Nobody moved. Even Shira, who had shut her eyes, slowly opened one to look.
Falafel was lying behind the loose panel in his old nest, a nest of socks, rebuilt. Hutie’s red sock, the strawberry sock, three socks nobody remembered losing, a doll’s jumper and a scrap of towel. And it was all warm. Amy felt the warmth on her face, like a little oven. In the middle, between Falafel’s paws, sat Pip. Chewing. And chewing. Without a care in the world.
“Pip,” whispered Tom, sounding like someone seeing a miracle. A small, golden miracle with full cheeks.
He reached out his hand. And Falafel, who had never bitten anyone, ever, huffed. One short huff through his nose. A rabbit’s warning. Tom snatched his hand back as if he had touched a kettle.
“He won’t let me,” Tom whispered, amazed. “Falafel won’t give me my Pip.”
“Let me,” said Maya.
And Maya, who had looked after Falafel since Case Number 2, who slept with him and talked to him every night when she was sad, knelt in front of the panel and didn’t reach out. She just talked. Quietly, in the voice she always used with him at bedtime. “Falafel,” she said. “It’s all right. It’s Tom. Tom’s in charge. He looks after Pip. We’re not taking him away from you for ever. We’re just taking him home.”
Falafel looked at her for a long time. Then, slowly, he moved one front paw a little step to the side. And Pip, who had finished chewing, peeped out, saw Tom, squeaked, and crawled all by himself straight into Tom’s open hands.
Tom didn’t say anything. He just held Pip close, close to his chest, and began to cry. But this time it was the good kind. The kind that ends in laughing.
“He’s warm,” he whispered. “He’s so warm.”
“Of course he’s warm,” said Leo. “He slept all night next to a rabbit. Rabbits are basically hot-water bottles with ears.”
But the case wasn’t closed yet. And Amy knew it.
“Who opened the cage?” she asked on the third stair, after Pip was back in his cage and Tom was sitting beside it, refusing to move. “David said the catch was fine. That someone opened it from outside. By force, or by patience.”
“Shoelace,” said Hutie. “Shoelace opened it, and Falafel saved Pip from him! Falafel’s a hero!”
“Mr Ben-Ami and Shoelace went home at six,” said Ari. “I saw them leave. And Tom shut the cage at half past eight. I was there. He checked twice.”
“So not Shoelace,” said Amy, crossing out the line in her notebook with one straight stroke. “Who’s left?”
Everyone looked at Falafel, sitting by Maya and chewing a carrot without the slightest sign of guilt.
“You can’t blame a rabbit without proof,” said Amy. “Not even a rabbit.”
“Then let’s prove it,” said Leo. And his eyes shone.
The experiment took place that evening in the little ones’ room. With an audience. Because when anyone at Hilltop House says “experiment”, everyone comes.
Leo took Pip out of the cage, carefully, and gave him to Tom, who held him inside his jumper like a pocket. Then he put a slice of carrot in the empty cage. Shut the little door. Put the catch on. Checked twice, like Tom. Then he set the cage on the floor. Maya brought Falafel and put him down a metre in front of it. Everyone moved back along the wall and held their breath.
Falafel sat. He looked at the cage. He looked at the audience. He scratched his ear. And Benny, waiting for some action, whispered, “This is the most boring thing I’ve ever seen.”
Then Falafel got up.
He hopped once, to the cage. Sniffed the bars. Sniffed the catch. Then slowly, like someone who had done it many times before, he rested his chin on the catch. And pressed. Down. The catch moved a little. Falafel shifted his head and pushed with his nose. Sideways. Once. Twice. Three times.
Click.
The little door swung open. Falafel put his head in, took the carrot, and sat down to eat it in perfect peace, in front of forty people standing with their mouths open.
In the silence afterwards you could hear Falafel chewing. Then Benny, who a moment earlier had called it the most boring thing in his life, whispered with deep respect, “Wow.” Others joined in. And Tom, still holding Pip inside his jumper, whispered to him, “See? That’s your friend. He’s a genius.”
“Two minutes and seven seconds,” said Leo, looking at his watch. “By force. And by patience. David was right on both counts.”
“Falafel!” said Maya, in the voice of a mother who finds her child has drawn on the wall. But she couldn’t hide how proud she was.
Amy wrote: Suspect: Falafel. Method: chin and nose. Proved. Now we just need to know why.
“Because he wanted a friend,” said Hutie. “Like Ari with the labels. Like the jay with the chess. Everyone in this house wants a friend.”
“Or because he wanted to eat the seeds,” said Benny. “He’s a rabbit. Rabbits eat.”
Ari didn’t say anything. He went to the window by the chest of drawers and put his hand on it, as Leo had that morning. Then he turned round.
“Three days,” he said quietly, “Falafel stood in front of the cage. We all thought he was curious. Or jealous. But he didn’t look at Pip like food. He looked at him like…” Ari searched for the word. “Like Amy looked at me, the night of the labels. Like someone who sees somebody on their own, shivering.”
