For three seconds nobody in the dining room moved.
Then everybody moved at once. Benny leapt up and knocked over a plate. Shira ran to Room Seven. Noam ran to the gate. Zehava said “Oh, oh, oh” and put the cake knife in her apron pocket for no reason at all. And Noa stood up, pale, hand on the third button of her coat, saying nothing, because anyone who has worked for years as a nurse knows that in a fright the first thing you need is to breathe.
Mrs Cohen raised a hand. “Wait,” she said in her headmistress voice, and everyone stopped. “We are not running in all directions like hens. We search properly.” She looked round the table. “Who here knows how to search properly?”
And it turned out the answer was nobody. Because whenever anything went missing at Hilltop House, a spoon, a cockerel, a notebook, a cat, there was always Amy. Amy with her notebook. Amy saying “Facts first.” And now the thing that had gone missing was Amy herself.
“Maybe pirates took her,” Hutie suggested, trembling, hand on her forehead as if on stage.
“There aren’t any pirates on the hill,” said Benny. “There’s no sea.”
“Hill pirates, then,” said Hutie. “Dry pirates.”
Then a small voice came from the end of the table. “Me,” said Tom.
Everyone turned. Tom was standing on his chair so they could see him. He was seven, the smallest in Room Six, with a cake crumb on his nose because he’d tasted it by mistake before the candles. But his face was completely serious.
“I know how to search,” he said. “I’ve followed Amy on every case. Every one. I know what she does.” And he took a notebook out of his pocket. A small green one with a pencil tied on a string, which nobody knew he had. On the first page, in wobbly letters, it said: Tom’s Notebook. Assistant Detective. “She always says,” he said, “facts first. Ideas after.”
Mrs Cohen looked at him for a long moment. Then she nodded. “Go ahead, Detective Tom,” she said. “We’re listening.”
Tom climbed down, took a deep breath and did exactly what Amy does. He didn’t run. He stood still and thought. “Fact one,” he said, writing. “Amy’s not in her room. Shira checked. Fact two.” He ran to the coat hooks in the corridor and came back. “Her coat’s not on its hook. So she’s outside. And it’s cold outside, so she took a coat, because she’s clever.”
“Fact three,” said Noa suddenly. “Mozart. Mozart isn’t here either. Not since four.”
Tom wrote it down. Then he did something Amy had taught him a year ago, in the case of the spoon. He went to every door and checked. The front door was locked, as always. The kitchen door was shut, and Zehava had been there all day. But the back door, by the laundry, was only nearly shut. And on its step, in the dark, under Tom’s torch, lay something small and yellow.
A flower. A little yellow flower, the kind that grows only on the path to the top of the hill.
“Fact four,” whispered Tom, raising the torch. Ten metres away on the path was another flower. And another after it. Like dots on a map. Like the children in the forest with their breadcrumbs, except the birds hadn’t eaten them, because birds don’t eat flowers, according to Benny.
“She went up,” said Leo behind him. “To the top of the hill.”
“Not yet,” said Tom, in exactly Amy’s voice. “That’s still an idea. We have to check.”
So they went. Tom in front with the torch and notebook. Then Leo, Hutie, Benny, Maya with Falafel, Noa, and Mrs Cohen in her headmistress shoes, which were not hill shoes at all, and David at the back with two more torches, just in case. The path was steep and narrow, and the flowers kept appearing, and every time someone spotted one they shouted “Another!” and Tom wrote it down.
Then, halfway up, the flowers stopped.
The path split in two. One way went straight on towards the rocks. The other turned right into the little pine wood. And there was no flower on either. Tom stood at the fork, torch jumping from side to side, and felt for the first time what Amy feels in every case: everybody watching, waiting, and he didn’t know.
“Right,” said Benny. “There are hiding places in the wood.”
“Straight on,” said Hutie. “Straight on is more dramatic.”
“Left,” said someone at the back, and everyone looked round. It was David. “No,” he corrected himself. “There isn’t a left. Sorry. I got muddled. I’m a grown-up.”
Tom shut his eyes and thought what Amy would do. Amy would say: when the clues run out, look at what isn’t moving. He opened his eyes and shone the torch around, slowly. Rock. Bush. Another rock. And on the big flat rock beside the straight path sat two green eyes, glinting in the torchlight.
Mozart.
He sat quite still, tail wrapped round his feet, like a sentry. He looked at Tom. Then, slowly and deliberately, he looked up the straight path. And yawned.
“Fact five,” said Tom. “The cat is guarding the way.”
“That’s not a fact,” said Leo. “That’s a cat.”
