Daniel, Ben and Maya at camp – What Happens at Camp

What Happens at Camp Chapter 93: Always

The steps of the sports hall were cold.

The steps of the sports hall were cold.

Ben sat on the top step, Ahuva’s grey blanket round him, his back to the door. From inside came voices: Omer’s laugh, Gili’s guitar, playing again, and Shimon explaining to someone for the third time that a sandwich with no name is the worst punishment there is. Outside it was quiet. Only the frogs, the wind in the eucalyptus trees, and far off, the Kinneret, which at night sounds like someone breathing in their sleep.

The police cars had gone. All the blue and red lights had vanished, and the night had gone back to being just a night, with an almost full moon and stars.

Daniel came out right behind him, shut the door, and sat down beside him. Not half a metre away. Right next to him.

They were quiet for a long time.

“They caught them,” Ben said at last. As if he needed to say it out loud for it to be true.

“They caught them,” said Daniel.

“It’s over.”

“It’s over.”

Ben nodded. Then nodded again. Then realised he couldn’t stop nodding, that his chin was trembling, his eyes were burning, and something was rising from his stomach, slowly, like a huge wave approaching from far away, which you can see coming and can’t escape.

“Daniel,” he said. His voice cracked.

“I’m here.”

“You believed me.”

He didn’t ask. He said it the way you say something you don’t understand. Something in a foreign language that you repeat, and repeat again, and still don’t understand.

“You believed me,” he said again. “Before I said anything. Before I told anyone about the van. Before Roy came. Before everything. I ran to you, covered in mud, and you’d heard what everyone was saying, and… and you said ‘It wasn’t you.’ Without asking where I’d been. Without asking anything.”

“Yes,” said Daniel.

“Why?”

Daniel looked at him. His face was very serious, no smile at all, like when he watches the wind before a race.

“Because I know you,” he said. “And I’ll always believe you.”

“Always?”

“Always.”

* * *

Then the wave arrived.

Ben didn’t decide to cry. It just happened. His whole body folded at once, forwards, like a sail the wind has left, and he cried. Not like behind the boathouse, with the short breaths and the fear. Differently. A deep, shaking, long cry, from the lowest place in his stomach, from the place where all those years he had kept every time nobody believed him.

The window in fourth grade. The teacher. The head. Why do you always do this to me. Two grey ticks. A picture of a baby in a striped hat. A birthday with no phone call. I apologise on his behalf. Again. Always you.

It all came out. At once. Like a slat snapping.

And Daniel said nothing. He just opened his arms, and Ben fell into them. Not like on the path, when he’d crashed into him like a wall. Differently. Like someone getting home after a very long journey and finally putting down his bag.

Daniel held him. Tight. One hand on his back and one on his head, the way his mom had held him once, at Bat Yam, after a wave knocked him over and he swallowed water and cried. He didn’t say “Enough.” He didn’t say “It’s okay.” He didn’t say anything. He just held on, and breathed, slowly, four and six, like before a penalty, until Ben, without noticing, began breathing in the same rhythm.

It took a long time. Daniel didn’t count.

* * *

“I read the letter,” said Daniel, when Ben was only shaking now, not crying.

Ben didn’t move. His head was still on Daniel’s shoulder. “What letter?”

“To Dad. The one you wrote in letter-writing hour. And didn’t send.” Daniel took a breath. “You dropped it, and I found it, and I read it. Before I gave it back. I’m sorry. It wasn’t okay. I want you to know.”

Ben was quiet for a long moment. Then, from inside Daniel’s shoulder, in a hoarse voice:

“Did you read the crossed-out line?”

“Only the beginning.”

“‘And if I start to love,'” said Ben.

“Yes.”

Ben lifted his head. His face was red, wet, swollen, and never, Daniel thought, had he looked so fourteen and so grown-up at the same time.

“Do you want to know how it ends?” asked Ben.

Daniel didn’t answer. He just waited.

“‘And if I start to love you,'” said Ben slowly, word by word, as if reading it off the torn page, “‘you’ll leave. Everyone leaves in the end. Dad left. So better not.'”

The frogs kept croaking. The Kinneret kept breathing.

“I crossed it out,” said Ben, “because it was true. And I didn’t want Amir to read something true.”

“Do you know how he left?” Ben asked. “Roni?”

Daniel shook his head.

“I was eleven. It was my last Saturday at his flat, before Berlin. I remember, because there was a match that morning. I came back from the field, and his suitcase was already standing by the door. The big blue one, with the aeroplane sticker. And he was standing next to it, holding his keys.” Ben looked at his hands. “He didn’t hug me. He just said: ‘Be a good boy for your mother. And don’t do to her what you did to me.'”

Daniel said nothing. But Ben felt his arm tighten.

“Three years,” said Ben, “I thought it was because of me. That if I’d been a better kid, he’d have stayed. That if I hadn’t broken the window, which I didn’t break, and the vase, which the cat broke, he’d have stayed.” He sniffed. “Then Mom met Amir, and Amir was nice. Too nice. And I was scared that if I was a bad kid, he’d leave too. And if I was a good kid, and then he left, it would be even worse. So I decided to be bad in advance. That way at least I’d know why.”