“Wait,” said Leo, leafing through the book. “It says here that when rabbits are cold, they sleep pressed up against each other. In a heap. To keep warm. It’s called…” He stopped. “It doesn’t say what it’s called. It just says they do it.”
“And nine degrees,” said Amy slowly. “By the window. At night. And Pip, so small, shivering in his wood shavings. And Falafel standing in front of him all day, watching.”
“So he opened the cage,” whispered Maya, “and took him to the warmest place he knew. His nest. To warm him up.”
“It doesn’t say that in the book,” said Leo. “That rabbits do that. For other animals.”
Amy closed her notebook. “Not everything’s in the book, Leo,” she said. “Some things are only written at Hilltop House.”
But there was one more thing left. The hardest.
“I have to tell Miss,” said Tom, sounding like someone going to the dentist. “Miss said if anything happens, no matter what, I have to ring. Even in the holidays.”
“But Pip’s fine now,” said Hutie. “She doesn’t need to know.”
Tom looked at Pip, asleep now inside his jumper, curled up like a bread roll. “Being in charge,” he said quietly, “isn’t just shutting the door. It’s also saying when it came open.”
Nobody said anything, because nobody could have put it better.
So Amy went with him to Mrs Cohen’s office, to the telephone. Mrs Cohen dialled, handed Tom the receiver and left the room so he’d have privacy. But she left the door open a crack. And Amy stood outside and listened.
“Miss Orna?” said Tom in a shaky voice. “It’s Tom. From the class. I need to tell you something. Pip ran away. Because he was cold. And our rabbit opened his cage with his chin and took him to a nest of socks to warm him up. And now he’s fine. But I wanted you to know. Because I’m in charge.”
There was a long silence at the other end. Then Amy heard, even through the door, laughter. Long, warm teacher’s laughter.
Tom listened, and listened, and his face changed slowly. From fear, to surprise, to joy. “Really?” he said. “Really? Falafel too?”
When he came out he was at least a metre and a half tall, although usually he barely reached the door handle. “Miss said,” he announced, “it’s the most responsible thing a Year One child has ever done. That telling the truth when something goes wrong matters more than never getting it wrong. And that the cage has to move away from the window. And…” He took a deep breath. “And after the holidays I’m bringing Falafel to class. For a visit. Because everyone needs to meet a rabbit who rescues hamsters.”
That night Tom refused to sleep. He sat up in bed with the cage on his knees and announced that he was on guard. All night. “Like a goalkeeper,” he explained. Noam found him like that on his ten o’clock round and didn’t argue. He just moved the cage onto the chest of drawers, close to the bed but well away from the window, tucked Tom in and told him that guards need sleep too, or they miss the penalties. Tom fell asleep with his hand outside the blanket, touching the bars. And Falafel, Maya found later, was asleep on the floor under the chest of drawers. As if he were on guard too.
The cage moved to the warm corner by the radiator, far from the window. David mended the window, and Leo added a clothes peg to the catch, “against chins”. And every afternoon until the end of the holiday, David put up a low fence of planks in the little ones’ room, a sort of tiny yard, and there, for half an hour, Falafel and Pip played together. That is, Falafel lay down, and Pip climbed onto him and sat between his ears like a king on a hill. And the whole of Hilltop House came to watch every day, as if it were the best film in the world.
Hutie, who couldn’t bear the thought of anyone at Hilltop House shivering, spent two evenings with her threads knitting Pip a scarf. A tiny scarf the length of a finger, in blue and white, like Ari’s bracelet. Pip refused to wear it for even a second. He took it in his mouth, dragged it to the corner and built a nest out of it. “That’s fine too,” said Hutie proudly. “As long as he’s warm.”
Oliver suggested painting orange stripes on the cage, “because orange is a warm colour, it’s science”, and was outvoted thirty-nine to one, and was offended, and then painted one small orange stripe on the lid of the seed box when nobody was looking. Nobody rubbed it off.
At the end of the holiday Tom took Pip back to class. With the cage, the scarf and a letter Amy helped him write about everything that had happened, with pictures. A week later, as the teacher had promised, Falafel came to visit in a basket, with Maya, and David to drive them. He sat on the teacher’s desk in front of twenty-three children and did nothing special at all, except eat a lettuce leaf. And everyone clapped as if he had saved the world. And Pip, from his cage in the corner, squeaked.
Amy wrote: Case Number 33: The Hamster on Holiday. Solved. Suspect: Falafel. Crime: keeping warm. Punishment: none. Reward: a friend.
But when David mended the window in the little ones’ room, he said something that Amy wrote down, just in case, on the last line of the page. “Odd,” he said, sniffing. “The window’s shut now. But there’s still a draught. A cold one. From the corridor. As if someone left a door open somewhere. A door I don’t know about.”
And on Friday evening, when Zehava lit the candles on the big table in the dining room as she did every week, and everyone sang, exactly seven minutes later, with no window open and nobody blowing, every candle went out. All of them. Together. At once.