“With Amy,” said Tom, “a cat is a fact too.”
So they went straight on. And at the top of the path, under a sky already fully dark with its first star, stood the tree. Tova’s oak. And on Avraham’s bench, curled up in her coat with her notebook on her knees, sat Amy.
She looked up when the torchlight reached her. She saw Tom, and the whole line of torches behind him, and didn’t understand. “What… how did you find me?”
“Flowers,” said Tom, panting. “And a coat. And a back door. And a cat.” He showed her the green notebook. “Facts first. Ideas after. Like you say.”
“And I knew it was a real case,” Benny added from behind, “because the cat didn’t get up when we passed. Cats only get up for food or for people they love. He didn’t, because he was already guarding someone.”
Amy looked at the notebook. At the wobbly letters. Assistant Detective. And something big and warm caught in her throat.
“And also,” said Tom, more quietly, “you said ‘not now’ to me. You’ve never said ‘not now’. So I knew something was wrong. A detective notices.”
“Why did you run away?” asked Maya. “There’s a party!”
“Because of the party,” said Amy quietly. “My party. My goodbye. I saw the book. And I… haven’t decided yet. And everyone’s already decided for me.”
Silence. Then Leo sat down beside her on the bench and cleaned his glasses, as he always does before an explanation. “Amy,” he said. “It’s not your party. It’s mine.”
Amy stared at him.
“Yael and Uri are coming tonight,” said Leo. “For Shabbat. The first time as a family. That’s what Mrs Cohen was saying on the phone. They wanted to keep it from me, not from you. I found out, because I always find out, and then I promised to pretend I didn’t know. The green-and-orange bracelets are for me and them. Green like the sea, orange like the lighthouse.”
“And the book?” whispered Amy.
“The book,” said Tom, “was my idea.” He went red in the dark. “I thought if you go, you’ll need us. And if you stay, you’ll need it anyway. You didn’t see the last page.”
He opened the blue book, which he’d carried all the way under his arm. On the last page, in Tom’s drawing, were two houses. A big one on a hill with sunflowers on the roof, and a small one below with a lemon tree. Between them ran a path, and on the path, in the middle, a girl with two plaits. Underneath, in wobbly letters: If you stay, it’s a book for staying. If you go, it’s a book for coming back.
Amy cried. Not much. Just a bit. And this time it was the good kind.
Then came a long puffing from the path, and headmistress shoes on stones, and Mrs Cohen arrived. She sat down on Amy’s other side without asking, put her bag on her knees and breathed. “Tova,” she said, “should have planted this tree a bit lower down.”
When she had her breath back, she said, “Amy. Hilltop House isn’t a place you leave. It’s a place that comes with you. Like the song. Tova wrote it for exactly that, so whoever goes can take it with them.” She looked down at the lit windows. “And, just so you know, Friday supper at Hilltop House starts seven minutes after the candles. Every week. And there’s a chair there. Yours. Whatever you decide.”
Amy looked at the house. Then the other way, down at the town. Then at Noa, standing quietly at the back with Mozart in her arms, not saying a word, because she had promised time. Amy opened her notebook and looked at the two words with the line between them. Stay. Go.
She rubbed out the line. And in its place she wrote one small word: And.
“Yes,” she said to Noa. “I’d like to. To the house with the lemon tree. And Fridays here.”
Noa said nothing. She just knelt, cat and all, and held her. Mozart, squashed in the middle, growled crossly, then simply purred.
They went down the hill together in a long line of torches, singing the Hilltop Song, Hutie loudest of all. In the dining room Yael and Uri Barak were waiting by the cake. And the party, which started an hour and seven minutes late, was the best in the history of Hilltop House, for two children who were leaving and yet not really leaving.
Zehava cut the cake and explained, very seriously, that each tier had a job. “The bottom one’s for Leo, for the lemon tree by the lighthouse. The middle one’s for Amy and Noa, for the lemon tree in town. And the top one,” she raised the knife, “is for everyone who stays here and eats cake. That is, everyone.” Tom got two slices, being the detective who solved the case, and nobody argued.
Later, after the third round of singing, Mrs Cohen stood, tapped her glass with a spoon and said just one sentence. “Today,” she said, “Hilltop House gained another detective.” She pointed at Tom. The whole dining room clapped, and Tom went so red his ears turned the colour of Kuku.
That night Amy wrote: Case No. 48: Everybody’s Secret. Solved. Who solved it: Detective Tom. How: facts, flowers and a cat. What I learnt: sometimes you don’t have to choose between here and there. A path is enough.
And underneath, small, she added one more line. Leo needs a present. A detective’s present. Tomorrow.