“That’s the saddest logic I’ve ever heard,” Daniel said quietly.

“I know,” said Ben. “But it worked. Until you came.”

“And now?” asked Daniel quietly.

Ben looked at him for a long time.

“Now it’s not true,” he said. “Because you didn’t leave. Even when I yelled. Even when I said I didn’t need you. You sat on the steps all night. You went back for Asaf. You stood up to the policewoman. You… you don’t leave.” He swallowed. “You’re good at going back.”

“I’m good at staying,” said Daniel. “That’s the third half. Mom didn’t have time to teach me. I learned it myself. From you.”

* * *

Ben laughed. A small, wet laugh, through his nose, that came in the middle of the crying and broke it in two.

“There’s no third half,” he said.

“There is now.”

“That’s not maths.”

“I hate maths,” said Daniel. “I told you. One test, a corridor, a caretaker.”

Ben laughed again, and this time it was a real laugh. He wiped his face on Ahuva’s grey blanket, which was now probably the wettest blanket at camp. Then he leaned back against the door and looked at the stars.

“Daniel.”

“What?”

“I want to give it to him. The letter. To Amir. Tomorrow.”

Daniel didn’t move. “With the line?”

“Without crossing it out again,” said Ben. “I’ll write something underneath. Something new. I don’t know what yet.”

“You’ll know,” said Daniel.

“How do you know?”

“Because you always know what you want to say. You just wait until there’s someone listening.”

* * *

“I was scared too,” said Daniel after a moment.

Ben turned to him.

“Of you,” said Daniel. “At the start. Not that you’d hate me. I knew you’d hate me, that was obvious. I was scared of something else.” He looked at the Kinneret. “I was scared that if I started loving the new family, I’d forget Mom. That if I laughed with Michal, if I called you my brother, it would be like saying she could be replaced. So I kept my distance. Half a metre. All the time.”

“Half a metre,” Ben repeated. He remembered. All summer. Daniel always sitting next to him, but at a distance.

“Then I realised,” said Daniel, “it doesn’t work like that. Love isn’t one chair that someone has to get up from so someone else can sit. It’s more like… like camp. There’s always another mattress.”

“You got that from Gili,” said Ben.

“Totally,” Daniel admitted.

Ben thought about it. “Would Naama have liked me?” he asked suddenly. Quietly. As if it were the most dangerous question in the world.

Daniel laughed. A real, surprised laugh, from his stomach. “She’d have driven you mad,” he said. “She’d have called you ‘sweetie,’ put you in a boat at six in the morning, talked to the boat, sung you the song, and made you shout ‘Olé!’ in the middle of a race. She’d have been crazy about you.” He stopped. The words hung in the air for a moment. “She’d have loved you very much, Ben. From day one. Even when you were yelling.”

Ben said nothing. But he didn’t move his head from Daniel’s shoulder.

* * *

The door behind them opened a crack.

Maya peeked out. She saw them both, close together on the top step, with the grey blanket and Ben’s head on Daniel’s shoulder. She didn’t say anything. She just smiled, a very small smile with shining eyes, and put two cups of hot chocolate down by the door.

Then she closed the door quietly and gave them the night.

* * *

“Wait,” said Daniel suddenly, standing up.

“Where are you going?” Ben half rose, in a small panic that came fast and went fast. Because he knew. He already knew.

“I’ll be back,” said Daniel. “Two minutes. Don’t move.”

And he ran. Ben watched him run in the dark along the path towards Pelican. And thought, very strangely, that this was the first time in his life someone had said “I’ll be back” and he wasn’t counting the seconds.

Daniel came back after two minutes. Exactly. With something in his hand. Something yellow and blue, folded.

The Maccabi blanket.

“It was on my bed,” said Daniel, panting. “The cabin’s completely wrecked, mattress on the floor, my bag torn open. And it was there, folded, on the bed. They didn’t touch it.” He shook it out. “They must have thought it was too old.”

“It is too old,” said Ben.

“It’s perfect,” said Daniel, and laid it round Ben’s shoulders, over the grey blanket, wrapping him like a very tired king.

Ben looked at the yellow and blue. At the small tea stain from that morning in the tent. At the frayed edges.

“It’s your blanket,” he said. “I gave it to you.”

“It’s our blanket,” said Daniel.

And Ben, on the cold steps of the sports hall, on the last night, with two blankets and a rope in his pocket and a brother beside him, put his head on Daniel’s shoulder again. And this time he didn’t lift it.

“My brother,” he said quietly. In a voice you could barely hear. Not to Roni. Not to Lihi. Not to anyone else. Straight to Daniel.

Daniel didn’t answer. He couldn’t. He just rested his chin on Ben’s head and looked at the stars, and the tears ran down quietly, one by one, into his brother’s hair.

From inside, through the door, Gili was playing “Little Sailor.” Softly. No words.

And outside, on the steps, nobody needed the words.

What Happens at Camp Chapter 93: Always - Like Likro - books to read online