ever got without kicking anything. Then Zehava called everyone in for cocoa, and they all ran, and only Benny stayed by the fence a moment longer.
David spread the gravel that same evening. On the path under Mrs Cohen’s window, where it should have gone in the first place. And he tied the manger to the shed post with a rope. “So no Backwards Day,” he announced, “ever moves it again.” Maya promised, perfectly seriously, that next year she would only turn round things nobody eats from.
Amy wrote: Case Number 39: Sugar Won’t Eat. Solved. Why he wasn’t eating: the food was too far away, on stones. What was in his foot: a sharp stone by the frog. Who took it out: Benny and me, together. With David behind. And everyone else around. What I learned: a frightened horse only trusts the one who sat quietly beside him for many evenings. People too.
The stone, the triangular one, Benny gave to nobody. He put it in his pocket. And that night, Amy knew, he put it on the shelf in the Quiet Room, beside the horse with the new tail. Because some things are best kept where nobody asks.
Later, from the window of Room Seven, Amy saw a small torch moving in the dark snow by the paddock. She knew who it was. Benny was sitting on the upturned bucket, back to the fence, wrapped in a blanket, and Sugar stood behind him with his head over his shoulder, gently chewing his hat. They weren’t doing anything. Just sitting. Snow fell on both of them, and nobody asked any questions.
And the snow kept falling. All night. It covered the fence, the coop, the gate and the new path. In the morning, when Amy opened her eyes, the light in the room was white and strange and quiet, quiet the way Hilltop House never is. She leapt to the window.
Everything was white. The whole world. To the horizon.
And from the yard below came a shout. David’s voice. “The sled! Has anyone seen the sled? It’s not in the shed!”